Acupuncture is a procedure in which fine needles are inserted into an
individual at discrete points and then manipulated, with the intent of
relieving pain. Since its development in China around 2,000 B.C.,
acupuncture has become worldwide in its practice1. Although Western
medicine has treated acupuncture with considerable skepticism2, a
broader worldwide population has granted it acceptance. For instance,
the World Health Organization endorses acupuncture for at least two
dozen conditions3 and the US National Institutes of Health issued a
consensus statement proposing acupuncture as a therapeutic intervention
for complementary medicine. Perhaps most tellingly, the U.S. Internal
Revenue Service approved acupuncture as a deductible medical expense in
1973.
Although the analgesic effect of acupuncture is well documented, little
is understood about its biological basis. Insertion of the acupuncture
needles in itself is not sufficient to relieve pain4. An acupuncture
session typically lasts for 30 min, during which the needles are
intermittently rotated, electrically stimulated or, in some cases,
heated. The pain threshold is reported to slowly increase and to outlast
the treatment4. The primary mechanism implicated in the
anti-nociceptive effect of acupuncture involves release of opioid
peptides in the CNS in response to the long-lasting activation of
ascending sensory tracks during the intermittent stimulation4–6.
However, a centrally acting agent cannot explain why acupuncture is
conventionally applied in close proximity to the locus of pain and why
the analgesic effects of acupuncture are restricted to the ipsilateral
side7,8.
RESULTS
Acupuncture triggers adenosine and ATP metabolites release
ATP is released in response to either mechanical and electrical
stimulation or heat. Once released, ATP acts as a transmitter that binds
to purinergic receptors, including P2X and P2Y receptors9,10. ATP
cannot be transported back into the cell but is rapidly degraded to
adenosine by several ectonucleotidases before re-uptake10. Thus,
adenosine acts as an analgesic agent that suppresses pain through
Gi-coupled A1-adenosine receptors11–13. To determine whether adenosine
is involved in the anti-nociceptive effects of acupuncture, we first
asked whether the extracellular concentration of adenosine increases
during acupuncture.
We collected samples of interstitial fluid by a microdialysis probe
implanted in the tibialis anterior muscle/subcutis of adult mice at a
distance of 0.4–0.6 mm from the ‘Zusanli point’, which is located 3–4 mm below and 1–2 mm lateral for the midline of the knee4. Adenine
nucleotides and adenosine were quantified using high-performance liquid
chromatography (HPLC) with ultraviolet absorbance before, during and
after acupuncture (Fig. 1a)14,15. At baseline, the concentrations of
ATP, ADP, AMP and adenosine were in the low nanomolar range (Fig. 1b),
consistent with previous reports16,17. Acupuncture applied by gentle
manual rotation of the acupuncture needle every 5 min for a total of 30
min sharply increased the extracellular concentrations of all purines
detected (Fig. 1b). Adenosine concentration increased ~24-fold (253.5 ±
81.1 nM from a baseline of 10.6 ± 6.7 nM) during the 30-min
acupuncture session (Fig. 1c). The extracellular concentration of ATP
returned to baseline after acupuncture, whereas adenosine, AMP and ADP
remained significantly elevated (adenosine and AMP, P < 0.01; ADP, P
< 0.05, paired t test compared to 0 min) at 60 min (Fig. 1c).
Notably, previous studies have shown that deep brain stimulation is also
associated with a severalfold increase in extracellular ATP and
adenosine. Similar to electroacupuncture and transcutaneous electrical
nerve stimulation, deep brain stimulation delivers electrical
stimulation that triggers an increase in extracellular adenosine
concentration18.
1Center for Translational Neuromedicine, University of Rochester Medical
Center, Rochester, New York, USA. 2Department of Neurology, Boston
University School of Medicine, Boston, Massachusetts, USA. 3National
Institute of Diabetes and Digestive and Kidney Diseases, US National
Institutes of Health, Bethesda, Maryland, USA. 4These authors
contributed equally to this work. Correspondence should be addressed to
M.N. (nedergaard@urmc.rochester.edu).
Received 16 March; accepted 27 April; published online 30 May 2010;
doi:10.1038/nn.2562
Adenosine A1 receptors mediate local anti-nociceptive effects of
acupuncture
Nanna Goldman1,4, Michael Chen1,4, Takumi Fujita1,4, Qiwu Xu1, Weiguo
Peng1, Wei Liu1, Tina K Jensen1,
Yong Pei1, Fushun Wang1, Xiaoning Han1, Jiang-Fan Chen2, Jurgen
Schnermann3, Takahiro Takano1,
Lane Bekar1, Kim Tieu1 & Maiken Nedergaard1
Acupuncture's painkilling secret revealed: it's all in the twist
action
Acupuncture 'meridians' match main nerve
pathways, scientists believe. Photograph: Getty Images/Getty
Ever since Chinese doctors first poked their patients with sharp
objects 4,000 years ago, and charged them for the pleasure, acupuncture
has been shrouded in mystery.
Tradition has it that the procedure
works by improving the flow of "qi" along invisible energy channels
called meridians, but research published today points to a less mystical
explanation for the painkilling claims of acupuncture.
The
answer, according to a team of scientists in New York, follows an
extraordinary study in which researchers gave regular acupuncture
sessions to mice with sore paws.
After each half-hour session the
mice felt less discomfort in their paws because the needles triggered
the release of a natural painkiller, the researchers say. The needles
caused tissue damage that stimulated cells to produce adenosine, an
anti-inflammatory chemical, that was effective for up to an hour after
the therapy was over.
Modern acupuncture involves inserting fine
needles into the skin at specific points around the body. The needles
are pushed in a few centimetres, and then heated, twisted or even
electrified to produce their claimed medical effects.
Acupuncture
has spread around the world since originating in China but conventional
western medicine has remained steadfastly sceptical. Although there is
now good evidence that acupuncture can relieve pain, many of the other
health benefits acupuncturists claim are on shakier ground.
The
latest research gives doctors a sound explanation of how sticking
needles into the skin can alleviate, rather than exacerbate, pain. The
discovery will challenge the view , widely held among scientists, that
any benefits a patient feels after acupuncture are due purely to the
placebo effect.
"The view that acupuncture has little benefit
beyond the placebo effect has really hampered research into the
technique," said Maiken Nedergaard, a neuroscientist at the University
of Rochester medical centre in New York state, who led the study.
"Some
people think any work in this area is junk research, but I think that's
wrong. I was really surprised at the arrogance of some of my
colleagues. We can benefit from what has been learned over many
thousands of years," Nedergaard said.
"I believe we've found the
main mechanism by which acupuncture relieves pain. Adenosine is a very
potent anti-inflammatory compound and most chronic pain is caused by
inflammation."
The scientists gave each mouse a sore paw by
injecting it with an inflammatory chemical. Half of the mice lacked a
gene that is needed to make adenosine receptors, which are found on
major nerves.
The therapy session involved inserting a fine needle
into an acupuncture point in the knee above each mouse's sore foot. In
keeping with traditional practice, the needles were rotated periodically
throughout the half-hour session.
To measure how effective the
acupuncture was, the researchers recorded how quickly each mouse pulled
its sore paw away from a small bristly brush. The more pain the mice
were in, the faster they pulled away.
Writing in the journal,
Nature Neuroscience, Nedergaard's team describe how acupuncture reduced
pain by two-thirds in normal mice, but had no effect on the discomfort
of mice that lacked the adenosine receptor gene. Without adenosine
receptors, the mice were unable to respond to the adenosine released
when cells were damaged by acupuncture needles.
Acupuncture had no
effect in either group of mice if the needles were not rotated,
suggesting that the tissues had to be physically damaged to release
adenosine.
Nedergaard said that twisting the needles seems to
cause enough damage to make cells release the painkilling chemical. This
is then picked up by adenosine receptors on nearby nerves, which react
by damping down pain. Further tests on the mice revealed that levels of
adenosine surged 24-fold in the tissues around the acupuncture needles
during and immediately after each session.
One of the longstanding
mysteries surrounding acupuncture is why the technique only seems to
alleviate pain if needles are inserted at specific points. Nedergaard
believes that most of these acupuncture points are along major nerve
tracks, and as such are parts of the body that have plenty of adenosine
receptors.
In a final experiment, Nedergaard's team injected mice
with a cancer drug that made it harder to remove adenosine from their
tissues. The drug, called deoxycoformycin, boosted the effects of
acupuncture dramatically, more than tripling how long the pain relief
lasted.
"There is an attitude among some researchers that studying
alternative medicine is unfashionable," said Nedergaard. "Because it
has not been understood completely, many people have remained
sceptical."
Although the study explains how acupuncture can
alleviate pain, it sheds no light on the other health benefits that some
practitioners believe the procedure can achieve.
Josephine
Briggs, the director of the national centre for complementary and
alternative medicine at the US National Institutes of Health, said:
"It's clear that acupuncture may activate a number of different
mechanisms … It's an interesting contribution to our growing
understanding of the complex intervention which is acupuncture."
weeks pregnant, and
randomly assigned 52 to receive acupuncture specifically designed
for
depressive symptoms, 49 to regular acupuncture and 49 to Swedish
massage.
Each woman received 12 sessions of 25 minutes each;
those given acupuncture did not
know which type they were getting. (In
the depression-specific treatment, needles are
inserted at body points
that are said to correspond to symptoms like anxiety, withdrawal
and apathy.)
After
eight weeks, almost two-thirds of the women who had depression-specific
acupuncture experienced
a reduction in at least 50 percent of their
symptoms, compared with just under half of the women treated with
either
massage or regular acupuncture.
There was no significant
difference in the rates of complete remission — about a third in each
group. The findings appear in the March issue of Obstetrics &
Gynecology.
The lead author, Rachel Manber, a professor of psychiatry
and behavioral sciences at Stanford, said the results suggested that
some symptoms of depression during pregnancy might be related to
physical discomfort that is alleviated by acupuncture.
Still,
the results were striking, she said, adding, “It’s quite remarkable,
especially since the prevalence of depression is highest in the third
trimester of pregnancy, so it goes against the course of how you would
expect depression to go.”
Obstetrics & Gynecology: March 2010 - Volume 115 - Issue 3 - pp
511-520, doi: 10.1097/AOG.0b013e3181cc0816, Original Research
Acupuncture for Depression During Pregnancy: A Randomized Controlled Trial
Acupuncture HELPS Brain's Ability To Regulate Pain, UM Study Shows
ScienceDaily (Aug. 11, 2009) — Acupuncture has been
used in East-Asian medicine for thousands of years to treat pain, possibly by
activating the body's natural painkillers. But how it works at the cellular
level is largely unknown.
Using brain imaging, a University of Michigan study provides novel evidence
that traditional Chinese acupuncture affects the brain's long-term ability to
regulate pain.
The results appear online ahead of print in the September Journal of
NeuroImage.
In the study, researchers at the U-M Chronic Pain and Fatigue Research
Center showed acupuncture increased the binding availability of mu-opoid
receptors (MOR) in regions of the brain that process and dampen pain signals –
specifically the cingulate, insula, caudate, thalamus and amygdala.
Opioid painkillers, such as morphine, codeine and other medications, are
thought to work by binding to these opioid receptors in the brain and spinal
cord.
"The increased binding availability of these receptors was associated
with reductions in pain," says Richard E. Harris, Ph.D., researcher at the
U-M Chronic Pain and Fatigue Research Center and a research assistant professor
of anesthesiology at the U-M Medical School.
One implication of this research is that patients with chronic pain treated
with acupuncture might be more responsive to opioid medications since the
receptors seem to have more binding availability, Harris says.
These findings could spur a new direction in the field of acupuncture
research following recent controversy over large studies showing that sham
acupuncture is as effective as real acupuncture in reducing chronic pain.
"Interestingly both acupuncture and sham acupuncture groups had similar
reductions in clinical pain," Harris says. "But the mechanisms
leading to pain relief are distinctly different."
The study participants included 20 women who had been diagnosed with
fibromyalgia, a chronic pain condition, for at least a year, and experienced
pain at least 50 percent of the time. During the study they agreed not to take
any new medications for their fibromyalgia pain.
Patients had position emission tomography, or PET, scans of the brain during
the first treatment and then repeated a month later after the eighth treatment.
Additional authors were Jon-Kar Zubieta, M.D., Ph.D., David J. Scott, Vitaly
Napadow, Richard H. Gracely, Ph.D, Daniel J. Clauw, M.D.
Funding was provided by the Department of Army, and the National Institutes
of Health.
1.Richard E. Harris, Jon-Kar Zubieta, David J. Scott,
Vitaly Napadow, Richard H. Gracely, Daniel J. Clauw. Traditional
Chinese acupuncture and placebo (sham) acupuncture are differentiated by their
effects on μ-opioid receptors (MORs). Journal of NeuroImage,
2009; 47 (3): 1077-1085 DOI: 10.1016/j.neuroimage.2009.05.083
Study Maps Effects of Acupuncture on the Brain
ScienceDaily (Feb. 5, 2010) — Important new research
about the effects of acupuncture on the brain may provide an understanding of
the complex mechanisms of acupuncture and could lead to a wider acceptability
of the treatment.
The study, by researchers at the University of York and the Hull York
Medical School published in Brain Research, indicates that acupuncture
has a significant effect on specific neural structures. When a patient receives
acupuncture treatment, a sensation called deqi can be obtained; scientific
analysis shows that this deactivates areas within the brain that are associated
with the processing of pain.
Dr Hugh MacPherson, of the Complementary Medicine Research Group in the
University's Department of Health Sciences, says: "These results provide
objective scientific evidence that acupuncture has specific effects within the
brain which hopefully will lead to a better understanding of how acupuncture
works."
Neuroscientist Dr Aziz Asghar, of the York Neuroimaging Centre and the Hull
York Medical School, adds: "The results are fascinating. Whether such
brain deactivations constitute a mechanism which underlies or contributes to
the therapeutic effect of acupuncture is an intriguing possibility which
requires further research."
Last summer, following research conducted in York, acupuncture was
recommended for the first time by the National Institute for Health and
Clinical Excellence (NICE) as a treatment option for NHS patients with lower
back pain. NICE guidelines now state that GPs should 'consider offering a
course of acupuncture comprising a maximum of 10 sessions over a period of up
to 12 weeks' for patients with this common condition.
Current clinical trials at the University of York are investigating the
effectiveness and cost-effectiveness of acupuncture for Irritable Bowel
Syndrome (IBS) and for depression. Recent studies in the US have also shown
that acupuncture can be an effective treatment for migraines and osteoarthritis
of the knee.
The York team believe that the new research could help to clear the way for
acupuncture to be more broadly accepted as a treatment option on the NHS for a
number of medical conditions.
1.Asghar et al. Acupuncture needling sensation:
The neural correlates of deqi using fMRI. Brain Research,
2010; 1315111 DOI: 10.1016/j.brainres.2009.12.019
Acupuncture Reduces Side Effects Of Breast Cancer Treatment As Much As
Conventional Drug Therapy, Study Suggests
ScienceDaily (Sep. 23, 2008) — Acupuncture is as
effective and longer-lasting in managing the common debilitating side effects
of hot flashes, night sweats, and excessive sweating (vasomotor symptoms)
associated with breast cancer treatment and has no treatment side effects
compared to conventional drug therapy, according to a first-of-its-kind study
presented September 24, 2008, at the American Society for Therapeutic Radiology
and Oncology's 50th Annual Meeting in Boston.
Findings also show there were additional benefits to acupuncture treatment
for breast cancer patients, such as an increased sense of well being, more
energy, and in some cases, a higher sex drive, that were not experienced in
those patients who underwent drug treatment for their hot flashes.
"Our study shows that physicians and patients have an additional
therapy for something that affects the majority of breast cancer survivors and
actually has benefits, as opposed to more side effects. The effect is more
durable than a drug commonly used to treat these vasomotor symptoms and,
ultimately, is more cost-effective for insurance companies," Eleanor
Walker, M.D., lead author of the study and a radiation oncologist at the Henry
Ford Hospital Department of Radiation Oncology in Detroit, said.
The reduction in hot flashes lasted longer for those breast cancer patients
after completing their acupuncture treatment, compared to patients after
stopping their drug therapy plan.
Eighty percent of women treated for breast cancer suffer from hot flashes
after being treated with chemotherapy and/or anti-estrogen hormones, such as
Tamoxifen and Arimidex. Although hormone replacement therapy is typically used
to relieve these symptoms, breast cancer patients cannot use this therapy
because it may increase the risk of the cancer coming back.
As a treatment alternative, patients are generally treated with steroids
and/or antidepressant drugs. These drugs, however, have additional side
effects, such as weight gain, nausea, constipation and fatigue. The
antidepressant, venlafaxine (Effexor), a selective serotonin reuptake
inhibitor, is one of the most common drugs used to treat these hot flashes.
However, many women decide against this treatment choice because of potential
side effects, including decreased libido, insomnia, dizziness and nausea, or
because they simply do not want to take any more medications.
The randomized clinical trial compared acupuncture treatment to venlafixine
for 12 weeks to find out if acupuncture reduced vasomotor symptoms in breast
cancer patients receiving hormonal therapy and produced fewer side effects than
venlafaxine. The study involved 47 breast cancer patients who received either
Tamoxifen or Arimidex and had at least 14 hot flashes per week. Results show
that acupuncture reduces hot flashes as effectively as venlafaxine, with no
side effects, and also provides additional health benefits to patients.
The abstract is entitled, "Acupuncture for the Treatment of Vasomotor
Symptoms in Breast Cancer Patients Receiving Hormone Suppression
Treatment."
Acupuncture Cuts Tension Headache Rates By Almost Half
ScienceDaily (Aug. 1, 2005) — Acupuncture is an
effective treatment for tension headache, cutting rates for sufferers by almost
half, shows a study on bmj.com this week.
And a minimal acupuncture course works almost as well as traditional Chinese
therapy, say the researchers.
In a randomised controlled trial - the gold standard of clinical trials -
researchers in Germany divided 270 patients with a similar severity of tension
headache into three groups.
Over an eight week period one set were treated with traditional acupuncture,
one with minimal acupuncture (needles inserted only superficially into the
skin, at non-acupuncture points), and one group had neither treatment
('control' group).
Those receiving traditional acupuncture care saw their headache rates drop
by almost half - suffering 7 days less headaches over the four weeks following
the treatment. Those receiving minimal acupuncture had 6.6 less days of
headaches. While the control group experienced 1.5 less days of headaches - a
drop of just a tenth.
Improvements to headache rates continued for months after the acupuncture
treatment, though they began to rise slightly as time went on.
Those in the 'no treatment' group were subsequently given acupuncture for
eight weeks after the main study period. These patients also improved
significantly after the treatment, though not to the same level as those given
acupuncture initially.
Of the 195 patients in the acupuncture groups, 37 reported some side effects
- the most common being dizziness, other headaches and bruising.
Such a small difference in results between traditional and minimal acupuncture
treatments seems to indicate that the location of acupuncture points and other
aspects of traditional Chinese acupuncture do not make a major difference for
tension headache, say the authors.
Acupuncture treatments are sometimes associated with strong placebo effects,
caution the authors. But these findings show that acupuncture produces just as
good improvements for tension headache sufferers as treatments already
accepted, they conclude.
Acupuncture May Relieve Joint Pain Caused by Some Breast Cancer Treatments
ScienceDaily (Mar. 5, 2010) — A new study, led by
researchers at the Herbert Irving Comprehensive Cancer Center at
NewYork-Presbyterian Hospital/Columbia University Medical Center, demonstrates
that acupuncture may be an effective therapy for joint pain and stiffness in
breast cancer patients who are being treated with commonly used hormonal
therapies.
Results were published in the Journal of Clinical Oncology.
Joint pain and stiffness are common side effects of aromatase inhibitor
therapy, in which the synthesis of estrogen is blocked. The therapy, which is a
common and effective treatment for early-stage, hormone-receptor-positive
breast cancer in post-menopausal women, has been shown in previous research to
cause some joint pain and stiffness in half of women being treated.
"Since aromatase inhibitors have become an increasingly popular
treatment option for some breast cancer patients, we aimed to find a non-drug
option to manage the joint issues they often create, thereby improving quality
of life and reducing the likelihood that patients would discontinue this
potentially life-saving treatment," said Dawn Hershman, M.D, M.S., senior
author of the paper, and co-director of the breast cancer program at the
Herbert Irving Comprehensive Cancer Center at NewYork-Presbyterian Hospital/Columbia
University Medical Center, and an assistant professor of medicine
(hematology/oncology) and epidemiology at Columbia University Medical Center.
To explore the effects of acupuncture on aromatase inhibitor-associated
joint pain, the research team randomly assigned 43 women to receive either true
acupuncture or sham acupuncture twice a week for six weeks. Sham acupuncture,
which was used to control for a potential placebo effect, involved superficial
needle insertion at body points not recognized as true acupuncture points. All
participants were receiving an aromatase inhibitor for early breast cancer, and
all had reported musculoskeletal pain.
Among the women treated with true acupuncture, findings demonstrated that
they experienced significant improvement in joint pain and stiffness over the
course of the study. Pain severity declined, and overall physical well-being
improved. Additionally, 20 percent of the patients who had reported taking pain
relief medications reported that they no longer needed to take these
medications following acupuncture treatment. No such improvements were reported
by the women who were treated with the sham acupuncture.
"This study suggests that acupuncture may help women manage the joint
pain and stiffness that can accompany aromatase inhibitor treatment," said
Katherine D. Crew, M.D., M.S., first author of the paper, and the Florence
Irving Assistant Professor of Medicine (hematology/oncology) and Epidemiology
at Columbia University Medical Center and a hematological oncologist at NewYork-Presbyterian
Hospital/Columbia University Medical Center. "To our knowledge, this is
the first randomized, placebo-controlled trial establishing that acupuncture
may be an effective method to relieve joint problems caused by these
medications. However, results still need to be confirmed in larger, multicenter
studies."
1.Katherine D. Crew, Jillian L. Capodice, Heather
Greenlee, Lois Brafman, Deborah Fuentes, Danielle Awad, Wei Yann Tsai, and Dawn
L. Hershman. Randomized, Blinded, Sham-Controlled Trial of Acupuncture
for the Management of Aromatase Inhibitor-Associated Joint Symptoms in Women
With Early-Stage Breast Cancer. Journal of Clinical Oncology,
2010; 28 (7): 1154 DOI: 10.1200/JCO.2009.23.4708
ACUPUNCTURE There is growing scientific evidence that acupuncture, a pillar of Chinese medicine, can relieve many kinds of pain, but there's no clear agreement about how it works. That was underscored by a German study of migraines: it found that inserting needles at various acupuncture points in the body relieved pain just as effectively as inserting them in the points that are supposed to affect migraines. Both therapies cut the number of episodes more than 50% over a 12-week period; a control group that did not receive either treatment continued to suffer as before.
Acupuncture as a therapeutic intervention is widely practiced in the United States. There have been many studies of its potential usefulness. However, many of these studies provide equivocal results because of design, sample size, and other factors. The issue is further complicated by inherent difficulties in the use of appropriate controls, such as placebo and sham acupuncture groups.
However, promising results have emerged, for example, efficacy of acupuncture in adult post-operative and chemotherapy nausea and vomiting and in post-operative dental pain. There are other situations such as addiction, stroke rehabilitation, headache, menstrual cramps, tennis elbow, fibromyalgia, myofascial pain, osteoarthritis, low back pain, carpal tunnel syndrome, and asthma for which acupuncture may be useful as an adjunct treatment or an acceptable alternative or be included in a comprehensive management program. Further research is likely to uncover additional areas where acupuncture interventions will be useful.
Findings from basic research have begun to elucidate the mechanisms of action of acupuncture, including the release of opioids and other peptides in the central nervous system and the periphery and changes in neuroendocrine function. Although much needs to be accomplished, the emergence of plausible mechanisms for the therapeutic effects of acupuncture is encouraging.
The introduction of acupuncture into the choice of treatment modalities readily available to the public is in its early stages. Issues of training, licensure, and reimbursement remain to be clarified. There is sufficient evidence, however, of its potential value to conventional medicine to encourage further studies.
There is sufficient evidence of acupuncture's value to expand its use into conventional medicine and to encourage further studies of its physiology and clinical value.
Study of Mummified Body Raises Questions about Practice's Origin
By Editorial Staff
In 1991, the scientific world was rocked by the discovery of Otzi, a 5,000-year-old mummified man found in the mountains along the border between Austria and Italy. Named after the Otz valley in which it was discovered, the mummy's body was remarkably well preserved, as were most of his clothing, tools and weapons.
For the past nine years, scientists have examined the mummy's remains thoroughly, learning much about the everyday life of ancient Europeans. One of the most remarkable discoveries was a complicated system of bluish-black tattoos running along Otzi's back, right knee and left ankle.
While most tattoos are ornamental in nature, the tattoos found on Otzi's body were in the form of simple stripes or crosses. They were also found in places that would normally be covered by hair or clothing. Since such non-ornamental tattoos had previously been found in similar locations on mummies in Siberia and South America, some researchers speculated that the lines on Otzi's body were of therapeutic importance.
What, if any, significance did the ice man's tattoos have beyond ornamentation? A group of scientists from the University of Graz in Austria attempted to answer that question by theorizing a possible relationship between the tattoos and traditional acupuncture points. Their findings, first published in The Lancet in 1999 and updated in Discover magazine earlier this year,1,2 purport to show that acupuncture or a system of healing quite similar to it may have been in use in central Europe more than 2,000 years earlier than previously believed.
The research team, led by Drs. Leopold Dorfer and Max Moser, first calculated the mummy's cun by measuring its femur, tibia and radius. They then converted the measurements of the tattoos to cun and overlaid the locations of the tattoos to topographical representations of Chinese acupuncture points.
Experts from three acupuncture societies then examined the locations of the tattoos. In their opinion, nine tattoos could be identified as being located directly on, or within six millimeters of, traditional acupuncture points. Two more were located on an acupuncture meridian. One tattoo was used as a local point. The remaining three tattoos were situated between 6-13mm from the closest acupuncture point.
Table I: Location of tattoo groups on the Tyrolean ice man ("Otzi") and their relation to classical acupuncture points.
Tattoo location and shape
Acunpuncture point
Distance between tattoo & acupuncture point (mm)
Left back
Upper four lines Upper three lines Lower three lines Lower four lines
UB21 UB22 UB23 UB25
4 3 0 0
Right back
Four lines
UB24
13
Right leg
Cross on knee, medial Three lines, medial Three lines, frontal Upper three lines, lateral Two lines, lateral Lower three lines, lateral
Li8 Ki7, SP6 Local pt between GB40 and ST41 On GB meridan GB37, dorsal to fibula GB38, dorsal to fibula
0 0 N/A N/A 7 6
Left leg
Seven lines, dorsal Three lines, dorsal One line dorsal Dorsal cross at lateral malleolus
Ub56 On UB, Between UB58 and UB59 UB59 UB60
2 N/A 0 4
X-rays of the ice man's body revealed evidence of arthritis in the hip joints, knees, ankles and lumbar spine. Nine of the mummy's 15 tattoos are located on the urinary bladder meridian, a meridian commonly associated with treating back pain. In fact, one of the mummy's two cross-shaped tattoos is located near the left ankle on point UB60, which is considered by several texts a "master point for back pain."3-5
"The fact that not randomly selected points, but rather corresponding groups of points were marked by tattoos, seems especially intriguing," the researchers noted. "From an acupuncturist's viewpoint, the combination of points selected represents a meaningful therapeutic regimen."
Forensic analysis of the mummy also revealed that his intestines were filled with whipworm eggs, which can cause severe abdominal pain. Five other tattoos located on the body corresponded with points located on the gall bladder, spleen and liver meridians points that are traditionally used to treat stomach disorders.
"Taken together," the scientists added, "the tattoos could be viewed as a medical report from the stone age, or possibly as a guide to self-treatment marking where to puncture when pains occur."
Admittedly, not all of the tattoos matched up precisely with known acupuncture sites; one tattoo, in fact, was located more than half an inch from the nearest acupuncture point. The scientists theorized that these differences in location "might be explained by twisting of the Iceman's skin relative to underlying structures that may have occurred during 5,000 years in the ice." They also acknowledged that some tattoos "are partly shifted today out of symmetry according to their location on the twisted body."
Despite these small variations, the discovery of therapeutic tattoos on a mummy who died more than 2,000 years before the appearance of acupuncture as it is known today raises some interesting questions as to where this form of care originated and how long it has been practiced.
"The locations of the tattoos are similar to points used for specific disease states in the traditional Chinese and modern acupuncture treatment," the scientists concluded. "É This raises the possibility of acupuncture having originated in the Eurasian continent at least 2000 years earlier than previously recognized."
"At the time when Otzi was around, I'm sure that many shamanistic cultures worldwide might have practiced it," added Dr. Moser. "But only the Chinese formalized it and saved it into modern times."
References
Dorfer L, et al. A medical report from the stone age? Lancet Sep 18, 1999;354:1023-5.
Glausiusz J. The ice man healeth. Discover February 2000.
Essentials of Chinese Acupuncture. Compiled by Beijing, Shanghai and Nanjing College of TCM. Beijing: Foreign Language Press, 1980.
O'Connor J, Bansky D (eds.) Acupuncture: A Comprehensive Text. Seatle: Eastlan, 1996.
Maciocia G. The Foundations of Chinese Medicine. A Comprehensive Text for Acupuncturists and Herbalists. New York: Churchill Livingstone, 1989.
Micro-Acupuncture Systems As Fractals Of The Human Body Vadim Bouevitch, MD
ABSTRACT Microacupuncture
systems may be based on the principle of fractalization found in nature
(living and non-living), including the wave-like nature of acupuncture
channels. Such a theory accommodates the perspective of physics as well
as Traditional Chinese Medicine concepts of meridians, microacupuncture
systems, acupuncture points, Qi energy, pathogenic factors, etc. The
number of projections of microacupuncture systems onto the skin surface
and mucous membranes is potentially unlimited. The need exists for
scientific exploration and elaboration of the physiologic mechanisms
involved in microsystems to gauge treatment effects. KEY WORDS Acupuncture, Microacupuncture Systems, Fractal, Su Jok, Embryo Microsystems Formation, Yamamoto New Scalp Acupuncture
INTRODUCTION A
characteristic feature of modern acupuncture is the rapid development
of the doctrine of microacupuncture systems. A variety of microsystems
is in use: auriculotherapy, su jok therapy, ECIWO (embryo containing
the information of the whole organism) therapy, oral acupuncture,
iridodiagnostics, nasal therapy, different modifications of scalp
therapy (including Yamamoto New Scalp Acupuncture [YNSA]), vaginal
acupuncture, clavicle needle injection, and more.
These systems
are united by one general property; each is a projection of all parts
of the body and its internal organs onto a limited section of the skin,
mucous membrane, and periosteum. The organs are extrapolated not only
morphologically but also functionally. It is impossible to explain such
a reflection on so varied and removed surfaces simply by means of
neurohormonal connections. Nevertheless, the clinical efficacy of the
microsystems is irrefutable; one of the modern theories of the
influence of acupuncture pertains to the fractal-field model of the
structure of the organism. This accounts precisely for the appearance
and structure of microacupuncture systems and their activity.
The Fractal Model In
the field of nonlinear equations and complex numbers, Benoit Mandelbrot
is the originator of fractal geometry.1 Mandelbrot's set (Z [Z2-C]),
solved for Z and C, provides particular parameters that can be
represented pictorially via computer graphics. This visual display
illustrates the sheer variety of forms that arise, coupled with the
self-similarity of the figures. This quality of self-similarity is
independent of size or scale.1 The very peculiarity is in the primary
(mother) figure giving rise to smaller figures, which are still similar
in form and content (Figure 1). This self-similarity is mathematically
endless in principle, but the real size of the smallest figure is
necessarily restricted by atom size. Apart from the principle of
self-organization, one can see the dialectical unity of order and chaos
within the same process. The central symmetrical figure at the
beginning of the process gradually turns into the chaotic "fractal
dust" on the periphery.
Recently, the fractalization
(self-similarity) principle has been recognized as the basic principle
behind nature's self-organization. This is illustrated aptly by the
classic irregular coastline viewed on different scales (e.g., 1:100 m,
1:100 km) whereby the shape remains constant, irrespective of the scale
of measurement. Similarly, this pattern can be noted in the branching
of a tree or in the divisions in the veins of a leaf.
Many
fractal-like structures have also been discovered in the human
organism. Certainly, they are not as identical as mathematical sets,
but the principle of fractalization is nevertheless observed in the
bronchial dichotic division of the 1st, 2nd, 3rd, 4th, and 5th and
additional levels (Figure 2). This also occurs in the branching of
blood vessels and nerves, and in intestinal villi and microvilli.
In
addition to structural fractals, functional fractals exist in
organisms. For example, for electrocardiographic (ECG) Holter
monitoring data, the graph that depicts the variations in the healthy
heart rhythm over a 24-hour period is identical to the R-R interval on
ECG for a 1-minute period (Figure 3).
Wave Theory of Meridians Many
attempts have been made to explain the nature of the classic
acupuncture meridians. To date, there are approximately 20 theories,
none of which account for microsystems. A more recent interpretation is
the fractal-field model of the structure of the organism, which
describes the meridians as the final wave cycle in the coherent field
of an organism with projections onto the body surface at the level of
the acupuncture points. According to this concept, the main function of
the meridians is to provide an informational exchange between an
organism (microspace) and its environment (macrospace). The goal of
this exchange is the adaptation of an organism to the changeable
conditions of its environment.2
Fractal electromagnetic (or
torsion) fields, which transmit information without transferring
energy, probably play a part in the material substratum which
facilitates the exchange.3 The advantage of this model is that it
allows the modern view of the structure of matter to be united with the
ancient East's conception of acupuncture to prove the physical reality
of such concepts as meridians, Qi energy, internal and external
pathogens, and more.
Thus, the channels of acupuncture are wave
formations that transmit information about the internal environment of
an organism and facilitate the exchange of this information with the
external environment via the acupuncture points. Indeed, the meridian
system is an informational cast of the human body on the wave level. In
addition, according to the principle of fractalization, an organism
creates many quantum copies of itself with projections on the skin,
mucous membranes, etc. The biological reason for these multiple copies
is to create a bigger "durability reserve" for the informational
structure, i.e., the body codes its anatomical structure, the structure
and functions of its internal organs and systems, and the development
of the organism in space and time.4
Formation and Application to Microsystems A
large central image analogous to the system of 12 Principal, and 8
Extra Meridians, is shown in Figure 1; many other images are created
around it. These images are self-similar in form and content but
different in size, from the largest to the smallest "fractal dust."
These images can be used to represent the microacupuncture systems,
which also vary in size and in their resolving ability. The su jok,
ECIWO, and YNSA microsystems have the greatest resolving ability. Su
jok describes the microcopies of the meridians as bel meridians.
Generally, this system provides the most comprehensive description of
the principle of fractalization, particularly with regard to the basic
and minisystems of conformity.
Figure 1. The Mandelbrot Set (Z [Z2-C]) Depicted at Different Scales via Computer Graphics7 (A) Primary "Mother Figure" acupuncture channels; (B) Amounts of different microsystems
Park
Jae Woo had no need to prove the principle of self-similarity, which
has long been known in the East. He simply used this principle as the
basis of his doctrine and at the same time, transferred the
philosophical concepts of traditional Eastern medicine to this
microsystem. He did not try to substantiate it physiologically.
Recently, there have been attempts to describe the meridians in other
acupuncture systems.
Since the DNA molecule is the smallest
information carrier and wave copy of an organism, a theoretically
possible number of microsystems must be at least 103 (the number of
cells in the living organism). The Chinese say, "Each object can be
divided 10,000 times." In principle, it is possible to describe many
other microsystems, but they are all smaller and less significant than
more recently discovered systems.
How should we regard the Extra
Meridian and purported new acupuncture points belonging to the
microacupuncture systems that have yet to be described? Accepting the
multitude of microacupuncture systems necessitates dealing with their
interrelationships. This problem can be solved via cybernetic and
homeostatic laws.
Figure 2. Dichotomic Branching as a Fractal of the Bronchial Tree
In
cybernetics, any microacupuncture system is a homeostat that provides
an informational exchange between the inner medium of the human
organism and the environment, and that which keeps internal stability.
The body's lower-order homeostats, being informational fractals, join
to form a hierarchical net resulting in a homeostat of a higher order.5
According to cybernetic laws, the higher-order homeostat controls all
the lower-order ones included in its circuit. In the human organism,
the system of classic Chinese meridians is an acupuncture homeostat of
the highest order. It includes and rules all the smaller systems.
The
size of the organism is a factor that results in different resolutions
in the multitude of acupuncture systems. This directly impacts the
clinical efficacy during a treatment period. This conclusion is borne
out by the holographic principle as follows: if only a small portion of
the hologram is illuminated, the whole image of the object still
appears, but in less detail from fewer angles."6
Figure 3. Fractalization of the Cardiac Rhythm During a 24-Hour Period and a 1-Minute Interval
The
pathology of an internal organ, of a system within the organism, or of
a traumatic injury is momentarily reflected in all acupuncture systems
on the field level. The main task of a clinician is to find the core of
pathology and be able to influence it directly or indirectly. It is
sometimes easier to do this by using a microsystem, where all the
information about an individual is concentrated on a limited surface.
The possibilities are limited by the respective resolving ability of a
particular microsystem and, as a result, its influence on an organism.
The most effective diagnostics and treatment are possible when
performed with Classic and Extra Meridians. In some cases, lack of
success (with these) is the result of a lack of knowledge and not due
to a defect in the system.
This hypothesis of the formation of
microacupuncture systems is somewhat abstract. It only models the
process mathematically and physically, without the participation of the
nervous, humoral, and other systems. Important to remember is that
demonstrating mathematical laws in nature, including living nature, is
universal. Concrete physiologic substantiation will perhaps be carried
out in the future, probably in some unusual form, taking knowledge of
this to the next level.
The fractal theory of the microsystems
is a component of a more general fractal-field model of the organism.
By using this model, it is possible to explain the mechanism of
interaction between the living organism and a low-energy laser beam.
Additionally,
the above-mentioned model is the theoretical basis of the electronic
marker of acupuncture points (EMAP) therapy, a new trend in acupuncture
actively being developed in Russia. The core of this method is the
noninvasive informational influence on the organism by means of fractal
electromagnetic fields, by means of the acupuncture points.
Confirming
and explaining concepts in traditional Eastern acupuncture from the
perspective of the laws of physics gives rise to new possibilities for
diagnostics and treatment. Instruments and tests for specific
diagnostics and EMAP therapy have been formulated. Their high level of
efficacy have been proven for treating pain syndromes, strong arterial
hypertension, chronic obstructive lung diseases with pulmonary
hypertension, and eye diseases, as well as in pediatric practice.
CONCLUSION Microacupuncture
systems are one of the manifestations of fractalization, the universal
principle of self-organization in nature. The number of possible
microsystems is unlimited. Resolution of a microsystem and its
influence on the organism depends on the size of its projection on the
surface of the skin, mucous membrane, and periosteum. This influence is
most effective at the points of the classic acupuncture meridians. The
new and Extra Meridian points belong to microsystems that have yet to
be described.
The medical effects of the microacupuncture
systems need to be accepted fully. To do this, it is necessary to
thoroughly explore the physiologic mechanisms of fractal-field theory
as they apply to microacupuncture systems.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
I express my gratitude to Sue Marriott for helping me with the English translation.
REFERENCES
Peitgen H-O, Richter PH. Beauty of Fractals: Images of Complex Dynamical Systems. Berlin, Germany: Springer-Verlag; 1988:175.
Nebrat V. The physical model of the low energy electromagnetic field influence on
the human body through the acupuncture points. Poster presented at 2nd
European Congress "Acupuncture White Nights-97." St Petersburg, Russia;
1997.
Shipov G. The Theory of Physical Vacuum. Moscow, Russia: Nauka; 1993.
Gariaev P. Wave genome. Public Profit. 1994.
Stepanov A. The fundamental principle of the medical homeostatics. Voronezh, MODEC. 1994.
Jarrett LS. The holographic paradigm and acupuncture. J Tradit Acupuncture. 1985;8:36-41.
Dr
Vadim Bouevitch is a Medical Doctor and Licensed Medical Acupuncturist
at the Hospital of Medical Rehabilitation, Amur Medical Academy,
Russia. Dr Bouevitch is interested in classic acupuncture theories and
their evidence with regard to physics.
Vadim Bouevitch, MD, MAc* Hospital of Medical Rehabilitation Krasnoflotskaya St 189 Blagoveschensk, 675000 Russia Phone (office): +7-4162-421457; Home: +7-4162-356745 Fax: +7-4162-350018 E-mail: moxa@amur.ru
At present, acupuncture has been used to treat chronic pain
has been widely accepted [9]. Acupuncture clinical trials have also proved
effective in the treatment of fibromyalgia, chronic headache and primary
dysmenorrhea, through stimulation of free nerve endings and increase blood flow
velocity of cerebral blood vessels, the release of endorphin, prostaglandin to
achieve analgesic effects [1].
Chronic pain syndrome with sympathetic hyperactivity, but
also including the different divisions forebrain cortex and can inhibit the
promotion of pain and function with a degree of autonomy. Acupuncture arising
on the relationship between sensory, sympathetic and parasympathetic function
of the effects of self-government as well as the electroencephalogram (EEGs) changes
in research, results showed that acupuncture can significantly reduce the heart
rate (HR), increased systolic blood pressure (SBP) . Spectral analysis pointed
out that acupuncture can significantly reduce the HR variability (HRV) and SBP
variability (SBPV) in low-frequency component (LF), a significant reduction in
HRV low-frequency and high frequency (HF) ratio (LF / HF index for sympathetic
nerve activity), HRV and the LF / HF ratio and the reported number of
sensory-specific acupuncture was negatively correlated, HRV and the HF between
the number of acupuncture felt was a significant positive correlation.
EEG data analysis showed that non-specific acupuncture makes
waves in addition to γ, the increase in the intensity of all bands. And HF
(parasympathetic activity index) changes and the overall strength of HRV
(autonomic nervous system activity of the total) and θ, α and γ-wave intensity
was positively correlated, while the LF and HRV of SBPV the LF / HF change with
all changes in the intensity of bands was a negative correlation. The study
results suggest that acupuncture-induced sensory changes caused by the autonomy
of the central nervous system through the forebrain in particular (such as
changes in EEG)-mediated, which is inhibited through the sympathetic nerve
activity to alleviate chronic pain and is useful [10] ... ...
PD is also called paralysis agitans, is a regular
middle-aged and older occurred in the central nervous system degenerative
diseases, mainly for static tremor, muscle rigidity, bradykinesia, ataxia,
postural reflex impairment, patients with severe memory impairment and symptoms
of dementia, PD prevalence rate second only to AD, mainly in middle-aged and
older people, people over the age of 65 the prevalence rate of about 2%. Acupuncture
treatment of PD in order to study the physiological mechanisms, the use of
methyl-phenyl-tetrahydropyridine (MPTP) to deal with C57BL / 6 mice, for making
PD model, and select points "Yanglingquan" and "Taichong"
to carry out acupuncture, testing whether acupuncture inhibition of nerve cells
of microglial activation and inflammatory response,‘
results showed that acupuncture could reduce tyrosine
hydroxylase immunoreactivity in the striatum and substantia nigra have a
neuroprotective effect, attenuation nerve cells of microglial markers that
macrophage antigen complex 1 (MAC-1) increase, decrease COX-2 (COX-2) and
inducible nitric oxide synthase (iNOS) expression increased. In the MPTP group,
dopamine in the striatum 7 days was 46%, while the acupuncture group compared
with 78% of dopamine. The study results show that acupuncture may be by
inhibiting the nerve cells of microglial activation and inflammatory response
to play a neuroprotective effect, suggesting that acupuncture can be used as a
means of neuroprotective intervention for patients with PD neurons inhibit
microglia activation and the inflammatory response [25].
MECHANISM OF ACUPUNCTURE EFFECT
"Thorn to the gas to and effective", a gas is caused by sensory stimulation of acupuncture, and is closely related to clinical efficacy. Study indicated that the hypothalamus is the air conditioning was an important site, the use of acupuncture and the feeling of scale can predict the activation of the hypothalamus and a feeling of relevance gas. To study the results of acupuncture treatment as an example, the forbidden drugaddiction, the changes in the function of the hypothalamus persists, through functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) studies have shown that in healthy volunteers and heroin addicts and the activation of the hypothalamus to stimulate acupuncture related to corticosterone levels and physiological responses, including a gas feeling sharp pain to anxiety and findings of the study showed that acupuncture stimulation, the addicts of the activation of the hypothalamus better than healthy, acupuncture treatment of heroin addicts have gas score was significantly higher than the healthy group [4].
Acupuncture is usually the body by regulating cell signaling molecules play a role of substance, like nitric oxide (NO), norepinephrine (NE) and so on. NO is an important signaling molecule, such as neurotransmitters, like with a variety of functions, may in some cells such as neurons and have a skin. Epidermis, outer root sheath and sebaceous glands with neuronal nitric oxide synthase (nNOS) immunoreactivity and NADPH diaphorase Ⅱ activity. Human skin in NO concentration can be micro-dialysis method of skin in vivo monitoring [5]. Research has shown that acupuncture points in the rat skin, the meridian on the NO concentration and relatively high expression of nNOS [6].
Skin surface in order to collect points of nitrate and nitrite quantitative, revealed by a bacterial enzyme nitrate reduction of non-acupuncture points on whether or not to participate in NO synthesis, at both ends with a length of 0.5 ~ 0.7 cm of small plastic tubes tied tube 50 healthy volunteers in the forearm or leg. The NO scavenger, hemoglobin, or 2 - benzene -4,4,5,5 - tetramethyl-imidazoline -1 - O -3 - oxide (PTIO) Add tube under the skin 20 min, the use of chemiluminescence to collect samples of nitrate and nitrite quantitatively. The results show that regional and non-meridian control samples collected compared to nitrate and nitrite concentration on the Pericardium Meridian Point 4, the bladder through two points on the significantly increased. Nitrate and nitrite concentration in the first a 20 min sample collection points were significantly increased, and in 20 ~ 40 min, 40 ~ 60 min and 60 ~ 80 min of the research team collected samples of similar concentration. Water treatment and the skin surface compared to the skin with sodium hypochlorite to deal with the surface nitrate and nitrite concentration and the number of bacteria significantly reduced cloning. This study shows that with non-points compared to the skin, NO in the points to a very high level of physical release, by the bacterial reduction of nitrate to participate in non-enzymatic chemical skin acupoint produced NO, and L-arginine for NO synthesis [7].
With α-methyl tyrosine methyl ester pretreatment and intravenous injection of rat L-(2,3,5,6-3H) - tyrosine, blood, stripped lower limbs, upper limbs and trunk on the acupuncture points, non-acupuncture points and non-meridian skin regions were observed in skin tissue levels of NE and the determination of NO update on the acupuncture points and meridians on the NE effect, results showed that the NE concentration of the skin points and the release of 3H-NE was significantly higher than non-acupoints and non-meridian area. When the intravenous injection of NO donor DEA-NO-pro-nuclear complex, the points in the release of 3H-NE increase, when the injection of neuronal NO synthesis inhibitor NG-propyl-L-arginine, the points in the 3H - decline in NE release. NE Acupoints NO update rate in the treatment group for the lower body, and in the NO synthesis inhibitor group the opposite trend. In contrast, the NO donor and NO synthesis inhibitors both organizations to deal with non-acupuncture points or non-meridian control organization of the update rate of NE were not affected. NE of the study to prove the first update rate is always lower in the acupuncture points, NO donor points to the promotion of increased NE synthesis or release, NO synthesis inhibitor, can inhibit NE synthesis or release points, tips and non-acupuncture points, meridians compared to skin tissue, in acupuncture points, meridians NE skin is to increase the synthesis or release, and in the sympathetic nervous system can be derived from L-arginine by NO synthesis regulation [8].
The Mechanism of Acupuncture - Beyond
Neurohumoral Theory
By
Charles Shang, MD HARVARD
Abstract:
Objectives:
The gold standard in testing scientific theory requires multiple
independent prospective tests. This standard is applied to basic
acupuncture research. This article reviews the key results of basic
acupuncture research which meet the gold standards and discusses their
implications.
Method:
Literature search and review of publications in medline and Chinese
medical literature databases are combined with discussion with many
experts to identify and analyze the models in basic acupuncture research
which have predictions. These predictions are further checked for
independent confirmation by multiple research groups.
Results:
Initial literature screen identified more than 400 related articles.
Further analysis and discussion showed that the growth control model is
the only published model in basic acupuncture research which has met the
gold standard. It encompasses the neurophysiology model and suggests
that a macroscopic growth control system originates from a network of
organizers in embryogenesis. The activity of the growth control system
is important in the formation, maintenance and regulation of all the
physiological systems. Several phenomena of acupuncture such as the
distribution of auricular acupuncture points, the long term effects of
acupuncture and the effect of multimodal nonspecific stimulation at
acupuncture points are consistent with the growth control model. The
following predictions of the growth control model have been
independently confirmed by research results in both acupuncture and
conventional biomedical sciences: 1. Acupuncture has extensive growth
control effects. 2. Singular point and separatrix exist in
morphogenesis. 3. Organizers have high electric conductance, high
current density and high density of gap junctions. 4. A high density of
gap junctions is distributed as separatrices or boundaries at body
surface after early embryogenesis. 5. Many acupuncture points are
located at transition points or boundaries between different body
domains or muscles, coinciding with the connective tissue planes. 6.
Some morphogens and organizers continue to function after embryogenesis.
Conclusion: Current acupuncture research suggests a convergence of the
neurophysiology model, the connective tissue model and the growth
control model. The growth control model of acupuncture set the first
example of a biological model in integrative medicine with significant
prediction power across multiple disciplines. Basic acupuncture research
has met the gold standard of science with multiple independently
confirmed predictions.
Introduction
According to the World Health Organization (WHO),
a broad definition of acupuncture is the stimulation of certain points
on the body (acupuncture points) using needling, moxibustion,
electricity, laser, or acupressure for therapeutic purposes.1
The Standard Acupuncture Nomenclature published by the WHO listed about
400 acupuncture points and 20 meridians connecting most of the points.2
Results from randomized controlled trials (RCTs) have shown that
acupuncture is effective in treating dozens of disorders1
such as osteoarthritis 3, 4, 5 pelvic and back pain 6
neck pain 7 migraine and tension headache 8,9
nausea/vomiting 10 and inflammatory bowel disease.11
Mixed results widely exist in acupuncture research12 for
various reasons. Many neurohumoral 13, 14, 15, 16 mechanical
and growth control effects of acupuncture18 have been
observed. Several models of acupuncture mechanism have been proposed.
The focus of this article is on the biological models of acupuncture
which can meet the gold standard of science with multiple independently
confirmed predictions.
The Observations from Acupuncture Research
In the mid-70s, the discovery of endorphin
induction in acupuncture analgesia and its blockade by naloxone was
instrumental in establishing the validity of acupuncture in modern
science.19, 20 In acupuncture analgesia, the peripheral
nervous system has been shown to be crucial in mediating the effect. The
analgesia can be abolished if the acupuncture site is affected by
postherpetic neuralgia21 or injection of local anesthetics.22
Different frequencies of electric stimulation in electroacupuncture lead
to release of different neuropeptides.13 Electroacupuncture
has been shown to release nociceptin and inhibit the reflex-induced
increases in blood pressure16 and increased the synthesis of
nitric oxide in mediating the protective effect on gastric mucosa.23
Since the 1950s, it has been discovered and
confirmed with refined techniques14 that many acupuncture
points and meridians have high electrical conductance24, 25, 26
though the results are sometimes mixed.27 High electric
conductance of acupuncture points have been successfully used for
locating acupuncture points in acupuncture therapy.28 The
high electric conductance at acupuncture points is further supported by
preliminary finding of high density of gap junctions at the epithelia of
the acupuncture points.29, 30, 31, 32 Gap junctions are
hexagonal protein complexes that form channels between adjacent cells.
It is well established in cell biology that gap junctions facilitate
intercellular communication and increase electric conductance. High
concentrations of nitric oxide and nitric oxide synthase have also been
observed at acupuncture points and meridians.33
Modern Biological Models of Acupuncture
In the 1970's, the relation between the nervous
system and acupuncture alteration of visceral function was explored by
examining the cortical evoked potentials, single unit discharges and
neurochemistry associated with acupuncture. These studies brought forth
the Meridian-Cortex-Viscera correlation hypothesis which states that: 1.
The meridian system is an independent system connected via the nervous
system to the cerebral cortex. 2. It acts through neurohumoral
mechanisms.34 A contending model claimed that the meridian
system as described in the classic acupuncture literature does not exist
and that all the effects of acupuncture are mediated through nervous
system.35, 36
Another hypothesis suggested that the network of
acupuncture points and meridians is a signal transduction network formed
by interstitial connective tissue. Mapping of acupuncture points on
human arm showed an 80% correspondence between the sites of acupuncture
points and the location of intermuscular or intramuscular connective
tissue planes in postmortem tissue sections.37
Modern biological models of acupuncture are
confronted with the following puzzling facts:
The distribution of acupuncture points: The
distribution of acupuncture points is different from the
distribution of nerves, blood vessels, lymphatics or connective
tissue. For example, an auricle has no important nerves or blood
vessels or lymphatics or complex connective tissue planes and no
significant physiological function other than sound collection.
While the vagus nerve has an auricular branch, this branch has no
known important function in modern neuroscience. A search of Medline
did not yield any article on the function of the auricular branch of
vagus nerve in the past 50 years. The auricle nevertheless has the
highest density of acupuncture points. According to the WHO, 43
auricular points have proven therapeutic value,2 which
consist of more than 10% of the acupuncture points of the entire
human body. Numerous RCTs have demonstrated the efficacy of
auricular acupuncture38, 39, 40, 41, 42, 43 while some
results are mixed.12
The non-specific activation of acupuncture
points: Therapeutic effect of acupuncture has been achieved by a
variety of stimuli10,1 including needling, injection of
nonspecific chemicals, electricity, temperature variation, laser,
and pressure. No conventional nerve stimulation technique has such
diverse modalities of stimulation. Non-noxious stimuli such as
non-thermal low intensity laser irradiation, which does not cause
local nerve excitation44 or collagen fiber reorganization
at acupuncture points, can cause extensive systemic effects45
and stimulate local cellular calcium oscillation,45 cell
proliferation, release of basic fibroblast growth factor,
interleukins as well as other growth control effects.46
This suggests that another system other than nervous system mediates
the initial signal transduction in acupuncture.
Transient acupuncture stimulation often
causes long lasting effect over weeks or months. For example, two
RCTs9,8 have shown that the relief of migraine headache
lasted 1 year after acupuncture treatment – thousands of times
longer than the physiological half life of endorphin47
and other common neurotransmitters. Similar long-term benefits of
acupuncture have been shown by RCTs on the treatment of shoulder
pain,48 chronic low back pain,49, 50 primary
dysmenorrhea,51 spinal cord injuries,42
urinary urgency41 and osteoarthritis.5, 52, 53
This long lasting effect is almost non-existent in conventional
therapy using transient mild peripheral nerve stimulation. In
conventional nerve stimulation, long lasting effects require long
term stimulation as observed in the effects of opioids, serotonin
reuptake inhibitors, sacral nerve stimulation,54 and
vagal nerve stimulation.55
The existence of acupuncture points. i.e. why
do stimuli at many acupuncture points cause diverse systemic effects
without obvious benefit of survival for normal animals? For example,
stimulation at acupuncture points PC6 and ST36 which are at the
extremities increases the gastric motility in dogs.56
This is contrary to the fight or flight response and seems to offer
no survival benefit to animals. What is the intrinsic function of
acupuncture points? How did these acupuncture points come into
existence over the course of evolution?
In science, models or hypotheses capable of
successful prospective predictions are considered more convincing than
models solely based on retrospective explanations or accommodations.57,
58 The gold standard in testing a scientific theory is multiple
independent confirmations of its predictions. It is therefore important
to assess which theory in basic acupuncture research has met this gold
standard. A literature research in PubMed with full text (Medline) using
keywords acupuncture AND (predict* OR corollary) identified 101
articles. Similar search strategy in Chinese medical/scientific
literature databases including
http://www.wanfangdata.com.cn/,
http://engine.cqvip.com/,and
http://www.chinainfobank.com/ identified over 300 articles. Further
review of the literature and discussion with more than a dozen experts
in this field narrowed down to two biological models59,18
which have independently confirmed prediction(s): The neurophysiology
model on the long term effects of acupuncture59 suggests: 1.
The trophic and anti-inflammatory effects of acupuncture are important
in mediating its long term effects. 2. Long term potentiation and long
term depression are likely involved in acupuncture signal transduction.
Its corollary on the peripheral anti-inflammatory effect of endorphin in
acupuncture has been confirmed.60 The growth control model
first published in the 1980s61 correctly predicted multiple
research results not only in acupuncture, but also in conventional
biomedical sciences. It also has shed light on the puzzling observations
mentioned above.62,18 This model encompasses the
neurophysiology of acupuncture18 and is supported by the
research results on connective tissue at acupuncture points.17,37
It is the only published model which has met the gold standard of
the multiple independent prospective tests.
The Origin and Function of Acupuncture Points
It is well known that all the physiological
systems, including nervous system, are derived from a system of
embryogenesis - a growth control system.63[Figure
1] In growth control, the fate of a larger region is frequently
controlled by a small group of cells, which is termed an organizing
center or organizer.64 A gradient of messenger molecules
called morphogens forms around organizers. Organizers have highest
(sources) or lowest (sinks) local concentration of morphogens64, 65
and therefore are macroscopic singular points of morphogen gradient
field. A singular point is a point of discontinuity. It indicates abrupt
transition from one state to another. Small, nonspecific perturbations
around singular points - organizers can have important systemic effect.66,
67 Several lines of evidence suggests that the bioelectric field
interacts with morphogens and growth factors, and guides morphogenesis.68,
69 The growth and migration of a variety of cells are sensitive to
electric fields of physiological strength.70, 71 Organizers
and acupuncture points share several common features: Both commonly
distribute at the extreme points of surface curvature18,61,62
and are activated by non-specific stimuli.67,61 Both are
associated with bioelectric field.18 The growth control model
therefore suggested that acupuncture points originate from organizers.18,61
Confirmed Predictions on Organizers and
Morphogens
Based on the connection between
acupuncture points and organizers, the growth control model predicted
that organizers have high electric conductance, high electric current
density and high density of gap junctions.18,61 These
predictions on organizers have been independently confirmed: Organizers
such as blastopore and zone of polarizing activity have high electric
conductance, high current density72 and high density of gap
junctions.73, 74, 75, 76 Multi-cellular organisms maintain
regular form and function despite constant replacement of cells,
intra-cellular components and extracellular matrix. Without growth
control, this constant regeneration is prone to structural
disintegration and degeneration into various tumors. The growth control
model predicted that organizers and morphogens partially retain their
regulatory function after embryogenesis.18,61 This prediction
has also been independently confirmed: Morphogens such as retinoic acid,
Wnt, bone morphogenetic protein and Hedgehog as well as some organizers
continue to exist and function in adult after embryogenesis.77, 78,
79, 80, 81
Confirmed Predictions on Acupuncture
One corollary from the growth control
model is that acupuncture has extensive growth control effects which
have been confirmed: Acupuncture has been shown to regulate various
growth factors and growth control genes. It can induce vascular
endothelial growth factor82 and basic fibroblast growth
factor83 during brain ischemia. It also induces glial cell
line-derived neurotrophic factor84 and expression of the c-fos
proto-oncogene.85, 86 Acupuncture regulates the expression of
Bcl-2,87 Bax, fas and FasL proteins which are involved in
apoptosis signaling. Acupuncture inhibits the apoptosis of intestinal
epithelial cells in inflammatory bowel disease of rats88 and
enhances proliferation of CD8+ lymphocytes,89 reduces nerve
growth factor in polycystic ovaries,90, 91reduces IL-6
expression and proliferation of osteoclasts.92 The
neuro-humoral factors induced by acupuncture such as endorphins, nitric
oxide and serotonin also have growth-control effects.92, 98, 94
In RCTs, acupuncture has shown efficacy in treating growth control
related disorders including spinal cord injuries38 and low
sperm quality.95, 96
Growth Control System as Foundation of
Pathophysiology
A growth control system originates from a
network of organizers.97 In embryogenesis, the development of
organizers precedes the development of other physiological systems.18,64
The formation, maintenance and regulation of all the physiological
systems are dependent on the activity of the growth control system.
Growth control is a primary function of all multi-cellular organisms.
The evolutionary origin of the growth control system likely preceded all
the other physiological systems. Its genetic blueprint served as a
template from which the newer systems evolved. Consequently, it overlaps
and interacts with other systems but is not merely part of the nervous
system, immune system or circulatory system. The growth control signal
transduction is embedded in the activity of the function-based
physiological systems: The regulation of many neural, circulatory,
immune processes and related disorders are mediated through growth
control mechanisms such as hypertrophy, hyperplasia, atrophy, apoptosis
with shared messenger molecules including morphogens98, 99, 77,81
and common signal transduction pathways involving growth control genes
such as proto-oncogenes.100, 101, 102
The Nonspecific Stimulation and the
Long Term Effects of Acupuncture
Based on the growth control model,
acupuncture points and organizers are singular points and therefore
prone to nonspecific perturbation. The long lasting systemic effects of
acupuncture can be achieved by nonspecific stimuli as mentioned above.
Similarly, long lasting growth control activities of organizers have
been induced by various stimuli such as mechanical injury and injection
of nonspecific chemicals.67 Based on the growth control
model, acupuncture effect is a byproduct of the growth control network.
Stimulating organizers – acupuncture points can not only cause transient
modulation of neurotransmission, but also alter the growth control
signal transduction in various systems - leading to long term effects.18
The Distribution of Acupuncture Points
and Organizers
Organizers are at the extreme points of
curvature on the body surface such as the locally most convex points
(e.g., apical ectodermal ridge and other growth tips) or concave or
saddle points (e.g., zone of polarizing activity).103, 18
Similarly, almost all the extreme points of the body surface curvature
are acupuncture points. For example, the convex points include EX-UE11
Shixuan (finger tips), EX-LE12 Qiduan (toe tips), ST17 Ruzhong (tip of
nipple), ST42 Chongyang, (the convex, palpable point of arteria dorsalis
pedis), GV25 Suliao (nose tip) ... The concave points include TE3
Zhongzhu (the concave point between the 4th and 5th metacarpal), KI1
Yongquan (at the concave point of the sole), GB20 Fengchi (the concave
point below occipital bone, between upper ends of sternocleidomastoid
and trapezius), BL40 Weizhong (midpoint of the transverse crease of the
popliteal fossa), HT1 Jiquan (the most concave point of axilla), BL1
Jingming (at the concave point above medial canthus), CV8 Shenque
(navel)... Based on growth control model, the extreme points of surface
curvature are associated with organizers – acupuncture points. The
auricle obviously has the most convoluted surface morphology of the
human body. Therefore it has the highest density of extreme points of
surface curvature and is expected to have the highest density of
organizers - acupuncture points. Auricle exemplifies the interconnection
of growth control: Auricular morphology is a sentinel of malformation in
other organs. Auricular malformation has been observed in numerous
malformation syndromes. It is recommended in a standard textbook of
pediatrics that any auricular anomaly should initiate a search for
malformations in other parts of the body.104
The Origin of Meridians
The growth control model suggests that
the discontinuity or abrupt transition in growth control not only exists
at organizers but also along boundaries.18,61 The growth
control boundaries or folds between different structures are also called
separatrices in mathematics and often connect singular points -
organizers. The model predicted that growth control boundaries have high
electric conductance and high density of gap junctions – just as the
meridians in acupuncture which likely originate from growth control
boundaries. These predictions have been confirmed: As embryogenesis
progresses, high density gap junctions become restricted at discrete
boundaries, leading to the subdivision of the embryo into communication
compartment domains.105, 106 Increasing or decreasing the gap
junctions can cause various developmental defects107 such as
spina bifida.108 These high electric conductance boundaries
are likely major pathways of bioelectric currents. Organizers are known
to locate at boundaries between different structures.109 The
growth control model suggests that meridians originate from separatrices
– boundaries in growth control and form an undifferentiated,18,61
interconnected cellular network that regulates growth and physiology. In
consistence with the prediction of under-differentiation of the meridian
system and growth control system, it has been observed that the most
apical part of folds of embryo remain undifferentiated in morphogenesis,110
including organizers such as apical ectodermal ridge.111 As
predicted by the growth control model, singular point and separatrix
have important roles in morphogenesis.112, 113 Growth control
boundaries/separatrices are similar to organizers in controlling growth
and pattern formation with morphogen gradient.114 Many
acupuncture points are located at boundaries between different body
domains or muscles, coinciding with the connective tissue planes which
connect adjacent body domains or muscles.17, 37, 115
Summary
Current acupuncture research suggests a
convergence of the neurophysiology model, the connective tissue model
and the growth control model. The growth control model of acupuncture
set the first example of a biological model in integrative medicine with
significant prediction power across multiple disciplines. It is the
first theory in basic acupuncture research which has met the gold
standard in testing scientific theory. The following predictions of the
growth control model have been independently confirmed by research
results in both acupuncture and conventional biomedical sciences: 1.
Acupuncture has extensive growth control effects. 2. Singular point and
separatrix have important roles in morphogenesis. 3. Organizers have
high electric conductance, high current density and high density of gap
junctions. 4. A high density of gap junctions is distributed as
separatrices or boundaries at body surface after early embryogenesis. 5.
Many acupuncture points are located at transition points or boundaries
between different body domains or muscles, coinciding with the
connective tissue planes. 6. Some morphogens and organizers continue to
function after embryogenesis. The growth control model has also shed
light on several puzzling phenomena of acupuncture such as the
distribution of auricular acupuncture points, the long term effects of
acupuncture and the effect of multimodal nonspecific stimulation at
acupuncture points.
Future Directions
The structure and cell
differentiation at acupuncture points as well as the neurophysiology
and growth control signal transduction involved in different
modalities of acupuncture should be further delineated.
Manipulating the singular points -
organizers of the growth control system may be a convenient way of
activating intrinsic stem cells as evident from the improvement of
sperm quality after acupuncture.95, 96
As the growth control model predicts
the growth control activity at acupuncture points/extreme points of
surface (or interface) curvature after embryogenesis, residual
morphogen gradient may still exist at these points and may be
detectable by probing morphogen candidates such as Hedgehog, Wnt and
TGF-beta families. Certain morphogen gradient distributes along
boundaries.116 This pattern may persist after
embryogenesis into adulthood and coincides with meridians.
Mapping of the growth control system
and the dynamics of its electromagnetic field with high resolution
techniques such as the superconducting quantum interference device
(SQUID) and atomic magnetometer :117 The growth control
model predicts that the singular points and separatrices of the
bioelectric field in growth control correlate with the acupuncture
points and meridians respectively.
The growth control model suggests
that techniques involving the stimulation of the growth control
system such as acupuncture can activate the growth control activity
of an organism and improve its structure and function at a more
fundamental level than symptomatic relief.18 In growth
control, the change in electric field precedes morphologic change
and manipulation of the electric field can affect the change.70,
118 Development of the techniques of detecting and
manipulating the electric field may enable the diagnosis and
treatment of a pathologic process at the early signal transduction
stage prior to the anatomical or morphological change.
The growth control model suggests
that apparently unrelated acupuncture points are not exactly
‘placebo’ points. The more acupuncture points are used as placebo
points in a RCT, the more likely that some systemic effects will be
resulted from the ‘placebo’ treatment. The self-regulatory effect of
acupuncture will be difficult to predict when the patients have
multiple comorbidities and many acupuncture points are used. Subtle,
‘sham’ stimulation at acupuncture points can be effective due to the
response of the acupuncture points to nonspecific stimuli. These
reasons may contribute to the mixed results in RCTs on acupuncture.
This model also suggests that acupuncture is mostly likely to
demonstrate its efficacy and advantage in a patient population with
few comorbidities, relatively good general health and vitality and a
regimen with efficient use of acupoints.
The growth control model suggests
that the distribution of growth control system is related to both
internal and external structures. Acupuncture points which are not
at obvious extreme points of surface curvature or meridians which
are not at obvious surface boundaries may be vestigial or related to
interface between internal structures such as muscles and bones.
Intrinsic stem cells are likely part of the undifferentiated growth
control network. The germ cell is one of the least differentiated
cells and also a type of stem cell – similar to the embryonic stem
cell in its ability to differentiate into all three germ layers. The
distribution pattern of intrinsic germ cells can be deduced based on
the fact that the distribution pattern of primary tumors reflects
the distribution of their normal counterpart. The primary germ cell
tumors119 have a midline and para-axial distribution
pattern which spans from the sacrococcygeal region to pineal gland.
It appears to concentrate at 7 locations: sacrococcygeal region,
gonads, retroperitoneum, thymus, thyroid,120 suprasellar
region, and pineal gland. This pattern reflects the distribution
pattern of intrinsic germ cells which are likely to be highly
inter-connected in a normal state (e.g. via gap junctions121
) and provide important regulatory functions.122, 56 This
also suggests a hierarchy in the degree of cell differentiation and
function in the growth control system.
Acknowledgments
I thank Steven K.H. Aung, Zang-Hee Cho,
Yuenan Cui, Li Dingzhong, Maria do Desterro Leiros, Michael Levin,
Vitaly Napadow, Richard Nuccitelli, Stig Ollmar, Rosa N. Schnyer, San
Wan, Peter Wayne, Raimond Wong, Seung-Schik Yoo for their input.
References
World Health Organization. 2002.
Acupuncture: Review and analysis of reports on controlled clinical
trials. WHO Geneva.
World Health Organization. 1991. A
proposed standard international acupuncture nomenclature: report of
a WHO scientific group. World Health Organization, Geneva.
Osiri M, Welch V, Brosseau L, Shea
B, McGowan J, Tugwell P, Wells G. 2004. Transcutaneous electrical
nerve stimulation for knee osteoarthritis. Cochrane Database of
Systematic Reviews. 3.
Kwon YD, Pittler MH, Ernst E.
Acupuncture for peripheral joint osteoarthritis: a systematic review
and meta-analysis. Rheumatology. 2006;45:1331-7.
Berman BM, Lao L, Langenberg P, Lee
WL, Gilpin AM, Hochberg MC. Effectiveness of acupuncture as
adjunctive therapy in osteoarthritis of the knee: a randomized,
controlled trial. Ann Intern Med. 2004;141:901-10.
Young G, Jewell D. 2004.
Interventions for preventing and treating pelvic and back pain in
pregnancy. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews. 3.
Trinh K, Graham N, Gross A,
Goldsmith Ch, et al. Acupuncture for neck disorders. Cochrane
Database Syst Rev, 2006; 3: CD004870.
Vincent CA. 1989. A controlled trial
of the treatment of migraine by acupuncture. Clin J Pain 5: 305-12.
Vickers AJ. Rees RW. Zollman CE.
McCarney R. Smith CM. Ellis N. Fisher P. Van Haselen R. 2004.
Acupuncture for chronic headache in primary care: large, pragmatic,
randomised trial. BMJ 328:744-747.
Vickers AJ. Can acupuncture have
specific effects on health? A systematic review of acupuncture
antiemesis trials. J R Soc Med 1996;89:303-11.
Joos S, Brinkhaus B, Maluche C,
Maupai N, Kohnen R, et al. 2004. Acupuncture and moxibustion in the
treatment of active Crohn's disease: a randomized controlled study.
Digestion 69: 131-9.
White PF. Electroanalgesia: does it
have a place in the routine management of acute and chronic pain?
Anesth Analg. 2004;98:1197-8.
Han JS. Acupuncture: neuropeptide
release produced by electrical stimulation of different frequencies.
Trends Neurosci. 2003;26: 17-22.
Pomeranz B. Acupuncture analgesia –
basic research. In Clinical Acupuncture: Scientific Basis. edited by
G. Stux and R. Hammerschlag, Berlin: Springer-Verlag; 2000;p1-29.
Han JS. Opioid and antiopioid
peptides: A model of Yin-Yang balance in acupuncture mechanism of
pain modulation. In Clinical Acupuncture: Scientific Basis. edited
by G. Stux and R. Hammerschlag, Berlin: Springer-Verlag;
2000;p51-68.
Crisostomo MM, Li P, Tjen-A-Looi SC,
Longhurst JC. Nociceptin in rVLM mediates electroacupuncture
inhibition of cardiovascular reflex excitatory response in rats. J
Appl Physiol. 2005;98:2056-2063.
Langevin HM, Churchill DL, Wu J,
Badger GJ, Yandow JA, Fox JR, Krag MH. Evidence of connective tissue
involvement in acupuncture. FASEB J 2002;16: 872-4.
Shang C. Electrophysiology of growth
control and acupuncture. Life Sci 2001;68:1333-1342.
Pomeranz B, Chiu D. Naloxone blocks
acupuncture analgesia and causes hyperalgesia: endorphin is
implicated. Life Sci 1976;19:1757-1762.
Mayer DJ, Price DD, Raffii A.
Antagonism of acupuncture analgesia in man by the narcotic
antagonist naloxone. Brain Res 1977;121:368-72.
Bowsher D. Mechanisms of
acupuncture. In: Filshie J, White A, editors. Medical Acupuncture.
Edinburgh: Churchill Livingston, 1998;p69-80.
Chiang CY, Chang CT. Peripheral
afferent pathway for acupuncture analgesia. Scientia Sinica
1973;16:210-7.
Xu GS, Wang ZJ, Zhu SL, Chen QZ,
Zhang DQ. Nitric oxide participates in protective effect of
acupuncture on gastric mucosal damages in rats. World J
Gastroenterol 1996;2:58-59.
Comunetti A, Laage S, Schiessl N,
Kistler A. Characterisation of human skin conductance at acupuncture
points. Experientia 1995;51:328-31.
Saku K, Mukaino Y, Ying H, Arakawa
K. Characteristics of reactive electropermeable points on the
auricles of coronary heart disease patients. Clin Cardiol
1993;16:415-9.
Oleson TD, Kroenig RJ, Bresler DE.
An experimental evaluation of auricular diagnosis: The somatotopic
mapping of musculoskeletal pain at acupuncture points. Pain 1980;8:
217-29.
Martinsen OG, Grimnes S, Morkrid L,
Hareide M. Line patterns in the mosaic electrical properties of
human skin--a cross-correlation study. IEEE Trans Biomed Eng.
2001;48:731-4.
Shiraishi T, Onoe M, Kageyama T,
Sameshima Y, Kojima T, Konishi S, Yoshimatsu H, Sakata T. Effects of
auricular acupuncture stimulation on nonobese, healthy volunteer
subjects. Obes Res 1995;3: 667S-673S.
Mashanskii VF, Markov IuV, Shpunt
VKh, Li SE, Mirkin AS. Topography of the gap junctions in the human
skin and their possible role in the non-neural signal transduction.
Arkh Anat Gistol Embriol 1983;84:53-60.
Cui H-M. Meridian system -
specialized embryonic epithelial conduction system. Shanghai J
Acupunct 1988;3: 44-45.
Fan JY. 1990. The role of gap
junctions in determining skin conductance and their possible
relationship to acupuncture points and meridians. Am J Acupunct
18:163-170.
Zheng CH, Huang GY, Zhang MM, Xiao
YL. [Experimental study on expression of connexin 43 in meridians of
rats] Zhongguo Zhen Jiu. 2005; 25:629-32.
Ma SX. Enhanced nitric oxide
concentrations and expression of nitric oxide synthase in
acupuncture points/meridians. J Altern Complement Med 2003;9:
207-215.
Chang HC, Xie YK, Wen YY, Zhang SY,
Qu JH, Lu WJ. Further investigation on the hypothesis of
meridian-cortex-viscera interrelationship. Am J Chin Med 1983.
11:5-13.
Ulett GA. Beyond Yin and Yang: How
Acupuncture Really Works. Warren H. Green, Inc. St. Louis, MO; 1992.
Mann F. A new system of acupuncture.
In: Filshie J, White A, editors. Medical Acupuncture. Edinburgh:
Churchill Livingston; 1998:63.
Langevin HM, Yandow JA. Relationship
of acupuncture points and meridians to connective tissue planes.
Anat Rec (New Anat) 2002;269: 257 – 265.
Barker R, Kober A, Hoerauf K, Latzke
D, Adel S, Kain ZN, Wang SM. Out-of-hospital auricular acupressure
in elder patients with hip fracture: a randomized double-blinded
trial. Acad Emerg Med. 2006;13:19-23.
Usichenko TI, Dinse M, Hermsen M,
Witstruck T, Pavlovic D, Lehmann Ch. Auricular acupuncture for pain
relief after total hip arthroplasty - a randomized controlled study.
Pain. 2005;114:320-7.
Sator-Katzenschlager SM, Scharbert
G, Kozek-Langenecker SA, Szeles JC, Finster G, Schiesser AW, Heinze
G, Kress HG. The short- and long-term benefit in chronic low back
pain through adjuvant electrical versus manual auricular
acupuncture. Anesth Analg. 2004;98:1359-64.
Ricci L, Minardi D, Romoli M, Galosi
AB, Muzzonigro G. Acupuncture reflexotherapy in the treatment of
sensory urgency that persists after transurethral resection of the
prostate: a preliminary report. Neurourol Urodyn. 2004;23:58-62.
Wong AM, Leong CP, Su TY, Yu SW,
Tsai WC, Chen CP. Clinical trial of acupuncture for patients with
spinal cord injuries. Am J Phys Med Rehabil. 2003;82:21-7.
Bier ID, Wilson J, Studt P,
Shakleton M. Auricular acupuncture, education, and smoking
cessation: a randomized, sham-controlled trial. Am J Public Health.
2002;92:1642-7.
Jarvis D, MacIver MB, Tanelian DL.
Electrophysiologic recording and thermodynamic modeling demonstrate
that helium-neon laser irradiation does not affect peripheral Adelta-
or C-fiber nociceptors. Pain 1990;43:235-42.
Whittaker P. Laser acupuncture:
past, present, and future. Lasers Med Sci 2004;19:69-80.
Yu HS, Wu CS, Yu CL, Kao YH, Chiou
MH. Helium-neon laser irradiation stimulates migration and
proliferation in melanocytes and induces repigmentation in
segmental-type vitiligo. J Invest Dermatol. 2003;120:56-64.
Foley KM, Kourides IA, Inturrisi CE,
Kaiko RF, Zaroulis CG, Posner JB, Houde RW, Li CH. Endorphin:
Analgesic and hormonal effects in humans. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A.
1979;76: 5377–5381.
Guerra de Hoyos JA, Andres Martin
Mdel C, Bassas y Baena de Leon E, Vigara Lopez M, Molina Lopez T,
Verdugo Morilla FA, Gonzalez Moreno MJ. Randomised trial of long
term effect of acupuncture for shoulder pain. Pain. 2004;112:289-98.
Sator-Katzenschlager SM. Scharbert
G. Kozek-Langenecker SA. Szeles JC. Finster G. Schiesser AW. Heinze
G. Kress HG. The short- and long-term benefit in chronic low back
pain through adjuvant electrical versus manual auricular
acupuncture. Anesth Analg. 2004;98:1359-1364.
Carlsson CP, Sjölund BH. Acupuncture
for chronic low back pain: a randomized placebo-controlled study
with long-term follow-up. Clin J Pain 2001;17: 296-305.
Helms JM. Acupuncture for the
management of primary dysmenorrhea. Obstet Gynecol. 1987;69:51-6.
Witt CM, Jena S, Brinkhaus B,
Liecker B, Wegscheider K, Willich SN. Acupuncture in patients with
osteoarthritis of the knee or hip: a randomized, controlled trial
with an additional nonrandomized arm. Arthritis Rheum.
2006;54:3485-93.
Stener-Victorin E. Kruse-Smidje C.
Jung K. Comparison Between Electro-Acupuncture and Hydrotherapy,
Both in Combination With Patient Education and Patient Education
Alone, on the Symptomatic Treatment of Osteoarthritis of the Hip.
Clin J Pain 2004;20:179-185.
Janknegt RA, Janknegt RA, Hassouna
MM, Hassouna MM, Siegel SW, Siegel SW, Oleson KA, et al. Long-term
effectiveness of sacral nerve stimulation for refractory urge
incontinence. Eur Urol 2001;39:101-106.
Schachter SC. Vagus nerve
stimulation therapy summary: five years after FDA approval.
Neurology. 2002;59:S15-20.
Qian L, Peters LJ, Chen JD. Effects
of electroacupuncture on gastric migrating myoelectrical complex in
dogs. Dig Dis Sci. 1999;44:56-62.
Lipton P. Testing hypotheses:
prediction and prejudice. Science. 2005;307:219-21.
Carlsson C. Acupuncture mechanisms
for clinically relevant long-term effects--reconsideration and a
hypothesis. Acupunct Med. 2002;20:82-99.
Kim HW, Roh DH, Yoon SY, Kang SY,
Kwon YB, Han HJ, Lee HJ, Choi SM, Ryu YH, Beitz AJ, Lee JH. The
anti-inflammatory effects of low- and high-frequency
electroacupuncture are mediated by peripheral opioids in a mouse air
pouch inflammation model. J Altern Complement Med. 2006;12:39-44.
Shang C. Singular Point, organizing
center and acupuncture point. Am J Chin Med 1989;17:119-127.
Bryant PJ, Simpson P. Intrinsic and
Extrinsic Control of Growth in Developing Organs. Quart Rev Biol
1984;59:387-415.
Meinhardt H. Models of Biological
Pattern Formation London: Academic; 1982:20.
Niehrs C. Regionally specific
induction by the Spemann-Mangold organizer.
Nat Rev Genet. 2004;5:425-34.
Winfree AT. The Geometry of
biological time. New York: Springer-Verlag. 1980: 71.
Toivonen S. Regionalization of the
embryo. In: Organizer – A milestone of a half- century from Spemann.
Nakamura O, Toivonen S. editors. Amsterdam: Elsevier; 1978: 132.
Marx JL. Electric currents may guide
development. Science 1981;211:1147-9.
Huttenlocher A, Horwitz AR. Wound
healing with electric potential. N Engl J Med. 2007;356:303-4.
Erickson CA. Morphogenesis of the
neural crest. In: Browder LW, editor. Developmental Biology. New
York: Plenum; 1985;2:528.
Hotary KB, Robinson KR. Endogenous
electrical currents and voltage gradients in Xenopus embryos and the
consequences of their disruption. Dev Biol 1994;166:797.
Laird DW, Yancey SB, Bugga L, Revel
JP. Connexin expression and gap junction communication compartments
in the developing mouse limb. Dev Dyn 1992;195: 153-61.
Yancey SB, Biswal S, Revel JP.
Spatial and temporal patterns of distribution of the gap junction
protein connexin43 during mouse gastrulation and organogenesis.
Development 1992;114: 203-12.
Coelho CN, Kosher RA. A gradient of
gap junctional communication along the anterior-posterior axis of
the developing chick limb bud. Dev Biol 1991;148: 529-35.
Meyer RA, Cohen MF, Recalde S, et
al. Developmental regulation and asymmetric expression of the gene
encoding Cx43 gap junctions in the mouse limb bud. Dev Genet
1997;21:290-300.
Rosendahl A, Pardali E, Speletas M,
Ten Dijke P et al. Activation of bone morphogenetic protein/Smad
signaling in bronchial epithelial cells during airway inflammation.
Am J Respir Cell Mol Biol. 2002;27:160-9.
Maden M. The role of retinoic acid
in embryonic and post-embryonic development. Proc Nutr Soc.
2000;59:65-73.
Farquharson C, Jefferies D,
Seawright E, Houston B. Regulation of chondrocyte terminal
differentiation in the postembryonic growth plate: the role of the
PTHrP-Indian hedgehog axis. Endocrinology. 2001;142:4131-40.
Kishimoto J, Burgeson RE, Morgan BA.
Wnt signaling maintains the hair-inducing activity of the dermal
papilla. Genes Dev. 2000;14:1181-5.
Miano JM, Topouzis S, Majesky M,
Olson EN. Retinoid receptor expression and all-trans retinoic
acid-mediated growth inhibition in vascular smooth muscle cells.
Circulation 1996;93:1886-1895.
Wang SJ. Omori N. Li F. Jin G.
Hamakawa Y. Sato K. Nagano I. Shoji M. Abe K. Functional improvement
by electro-acupuncture after transient middle cerebral artery
occlusion in rats. Neurol Res 2003;25:516-21,
Ou YW. Han L. Da CD. Huang YL. Cheng
JS. Influence of acupuncture upon expressing levels of basic
fibroblast growth factor in rat brain following focal cerebral
ischemia--evaluated by time-resolved fluorescence immunoassay.
Neurol Res 2001;23:47-50.
Liang XB. Luo Y. Liu XY. Lu J. Li FQ.
Wang Q. Wang XM. Han JS. Electro-acupuncture improves behavior and
upregulates GDNF mRNA in MFB transected rats. Neuroreport
2003;14:1177-81.
Pan B, Castro-Lopes JM, Coimbra A.
Activation of anterior lobe corticotrophs by electroacupuncture or
noxious stimulation in the anaesthetized rat, as shown by
colocalization of Fos protein with ACTH and beta-endorphin and
increased hormone release. Brain Res Bull 1996;40:175-82.
Lee JH, Beitz AJ. The distribution
of brain-stem and spinal cord nuclei associated with different
frequencies of electroacupuncture analgesia. Pain 1993;52:11-28.
Zhang Y, Wu GC, He QZ, Cao XD.
Effect of morphine and electro-acupuncture (EA) on apoptosis of
thymocytes. Acupunct Electrother Res 2000;25:17-26.
Wu HG, Gong X, Yao LQ, Zhang W, Shi
Y, Liu HR, Gong YJ, Zhou LB, Zhu Y. Mechanisms of acupuncture and
moxibustion in regulation of epithelial cell apoptosis in rat
ulcerative colitis. World J Gastroenterol 2004;10: 682-8.
Chen Y, Zhao C, Chen H, et al.
Effects of "moxibustion serum" on proliferation and phenotypes of
tumor infiltrating lymphocytes. J Tradit Chin Med 2003;23: 225-9.
Stener-Victorin E. Lundeberg T.
Waldenstrom U. Manni L. Aloe L. Gunnarsson S. Janson PO. Effects of
electro-acupuncture on nerve growth factor and ovarian morphology in
rats with experimentally induced polycystic ovaries. Biol Reprod
2000;63:1497-503.
Bai YH, Lim SC, Song CH, et al.
Electro-acupuncture reverses nerve growth factor abundance in
experimental polycystic ovaries in the rat. Gynecol Obstet Invest
2004;57:80-5.
Liu X, Shen L, Wu M, Wu B, Gao L, Hu
W, Zhang A. Effects of acupuncture on myelogenic osteoclastogenesis
and IL-6 mRNA expression. J Tradit Chin Med 2004;24:144-8.
Kishi H, Mishima HK, Sakamoto I,
Yamashita U. Stimulation of retinal pigment epithelial cell growth
by neuropeptides in vitro. Curr Eye Res 1996;15:708-13.
Pakala R, Benedict CR. Effect of
serotonin and thromboxane A2 on endothelial cell proliferation:
effect of specific receptor antagonists. J Lab Clin Med
1998;131:527-37.
Siterman S, Eltes F, Wolfson V,
Zabludovsky N, Bartoov B. Effect of acupuncture on sperm parameters
of males suffering from subfertility related to low sperm quality.
Arch Androl 1997;39:155-161.21
Pei J, Strehler E, Noss U, Abt M,
Piomboni P, Baccetti B, Sterzik K. Quantitative evaluation of
spermatozoa ultrastructure after acupuncture treatment for
idiopathic male infertility. Fertil Steril. 2005;84:141-7.
Rives AW, Galitski T. Modular
organization of cellular networks. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A.
2003;100:1128-33.
Voelker CA, Miller MJ, Zhang XJ,
Eloby-Childress S, Clark DA, Pierce MR. Perinatal nitric oxide
synthase inhibition retards neonatal growth by inducing hypertrophic
pyloric stenosis in rats. Pediatr Res 1995;38:768-74.
Lee CH, Whiteman AL, Murphy CJ,
Barney NP, Taylor PB, Reid TW. Substance P, insulin like growth
factor 1, and surface healing. Arch Ophthalmol 2002;120:215-7.
Baldwin AS Jr. The NF-kappa B and I
kappa B proteins: new discoveries and insights. Annu Rev Immunol
1996;14:649-83.
Bailey CH, Bartsch D, Kandel ER.
Toward a molecular definition of long-term memory storage. Proc Natl
Acad Sci USA 1996;93:13445-52.
Tanaka H, Samuel CE. Mechanism of
interferon action: structure of the mouse PKR gene encoding the
interferon-inducible RNA-dependent protein kinase. Proc Natl Acad
Sci USA 1994;91:7995-9.
Winfree AT. A continuity principle
for regeneration. In: Malacinski GM, editor. Pattern formation. New
York: Macmillan; 1984: 106-7.
Lo CW. The role of gap junction
membrane channels in development. J Bioenerg Biomembr
1996;28:379-85,
Levin M. Isolation and community: a
review of the role of gap-junctional communication in embryonic
patterning. J Membr Biol 2002;185: 177-92.
Ewart JL, Cohen MF, Meyer RA, Huang
GY, Wessels A, Gourdie RG, Chin A, Park SMJ, Lazatin BO, Villabon S,
Lo CW. Heart and neural tube defects in transgenic mice
overexpressing the Cx43 gap junction gene. Development 1997;124:
1281-1292.
Becker DL, McGonnell I, Makarenkova
HP, Patel K, Tickle C, Lorimer J, Green CR. Roles for 1 connexin in
morphogenesis of chick embryos revealed using a novel antisense
approach. Dev Genet 1999;24: 33-42.
Chi CL, Martinez S, Wurst W, Martin
GR. The isthmic organizer signal FGF8 is required for cell survival
in the prospective midbrain and cerebellum.
Development. 2003;130:2633-44.
Toivonen S. Regionalization of the
embryo. In: Organizer – A milestone of a half- century from Spemann.
Nakamura O, Toivonen S. editors. Amsterdam: Elsevier; 1978: 124.
Carlson MR. Bryant SV. Gardiner DM.
Expression of Msx-2 during development, regeneration, and wound
healing in axolotl limbs. J Experimental Zool 1998;282:715-23.
Lee D, Malpeli JG. Global form and
singularity: modeling the blind spot's role in lateral geniculate
morphogenesis. Science 1994;263:1292-4.
Sawai S, Thomason PA, Cox EC. An
autoregulatory circuit for long-range self-organization in
Dictyostelium cell populations. Nature 2005;433, 323-326.
Diaz-Benjumea FJ, Cohen SM.
Interaction between dorsal and ventral cells in the imaginal disc
directs wing development in Drosophila. Cell. 1993;75:741-52.
Baldry P. Trigger point acupuncture.
In: Filshie J, White A, editors. Medical Acupuncture. Edinburgh:
Churchill Livingston. 1998: 35.
Neumann CJ, Cohen SM. Long-range
action of Wingless organizes the dorsal-ventral axis of the
Drosophila wing. Development. 1997;124:871-80.
Xia H, Ben-Amar Baranga A, Hoffman
D, Romalis MV. Magnetoencephalography with an atomic magnetometer.
Appl Phys Lett 2006;89:211104.
McCaig CD, Rajnicek AM, Song B, Zhao
M. Controlling cell behavior electrically: current views and future
potential. Physiol Rev. 2005;85:943-978.
Gonzalez-Crussi F. Extragonadal
teratomas. Washington, D.C.: Armed Forces Institute of Pathology.
1982:118.
Francis RJ, Lo CW. Primordial germ
cell deficiency in the connexin 43 knockout mouse arises from
apoptosis associated with abnormal p53 activation. Development.
2006;133:3451-60.
Nichols CR, Timmerman R, Foster RS,
Roth BJ, Einhorn LH. Neoplasms of the testis. In: Cancer Medicine.
Holland JF, Basst RC, Jr. Morton DL, Frei E III, Kufe DW,
Weichselbaum RR, editors. 4th ed. Baltimore: Williams & Wilkins;
1997: 2206.
Charles Shang, MD
Department of Medicine
New England Baptist Hospital
Harvard Medical School
125 Parker Hill Ave.
Boston, MA 02120
Tel: 617-754-5248
Email:
cshang@caregroup.harvard.edu
Xin and Yi: Two Minds
by Dr. Yang, Jwing-Ming, January 1, 2008
Emotional Thinking (Limbic System)
If you are interested in learning Taijiquan, you must understand Yin
and Yang, and their relationship with Taiji. Without knowing the theory
and the Dao, your Taijiquan practice will be limited to the external
forms and movements. In this case, you will have lost the real meaning
of practicing Taijiquan. Before the action of Taijiquan movement, the
Xin (emotional mind) is peaceful and the Qi is harmonious, the Xin and
Yi (wisdom mind) are at the Real Dan Tian and the Qi stays in its
residence. This is the state of extreme calmness and is the state of
Wuji. However, when the Xin and Yi begin to act, the Qi circulation
begins, the physical body?s movement is thus initiated, and the Yin and
Yang accordingly divides. From this we can see that Xin and Yi are what
is called Taiji in Taijiquan. That means the Dao of Taijiquan is the
Dao of Xin and Yi, our two minds.
The Wuji state exists inside each of us. It is the state from which all
creative impulses grow. Taiji is generated out of Wuji and is the
mother of Yin and Yang. Thus, Taiji is the cause of the Yin and Yang
division, and is itself neither Wuji nor Yin and Yang, but the cause of
the separation of Yin and Yang. In this sense it is a part of the
divine aspect of the Dao. All things can be classified as either Yin or
Yang. Taijiquan was created according to this theory. In the beginning
posture of the Taijiquan sequence, the mind is calm and empty, and the
weight is evenly distributed on both feet. This state is Wuji. When
your mind starts to lead the body into the posture of Grasp Sparrow?s
Tail , internal (Yin) and external (Yang) aspects of Taijiquan features
start to be discriminated. Moreover, the hands and feet are
differentiated into insubstantial (Yin) and substantial (Yang). This is
the state of Two Polarities. Through interaction of substantial (Yang)
and insubstantial (Yin), all of Taijiquan?s fighting strategies and
techniques are generated. From this, you can see that the Taiji (i.e.,
the Dao) in Taijiquan is actually the mind. It is the mind that makes
the body move and divides the Wuji state into Yin and Yang two
polarities. We can conclude from this that Taijiquan is actually a
martial art of the mind. Taiji means "grand ultimate". In the body, the
mind is the grand ultimate that initiates movement, Qi circulation, and
discrimination between yin and yang.
Xin and Yi are able to reach anywhere in the universe without being
restricted by time and space. From Xin and Yi, the Yin and Yang are
initiated and continue to move into unlimited variations. This is the
theory of millions of divisions and creations of Taiji. Therefore,
those who practice Taijiquan must begin from the training of Xin and
Yi. Though our physical bodies are restricted by our three-dimensional
reality, our minds are free to travel and reach anywhere in the
universe, unrestricted by time, or even beyond this universe. All human
creations, from shovels to airplanes, arose first in our imaginations.
From our thoughts, new ideas are created. It is the same for Taijiquan.
It was created from the mind, and its creation will continue without an
end. Since it is an active, living, and creative art, Taijiquan is a
product of spiritual enlightenment and an understanding of life.
The emotional mind and wisdom mind are contained internally, which
belongs to Yin. The movements (actions) of Taijiquan are manifested
externally, which belongs to Yang. When the functions of Xin and Yi are
applied to our spiritual feeling, they direct us into the correct Dao
of cultivating our human nature, through efforts toward strengthening
the mind, raise up the spirit, and comprehend the real meaning of human
life, and from this, further to comprehend the meaning and relationship
among humans, between humans and objects around us, and also to search
for the truth of nature in heaven and earth. When the function of Xin
and Yi is applied to our physical body, it is the great Dao of
cultivating the physical life for self-defense, nourishing the physical
life, and strengthening the physical body. This is the foundation for
extending our lives and establishing a firm root of health.
When Xin and Yi are acting on internal spiritual feeling, it serves to
cultivate our human temperaments and helps us to understand the meaning
of our lives. When Xin and Yi are acting and manifested externally, it
promotes physical health and self-defense. Therefore, when we practice
Taijiquan, we should cultivate both our spiritual beings (Yin) and
train our physical bodies (Yang). Taijiquan originated from the Daoist
family. Its ultimate goal is to reach enlightenment and so as to
achieve the Dao of unification between heaven and human. Therefore, the
final goal of practicing Taijiquan is to reach the unified harmonious
Wuji state of heaven and human. From practicing Taijiquan, we are able
to further comprehend the meaning of human life and the universe.
It is important that you know about the progress that has been made by
modern science in the study of Qi. This will keep you from getting
stuck in the ancient concepts and level of understanding.
In ancient China, people had very little knowledge of electricity. They
only knew from acupuncture that when a needle was inserted into the
acupuncture cavities, some kind of energy other than heat was produced
which often caused a shocking or a tickling sensation. It was not until
the last few decades, when the Chinese people were more acquainted with
electromagnetic science, that they began to recognize that this energy
circulating in the body, which they called Qi, might be the same thing
as what today's science calls "bioelectricity."
We must look at what modern Western science has discovered about
bioelectromagnetic energy. Many bioelectricity related reports have
been published, and frequently the results are closely related to what
is experienced in Chinese Qigong training and medical science. For
example, during the electrophysiological research of the 1960's,
several investigators discovered that bones are piezoelectric; that is,
when they are stressed, mechanical energy is converted to electrical
energy in the form of electric current. This might explain one of the
practices of Marrow Washing Qigong in which the stress on the bones and
muscles is increased in certain ways to increase the Qi circulation.
It is understood now that the human body is constructed of many
different electrically conductive materials, and that it forms a living
electromagnetic field and circuit. Electromagnetic energy is
continuously being generated in the human body through the biochemical
reaction in food and air assimilation, and circulated by the
electromotive forces (EMF) generated within the body.
In addition, you are constantly being affected by external
electromagnetic fields such as that of the earth, or the electrical
fields generated by clouds. When you practice Chinese medicine or
Qigong, you need to be aware of these outside factors and take them
into account.
Countless experiments have been conducted in China, Japan, and other
countries to study how external magnetic or electrical fields can
affect and adjust the body's Qi field. Many acupuncturists use magnets
and electricity in their treatments. They attach a magnet to the skin
over a cavity and leave it there for a period of time. The magnetic
field gradually affects the Qi circulation in that channel.
Alternatively, they insert needles into cavities and then run an
electric current through the needle to reach the Qi channels directly.
Although many researchers have claimed a degree of success in their
experiments, none has been able to publish any detailed and convincing
proof of the results, or give a good explanation of the theory behind
the experiment. As with many other attempts to explain the How and Why
of acupuncture, conclusive proof is elusive, and many unanswered
questions remain. Of course, this theory is quite new, and it will take
more study and research before it is verified and completely understood.
Much of the research on the body's electrical field relates to acupuncture. For example, Dr. Robert O. Becker, author of The Body Electric1, 2,
reports that the conductivity of the skin is much higher at acupuncture
cavities, and that it is now possible to locate them precisely by
measuring the skin's conductivity. Many of these reports prove that the
acupuncture which has been done in China for thousands of years is
reasonable and scientific.
Although the link between the theory of "the Body Electric" and the
Chinese theory of Qi is becoming more accepted and better proven, there
are still many questions to be answered. For example, how can the mind
lead Qi (electricity)? How actually does the mind generate an EMF
(electromotive force) to circulate the electricity in the body? How is
the human electromagnetic field affected by the multitude of other
electric fields which surround us, such as radio wiring or electrical
appliances? How can we readjust our electromagnetic fields and survive
in outer space or on other planets where the magnetic field is
completely different from the earth's? You can see that the future of
Qigong and bioelectric science is a challenging and exciting one. It is
about time that we started to use modern technology to understand the
inner energy world which has been for the most part ignored by Western
society.
This article was originally written by Dr. Yang in the 1980's.
The subject of Qi as bioelectromagnetic energy has been explored in
much greater detail since that time, by many researchers in both the
East and West. This topic is discussed in the DVD Understanding Qigong 1.
It is known that the Chinese art of Qigong has a history that goes back
over 5,000 years, though only a few historical documents exist today.
Qigong can be roughly divided into four periods. We know little about
the first period, which started when the "Yi Jing" (Book of Changes)
was introduced, sometime before 1122 B.C., and to have extended until
the Han dynasty when Buddhism and its meditation methods were imported
from India. This infusion brought Qigong practice and meditation into
the second period, the religious Qigong era, which lasted until the
Liang dynasty, when it was discovered that Qigong could be used for
martial purposes. This was the beginning of the third period, that of
martial Qigong. Many different martial Qigong styles were created based
on the theories and principles of Buddhist and Daoist Qigong. This
period lasted until the overthrow of the Qing dynasty in 1911; from
that point Chinese Qigong training was mixed with Qigong practices from
India, Japan, and many other countries.
Before the Han Dynasty
The Book of Changes was probably the first Chinese book related to Qi.
It introduced the concept of the three natural energies or powers (San
Cai): Tian (Heaven), Di (Earth), and Ren (Man). Studying the
relationship of these three natural powers was the first step in the
development of Qigong.
In 1766-1154 B.C. (the Shang dynasty), the Chinese capital was located
in today's An Yang in Henan province. An archeological dig there at a
late Shang dynasty burial ground called Yin Xu discovered more than
160,000 pieces of turtle shell and animal bone which were covered with
written characters. This writing, called "Jia Gu Wen" (Oracle-Bone
Scripture), was the earliest evidence of the Chinese use of the written
word. Most of the information recorded was of a religious nature. There
was no mention of acupuncture or other medical knowledge, even though
it was recorded in the Nei Jing that during the reign of the Yellow
emperor (2690-2590 B.C.) Bian Shi (stone probes) were already being
used to adjust people's Qi circulation.
During the Zhou dynasty (1122-934 B.C.), Lao Zi mentioned certain
breathing techniques in his classic "Dao De Jing" (Tao Te Ching)
(Classic on the Virtue of the Dao). He stressed that the way to obtain
health was to "concentrate on Qi and achieve softness". Later, "Shi Ji"
(Historical Record) in the Spring and Autumn and Warring States Periods
(770-221 B.C.) also described more complete methods of breath training.
About 300 B.C. the Daoist philosopher Zhuang Zi described the
relationship between health and the breath in his book "Nan Hua Jing."
It states: "The men of old breathed clear down to their heels..." This
was not merely a figure of speech, and confirms that a breathing method
for Qi circulation was being used by some Daoists at that time. During
the Qin and Han dynasties (221 B.C.-220 A.D.) there are several medical
references to Qigong in the literature, such as the "Nan Jing" (Classic
on Disorders) by the famous physician Bian Que, which describes using
the breathing to increase Qi circulation. "Jin Kui Yao Lue"
(Prescriptions from the Golden Chamber) by Zhang Zhong-Jing discusses
the use of breathing and acupuncture to maintain good Qi flow. "Zhou Yi
Can Tong Qi" (A Comparative Study of the Zhou (dynasty) Book of
Changes) by Wei Bo-Yang explains the relationship of human beings to
nature's forces and Qi. Up to this time, almost all of the Qigong
publications were written by scholars such as Lao Zi and Zhuang Zi, or
physicians such as Bian Que and Wei Bo-Yang.
From the Han Dynasty to the Beginning of the Liang Dynasty (206 B.C.-502 A.D.)
Because many Han emperors were intelligent and wise, the Han dynasty
was a glorious and peaceful period. It was during the Eastern Han
dynasty that Buddhism was imported to China from India. The Han emperor
became a sincere Buddhist; Buddhism soon spread and became very
popular. Many Buddhist meditation and Qigong practices, which had been
practiced in India for thousands of years, were absorbed into the
Chinese culture. The Buddhist temples taught many Qigong practices,
especially the still meditation of Chan (Zen), which marked a new era
of Chinese Qigong. Much of the deeper Qigong theory and practices that
had been developed in India were brought to China. These training
practices were kept within the temple, not taught to laypersons, and
only during this century has it slowly become available to the general
populace.
Not long after Buddhism had been imported into China, a Daoist by the
name of Zhang Dao-Ling combined the traditional Daoist principles with
Buddhism and created a religion called Dao Jiao. Many of the meditation
methods were a combination of the principles and training methods of
both sources. Since Tibet had developed its own branch of Buddhism with
its own training system and methods of attaining Buddhahood, Tibetan
Buddhists were also invited to China to preach. In time, their
practices were also absorbed.
It was in this period that the traditional Chinese Qigong practitioners
finally had a chance to compare their arts with the religious Qigong
practices imported mainly from India. While the scholarly and medical
Qigong had been concerned with maintaining and improving health, the
newly imported religious Qigong was concerned with far more.
Contemporary documents and Qigong styles show clearly that the
religious practitioners trained their Qi to a much deeper level,
working with many internal functions of the body, and strove to obtain
control of their bodies, minds, and spirits with the goal of escaping
from the cycle of reincarnation and attaining enlightenment.
While the Qigong practices and meditations were being passed down
secretly within the monasteries, traditional scholars and physicians
continued their Qigong research. During the Jin dynasty in the 3rd
century A.D., a famous physician named Hua Tuo used acupuncture for
anesthesia in surgery. The Daoist Jun Qian used the movements of
animals to create the Wu Qin Xi (Five Animal Sports), which taught
people how to increase their Qi circulation through specific movements.
Also, in this period a physician named Ge Hong mentioned in his book
Bao Pu Zi using the mind to lead and increase Qi. Sometime in the
period of 420 to 581 A.D. Tao Hong-Jing compiled the "Yang Shen Yan
Ming Lu" (Records of Nourishing the Body and Extending Life), which
showed many Qigong techniques.
From the Liang Dynasty to the End of the Qing Dynasty (502-1911 A.D.)
During the Liang dynasty (502-557 A.D.) the emperor invited a Buddhist
monk named Da Mo (Bodhidharma), who was once an Indian prince, to
preach Buddhism in China. Da Mo was the 28th ?patriarch? to carry on
the lineage after the original Buddha, Siddhartha gautama, who lived in
India during the 5th century B.C. However, the emperor decided he did
not like Da Mo's Buddhist theory, which was based on ?internal
cultivation? rather than simply doing good deeds and such to attain
enlightenment, so Da Mo eventually withdrew to the Shaolin Temple. When
Da Mo arrived, he saw that the priests were weak and sickly from
focusing only on their minds and not their bodies, so he shut himself
away to ponder the problem. He emerged after nine years of seclusion
and wrote two classics: "Yi Jin Jing" (or Yi Gin Ching) (Muscle/Tendon
Changing Classic) and "Xi Sui Jing" (or Shii Soei Ching) (Marrow/Brain
Washing Classic). The Muscle/Tendon Changing Classic taught the priests
how to gain health and change their physical bodies from weak to
strong. The Marrow/Brain Washing Classic taught the priests how to use
Qi to clean the bone marrow and strengthen the blood and immune system,
as well as how to energize the brain and attain enlightenment. Because
the Marrow/Brain Washing Classic was harder to understand and practice,
the training methods were passed down secretly to only a very few
disciples in each generation.
After the priests practiced the Muscle/Tendon Changing exercises, they
found that not only did they improve their health, but they also
greatly increased their strength. The monks were often attacked by
bandits, and so they had developed some self defense techniques. When
this Qigong training was integrated into their martial arts forms, it
increased the effectiveness of their techniques. In addition to this
martial Qigong training, the Shaolin priests also created five animal
styles of Gongfu (kung fu) which imitated the way different animals
fight. The animals imitated were the tiger, leopard, dragon, snake, and
crane.
Outside of the monastery, the development of Qigong continued during
the Sui and Tang dynasties (581-907 A.D.). Chao Yuan-Fang compiled the
"Zhu Bing Yuan Hou Lun" (Thesis on the Origins and Symptoms of Various
Diseases), which is a veritable encyclopedia of Qigong methods listing
260 different ways of increasing the Qi flow. The "Qian Jin Fang"
(Thousand Gold Prescriptions) by Sun Si-Mao described the method of
leading Qi, and also described the use of the Six Sounds. The Buddhists
and Daoists had already been using the Six Sounds to regulate Qi in the
internal organs for some time. Sun Si-Mao also introduced a massage
system called Lao Zi's 49 Massage Techniques. "Wai Tai Mi Yao" (The
Extra Important Secret) by Wang Tao discussed the use of breathing and
herbal therapies for disorders of Qi circulation.
During the Song, Jin, and Yuan dynasties (960-1368 A.D.), "Yang Shen
Jue" (Life Nourishing Secrets) by Zhang An-Dao discussed several Qigong
practices. "Ru Men Shi Shi" (The Confucian Point of View) by Zhang
Zi-He describes the use of Qigong to cure external injuries such as
cuts and sprains. "Lan Shi Mi Cang" (Secret Library of the Orchid Room)
by Li Guo describes using Qigong and herbal remedies for internal
disorders. "Ge Zhi Yu Lun" (A Further Thesis of Complete Study) by Zhu
Dan-Xi provided a theoretical explanation for the use of Qigong in
curing disease.
During the Song dynasty (960-1279 A.D.), a Daoist named Chang San-Feng
is believed to have created Taijiquan (Tai Chi Chuan), which means
?grand ultimate fist?. Tai;ji followed a different approach in its use
of Qigong than did Shaolin. While Shaolin Gongfu emphasizes Wai Dan
(External Elixir) Qigong exercises, Taiji, and the other internal arts
that followed, emphasize Nei Dan (Internal Elixir) Qigong training.
In 1026 A.D. the famous brass man of acupuncture was designed and built
by Dr. Wang Wei-Yi. Before that time, the many publications which
discussed acupuncture theory, principles, and treatment techniques
disagreed with each other, and left many points unclear. When Dr. Wang
built his brass man, he also wrote a book called "Tong Ren Yu Xue Zhen
Jiu Tu" (Illustration of the Brass Man Acupuncture and Moxibustion). He
explained the relationship of the 12 organs and the 12 Qi channels,
clarified many of the points of confusion, and, for the first time,
systematically organized acupuncture theory and principles.
In 1034 A.D. Dr. Wang used acupuncture to cure the emperor Ren Zong.
With the support of the emperor, acupuncture flourished. In order to
encourage acupuncture medical research, the emperor built a temple to
Bian Que, who wrote the Nan Jing, and worshiped him as the ancestor of
acupuncture. Acupuncture technology developed so much that even the Jin
race in the distant North requested the brass man and other acupuncture
technology as a condition for peace. Between 1102 to 1106 A.D. Dr. Wang
dissected the bodies of prisoners and added more information to the Nan
Jing. His work contributed greatly to the advancement of Qigong and
Chinese medicine by giving a clear and systematic idea of the
circulation of Qi in the human body.
Later, in the Southern Song dynasty (1127-1279 A.D.), Marshal Yue Fei
was credited with creating several internal Qigong exercises and
martial arts. It is said that he created the Eight Pieces of Brocade to
improve the health of his soldiers. He is also known as the creator of
the internal martial style Xing Yi. Eagle style martial artists also
claim that Yue Fei was the creator of their style.
From then until the end of the Qing dynasty (1911 A.D.), many other
Qigong styles were founded. The well-known ones include Hu Bu Gong
(Tiger Step Gong), Shi Er Zhuang (Twelve Postures) and Jiao Hua Gong
(Beggar Gong). Also in this period, many documents related to Qigong
were published, such as "Bao Shen Mi Yao" (The Secret Important
Document of Body Protection) by Cao Yuan-Bai, which described moving
and stationary Qigong practices; and "Yang Shen Fu Yu" (Brief
Introduction to Nourishing the Body) by Chen Ji Ru, about the three
treasures: Jing (essence), Qi (internal energy), and Shen (spirit).
Also, "Yi Fan Ji Jie" (The Total Introduction to Medical Prescriptions)
by Wang Fan-An reviewed and summarized the previously published
materials; and "Nei Gong Tu Shuo" (Illustrated Explanation of Nei Gong)
by Wang Zu-Yuan presented the Twelve Pieces of Brocade and explained
the idea of combining both moving and stationary Qigong.
In the late Ming dynasty (around 1640 A.D.), a martial Qigong style,
Huo Long Gong (Fire Dragon Gong), was created by the Taiyang martial
stylists. The well-known internal martial art style Ba Gua Zhang (or Ba
Kua Chang)(Eight Trigrams Palm) is believed to have been created by
Dong Hai-Chuan late in the Qing dynasty (1644-1911 A.D.). This style is
now gaining in popularity throughout the world. During the Qing
dynasty, Tibetan meditation and martial techniques became widespread in
China for the first time. This was due to the encouragement and
interest of the Manchurian Emperors in the royal palace, as well as
others of high rank in society.
From the End of Qing Dynasty to the Present
Before 1911 A.D., Chinese society was very conservative and
old-fashioned. Even though China had been expanding its contact with
the outside world for the previous hundred years, the outside world had
little influence beyond the coastal regions. With the overthrow of the
Qing dynasty in 1911 and the founding of the Chinese Republic, the
nation began changing as never before. Since this time Qigong practice
has entered a new era. Because of the ease of communication in the
modern world, Western culture now has great influence on the Orient.
Many Chinese have opened their minds and changed their traditional
ideas, especially in Taiwan and Hong Kong. Various Qigong styles are
now being taught openly, and many formerly secret documents are being
published. Modern methods of communication have opened up Qigong to a
much wider audience than ever before, and people now have the
opportunity to study and understand many different styles. In addition,
people are now able to compare Chinese Qigong to similar arts from
other countries such as India, Japan, Korea, and the Middle East.
I believe that in the near future Qigong will be considered the most
exciting and challenging field of research. It is an ancient science
just waiting to be investigated with the help of the new technologies
now being developed at an almost explosive rate. Anything we can do to
accelerate this research will greatly help humanity to understand and
improve itself.
There is a Chinese story about six blind men who touch an elephant to
know what it looks like. The first one touches the elephant's ear and
says, "An elephant is like a large fan." The second one touches the
side of its body and says, "No, it is like a wall." The third one
describes the leg, "No, the elephant is a pillar." The fourth one
touches the nose and shouts, "The elephant is like a big, hanging
branch of a tree!" The fifth one touches the ivory, and says, "it is a
large horn sticking out of a huge mouth". The sixth one who touches the
tail says loudly, "No, an elephant is a large swinging broom sticking
out of the wall". If they were to put all of the information together,
they would have a reasonable description of the elephant. This story
shows we should not stubbornly insist there is only one viewpoint, as
we often see only part of the story. There is always more to learn.
Don't waste time in only theoretical research. Practice and theory
should go together. From practice, you gain experience, and from
theory, you have a clear guideline for practice. Some people hesitate
due to the danger involved in martial arts, qigong, or meditation,
accomplishing nothing and simply wasting time. Be cautious but
determined, and learn from the experience of others, and you will find
the right path. Study the Classics passed down in the lineage of your
art. Find a teacher, and practice, practice, practice.
Buddha traveled the countryside one day and came to a river. An old
Qigong master lived there, who asked him, "You are the Buddha? If so,
can you do the same thing I can? I cross the river by walking on top of
the water!" Buddha said, "That is very impressive. But how long have
you practiced it?" The old man replied proudly, "It took me nearly
forty years to achieve it." The Buddha looked at him and said, "It took
you forty years! It takes me only a few coins to cross the river on the
ferryboat."
Often we spend too much time on unimportant things. Treat your time
preciously and use it efficiently. Get rid of your dignity. If you take
your dignity too seriously, you will not find a sincere teacher willing
to teach from the heart.
A young Samurai swordsman entered the house of a famous Zen master. He
looked at the master, bowed and said, "Master! I have reached a deep
level of Zen, both in theory and practice. I have heard you are great
so I come here to bow to you and hope you can teach me something." The
Zen master looked at this proud young man. Without a word, he went into
the back room and brought out a teapot and a teacup. He placed the cup
in front of the young man and started to pour the tea into the cup. The
tea filled the cup quickly and soon began to overflow. The young man
looked at the old man with a confused expression. He said, "Stop,
master! The teacup is overflowing". The old Zen master put the teapot
down and smiled at him. He said, "This is you. You are too full
already. I cannot teach you. If you wish to learn, you must first empty
your cup." Can you be humble?
When you find a good qualified teacher or source of learning, treat it
preciously, so you don't miss the opportunity of learning. This chance
may not come again.
Traditionally, it was very difficult to find a qualified teacher. Even
if you found one, you would not necessarily be accepted. Today, it is
easier to collect information since there are so many books, and DVDs
available. But the guidance of an experienced teacher is crucial to
reach the final goal. Subtle advice can save you a great deal of time
and effort. When you are lost in a big city, even though you have read
the map, guidance from a passerby could save a lot of effort.
A young man had already spent more than seven years searching for a
good master. He came to where a great teacher lived deep in the remote
mountains with a few students. He was received kindly and expressed his
intention of learning from the master. The master looked at him for a
while, then brought out a teapot and a teacup.
He poured tea into the cup, stopping when the tea reached the brim. He
put the teapot down with a smile, hinting to the young man that the
place was already full. He could not accept another student. The young
man looked at the cup and realized what it meant. He lowered his head
in sadness. Noticing a rice straw on the floor, he picked it up and
carefully stuck it into the tea. The tea did not overflow. He looked at
the master's face with hope, showing him, Look, there is still space
for me. The tea did not overflow. Through this silent communication,
the old master realized that the young man was one of those rare
intelligent ones who could comprehend the profound feeling of the art.
He accepted him with delight. It is very difficult to find a humble and
intelligent student able to comprehend the art deeply and to develop
it. When a teacher finds this kind of student, it will be like a
precious pearl in his hands.
I don?t often write about alternative remedies for serious medical conditions. Most have little more than anecdotal support, and few have been found effective in well-designed clinical trials. Such trials randomly assign patients to one of two or more treatments and, wherever possible, assess the results without telling either the patients or evaluators who received which treatment.
Now, however, in describing an alternative treatment for asthma that does not yet have top clinical ratings in this country (although it is taught in Russian medical schools and covered by insurance in Australia), I am going beyond my usually stringent research criteria for three reasons:
?The treatment, a breathing technique discovered half a century ago, is harmless if practiced as directed with a well-trained therapist.
?It has the potential to improve the health and quality of life of many people with asthma, while saving health care dollars.
?I?ve seen it work miraculously well for a friend who had little choice but to stop using thesteroid medications that were keeping him alive.
My friend, David Wiebe, 58, of Woodstock, N.Y., is a well-known maker of violins and cellos, with a 48-year history of severe asthma that was treated with bronchodilators and steroids for two decades. Ten years ago, Mr. Wiebe noticed gradually worsening vision problems, eventually diagnosed as a form of macular degeneration caused by the steroids. Two leading retina specialists told him to stop using the drugs if he wanted to preserve his sight.
He did, and endured several terrifying trips to the emergency room when asthma attacks raged out of control and forced him to resume steroids temporarily to stay alive.
Nothing else he tried seemed to work. ?After having a really poor couple of years with significantly reduced quality of life and performance at work,? he told me, ?I was ready to give up my eyesight and go back on steroids just so I could breathe better.?
Treatment From the ?50s
Then, last spring, someone told him about the Buteyko method, a shallow-breathing technique developed in 1952 by a Russian doctor, Konstantin Buteyko. Mr. Wiebe watched a video demonstration on YouTube and mimicked the instructions shown.
?I could actually feel my airways relax and open,? he recalled. ?This was impressive. Two of the participants on the video were basically incapacitated by their asthma and on disability leave from their jobs. They each admitted that keeping up with the exercises was difficult but said they had been able to cut back on their medications by about 75 percent and their quality of life was gradually returning.?
A further search uncovered the Buteyko Center USA in his hometown, newly established as the official North American representative of the Buteyko Clinic in Moscow.
?When I came to the center, I was without hope,? Mr. Wiebe said. ?I was using my rescue inhaler 20 or more times in a 24-hour period. If I was exposed to any kind of irritant or allergen, I could easily get a reaction that jeopardized my existence and forced me to go back on steroids to save my life. I was a mess.?
But three months later, after a series of lessons and refresher sessions in shallow breathing, he said, ?I am using less than one puff of the inhaler each day ? no drugs, just breathing exercises.?
Mr. Wiebe doesn?t claim to be cured, though he believes this could eventually happen if he remains diligent about the exercises. But he said: ?My quality of life has improved beyond my expectations. It?s very exciting and amazing. More people should know about this.?
Ordinarily, during an asthma attack, people panic and breathe quickly and as deeply as they can, blowing off more and more carbon dioxide. Breathing rate is controlled not by the amount of oxygen in the blood but by the amount of carbon dioxide, the gas that regulates the acid-base level of the blood.
Dr. Buteyko concluded that hyperventilation ? breathing too fast and too deeply ? could be the underlying cause of asthma, making it worse by lowering the level of carbon dioxide in the blood so much that the airways constrict to conserve it.
This technique may seem counterintuitive: when short of breath or overly stressed, instead of taking a deep breath, the Buteyko method instructs people to breathe shallowly and slowly through the nose, breaking the vicious cycle of rapid, gasping breaths, airway constriction and increased wheezing.
The shallow breathing aspect intrigued me because I had discovered its benefits during my daily lap swims. I noticed that swimmers who had to stop to catch their breath after a few lengths of the pool were taking deep breaths every other stroke, whereas I take in small puffs of air after several strokes and can go indefinitely without becoming winded.
The Buteyko practitioners in Woodstock, Sasha and Thomas Yakovlev-Fredricksen, were trained in Moscow by Dr. Andrey Novozhilov, a Buteyko disciple. Their treatment involves two courses of five sessions each: one in breathing technique and the other in lifestyle management. The breathing exercises gradually enable clients to lengthen the time between breaths. Mr. Wiebe, for example, can now take a breath after more than 10 seconds instead of just 2 while at rest.
Responses May Vary
His board-certified pulmonologist, Dr. Marie C. Lingat, told me: ?Based on objective data, his breathing has improved since April even without steroids. The goal now is to make sure he maintains the improvement. The Buteyko method works for him, but that doesn?t mean everyone who has asthma would respond in the same way.?
In an interview, Mrs. Yakovlev-Fredricksen said: ?People don?t realize that too much air can be harmful to health. Almost every asthmatic breathes through his mouth and takes deep, forceful inhalations that trigger a bronchospasm,? the hallmark of asthma.
?We teach them to inhale through the nose, even when they speak and when they sleep, so they don?t lose too much carbon dioxide,? she added.
At the Woodstock center, clients are also taught how to deal with stress and how toexercise without hyperventilating and to avoid foods that in some people can provoke an asthma attack.
The practitioners emphasize that Buteyko clients are never told to stop their medications, though in controlled clinical trials in Australia and elsewhere, most have been able to reduce their dependence on drugs significantly. The various trials, including a British study of 384 patients, have found that, on average, those who are diligent about practicing Buteyko breathing can expect a 90 percent reduction in the use of rescue inhalers and a 50 percent reduction in the need for steroids within three to six months.
The British Thoracic Society has given the technique a ?B? rating, meaning that positive results of the trials are likely to have come from the Buteyko method and not some other factor. Now, perhaps, it is time for the pharmaceutically supported American medical community to explore this nondrug technique as well.
This is the first of two columns. Next week: The pros and cons of steroid treatments.
WINTER HARBOR ? Dr. Benjamin Newman, the ?Village Doc? in Winter
Harbor, recently returned from a conference in Toronto that was part of
?Vitamin D Action,? an international public health project focused on
addressing vitamin D deficiencies.
Newman said more and more scientists are recognizing the link
between vitamin D deficiencies and a range of serious medical
conditions.
For instance, the Mayo Clinic in Rochester, Minn., notes that
vitamin D offers many benefits, especially for older adults, such as
improved balance, reduction in the risk of bone fractures, and better
thinking skills.
The Mayo Clinic goes on to state that low levels of vitamin D are
associated with diabetes, cardiovascular disease, multiple sclerosis
and other autoimmune disorders, and infections such as tuberculosis and
periodontal disease. Low vitamin D levels also may affect certain
cancers, including colon, breast and prostate cancers.
It is widely accepted that residents 42 degrees north latitude of
Boston have the highest incidences of vitamin D deficiencies because of
reduced sun exposure due to the angle of the sun.
The following are excerpts from an interview with Newman about the conference and vitamin D.
Q. When did you first get involved with vitamin D?
A. About 10 years ago. I started noticing
associations between vitamin D deficiencies and medical problems in
patients. I?m a clinician, not a researcher. It was purely
observational. Double blind, randomized controlled trials mean more,
but you can?t deny the observations of someone who has been in practice
for a while.
Q. How long have you been checking vitamin D levels in patients?
A. I started 15 years ago in the Navy, where money wasn?t a problem.
Q. How were our vitamin D levels eons ago?
A. In the development of man when we lived near the
equator and didn?t wear clothes we had on average 100 to 160 nanograms
per milliliter. (A nanogram is one-billionth of a gram. A gram is about
1/30 of an ounce. A milliliter is equal to 1/1,000 liter. A liter is a
little bigger than a quart).
Q. When you test patients, what are their vitamin D levels on average?
A. The average by laboratory test is 30-80 nanograms.
Q. How much should we have today?
A. I want my patients at 50-to-60 nanograms. That?s where we reap the most benefits.
Q. What is vitamin D?
A. Vitamin D is a hormone, not a vitamin, and it
controls 2,000 genes. When you?re talking a compound that controls
2,000 genes you?re talking the atomic bomb. Every cell in the body
makes vitamin D. You can get most nutrients one way or another from a
good diet. Vitamin D is the exception.
Q. What does it do?
A. Take the flu virus, for example. The body
stimulates cells to produce a chemical to destroy the germ. Vitamin D
is a messenger to make or not make that chemical.
Q. Traditionally, what level of vitamin D have doctors found to be acceptable?
A. Thirty nanograms. That prevents rickets.
Q. What is the recommended daily dose of vitamin D?
A. The current daily recommended dose of vitamin D
for adults 50 and older is 400 to 600 international units (IU). Eighty
five years go you were told to take 400 units daily. Europe now
recommends 800 units for children up to 5, and then 1,000 units a day
after that. In Norway, where they have a high incidence of juvenile
diabetes, all newborns are now put on vitamin D. The rate of juvenile
diabetes in 16-year-olds has since decreased by 40 percent.
We haven?t increased the recommended dosages here. There is tremendous inertia in the medical profession.
Q. What do you mean by inertia?
A. Take Joseph Lister. In 1870, he noticed an
association between washing hands and reducing death by infection. He
was laughed out of town. Hand washing did not become the accepted
practice in the United States until 1910. It wasn?t until the early
1960s that doctors in the operating room routinely put a mask over
their noses.
Q. How much vitamin D should we be taking daily?
A. That needs to be determined by your doctor and
the results of a lab test. It varies from patient to patient. There is
no substitute for sitting down with a patient to determine, along with
a blood test, what they need.
Q. At what levels can vitamin D be toxic?
A. It is extremely difficult to take toxic levels
of vitamin D. We know if you take 30,000 units a day there will be no
toxicity. To put that in perspective, there are 50,000 units in 1.25
milligrams. Baby aspirin is 81 milligrams.
Q. What diseases and illness can vitamin D cure and/or prevent?
A. Observationally, it appears that vitamin D is as
good as a flu shot in preventing the flu. It helps prevent falls in old
age, which is one of the leading cause of death in the elderly.
Researchers have found there is a 67-70 percent reduction in the
incidence of breast cancer, type 1 diabetes, multiple sclerosis and
colon cancer.
Q. What is the best way to get vitamin D?
A. Sun is the best source of vitamin D, but only
ultraviolet B (UVB) rays in the sun make vitamin D in the skin. And UVB
rays are only one percent of the rays from the sun. As you get older
and darker, your ability to convert the sun?s rays to vitamin D is
significantly reduced. African-Americans, for instance, get little
vitamin D from the sun.
Q. During what months are Mainers most likely to need a boost in vitamin D?
A. September through April, because of the angle of
the sun 42 degrees latitude and north. If you live below 42 degrees
latitude and you?re young and you?re walking around in a bathing suit,
you can make 10,000 units of vitamin D in 10 minutes.
Q. What type of vitamin D supplement should people be taking?
A. Vitamin D3 is preferred. You can buy it over the
counter, but you need to know what you?re taking. The problem is that
over the counter supplements is an unregulated industry and there is no
guarantee that what is in them is what you think is in them.
The best non-pharmacological way to get vitamin D is the sun. All
you need is 20 minutes outside, three times a week, exposing your arms
and face, or arms and legs. It?s still not enough, but the sun exposure
won?t cause cancer or wrinkles at this level. Using sunblock or
sunscreen will prevent the sun from producing vitamin D in the skin.
Q. How much does the blood test cost?
A. I can do it for $70.
Q. What would the average regimen of vitamin D cost for the year?
A. $35. Even if it doesn?t change anything, what have you lost?
Koryo Hand Therapy is a scientific medical system that is quite simple
to learn and easy to perform without any
side effects or danger. If you have a problem or pain somewhere in your
body, the reactions are reflected on the
hands in the form of tender points. Pain commonly or frequently shown on
the hands corresponds to the painful
part of your body. Therefore, the stimulation of the tender points
positively affects pain relief.
Alarm points are located on the abdomen and chest, they are in close to
their related Zang-Fu organ, and may be tender or sensitive if there is
disharmony in the underlying organ. Visual examination, obtaining
certain reactions when pressing the
point or spontaneous sensation at the point are all significant
diagnostic information.
The five element theory is the cornerstone of acupuncture and meridian
therapy. This chart clearly shows the relationship of the five elements
(Fire, Earth, Metal, Water and Wood).
This chart contains 41 Cardinal points that are specific for conditions,
functions and areas of the body. Each point is mapped out, listed by
condition, point name is also listed by Chinese name with detailed
description of point location.
The Acupuncture Bookshelf
Please browse around our Acupuncture book shelf. Any books you
purchase will help to support our non–commercial website.
Guidelines on Basic Training and Safety in Acupuncture
World Health Organization; 1999; 35 pages (Adobe
Acrobat)
The increasing popularity in recent years of acupuncture as a form of
therapy and the interest of some countries in introducing it into
primary health care mean that national health authorities must ensure
safety and competence in its use.
Acupuncture: Review and Analysis of Reports on Controlled Clinical
Trials
World Health Organization; 2003; 87 pages (Adobe
Acrobat 2.18 MB)
In recognition of the increasing worldwide interest in acupuncture, the
World Health Organization (WHO) conducted a symposium on acupuncture in
June 1979 in Beijing, China. Physicians practising acupuncture in
different countries were invited to identify the conditions that might
benefit from this therapy. The participants drew up a list of 43
suitable diseases. However, this list of indications was not based on
formal clinical trials conducted in a rigorous scientific manner, and
its credibility has been questioned. The past two decades have seen
extensive studies on acupuncture, and great efforts have been made to
conduct controlled clinical trials that include the use of “sham”
acupuncture or “placebo” acupuncture controls. Although still limited in
number because of the difficulties of carrying out such trials,
convincing reports, based on sound research methodology, have been
published. In 1996, a draft report on the clinical practice of
acupuncture was reviewed at the WHO Consultation on Acupuncture held in
Cervia, Italy. The participants recommended that WHO should revise the
report, focusing on data from controlled clinical trials. This
publication is the outcome of that process.
Acupuncture Information and Resources
This collection was developed by the National
Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine (NCCAM) @
the National Institutes of Health (NIH)
The Consensus Development Statement on the Use of Acupuncture
Acupuncture is an effective treatment for nausea caused by cancer
chemotherapy drugs, surgical anesthesia, and pregnancy; and for pain
resulting from surgery and a variety of musculoskeletal conditions, an
expert panel concluded. The panel of non–Federal, non–advocate experts
was convened in November 1997 for the NIH
Consensus Development Conference on Acupuncture, cosponsored
by the OAM and the Office
of Medical Applications of Research (OMAR). (NIH)
Position Statement on "Traditional Medicine"
The World Health Organization (WHO)
says: "Traditional medicine" refers to ways of protecting and restoring
health that existed before the arrival of modern medicine. As the term
implies, these approaches to health belong to the traditions of each
country, and have been handed down from generation to generation.
Traditional systems in general have had to meet the needs of the local
communities for many centuries. China and India, for example, have
developed very sophisticated systems such as acupuncture and ayurvedic
medicine. In practice, the term "traditional medicine" refers to the
following components: acupuncture, traditional birth attendants, mental
healers and herbal medicine.
AMAC Position Paper on Laser Acupuncture
Japan and several Scandinavian countries are at the forefront of
clinical research work with laser. Low Level Laser Therapy (LLLT) is
also used in Australia, Canada, France, Korea, People's Republic of
China, U.K. and many other countries. A tissue repair research unit,
examining the effects of laser, now exists at Guy's Hospital, London.
Many centres of research are now developing around the world.
What is Electro Meridian Imaging (EMI)?
The Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM) analysis for the the meridian
system is based on pulse diagnosis. This involves taking pulse readings,
twice on each wrist; the first three lightly, and the next three deeply
(for a total of 12 readings). All this changed in the early 1950s, with
the development of Ryodoraku by Dr. Yoshio Nakatani of Japan. Nakatani
developed his procedure of electronic evaluation by measuring skin
conductance at the yuan (source) points of the wrist and ankle. He
created one of the most significant acupuncture diagnostic methods yet
created in either contemporary or traditional acupuncture.
The Neuroimmune Basis of Anti-inflammatory Acupuncture
Integrative Cancer Therapies 2007 (Sep); 6 (3): 251–257 ~ FULL TEXT
This review article presents the evidence that the antiinflammatory
actions of acupuncture are mediated via the reflexive central inhibition
of the innate immune system. Both laboratory and clinical evidence have
recently shown the existence of a negative feedback loop between the
autonomic nervous system and the innate immunity. There is also
experimental evidence that the electrical stimulation of the vagus nerve
inhibits macrophage activation and the production of TNF, IL-1beta ,
IL-6, IL-18, and other proinflammatory cytokines. It is therefore
conceivable that along with hypnosis, meditation, prayer, guided
imagery, biofeedback, and the placebo effect, the systemic
anti-inflammatory actions of traditional and electro-acupuncture are
directly or indirectly mediated by the efferent vagus nerve activation
and inflammatory macrophage deactivation. The use of acupuncture as an
adjunct therapy to conventional medical treatment for a number of
chronic inflammatory and autoimmune diseases seems plausible and should
be validated by confirming its cholinergicity.
Patients Seeking Care from Acupuncture Practitioners in the UK: A
National Survey
Complement Ther Med. 2006 (Mar); 14 (1): 20–30
Who seeks acupuncture treatment? According to this survey of 9408
acupuncture patients in the UK, 74% of patients were female. The most
common main problem or symptom reported by patients was musculo-skeletal
(38%), followed by psychological (11%), general (9%), neurological (8%)
and gynaecological/obstetric (8%), while 3% of patients were seeking
treatment for their general well-being.
Acupuncture for Upper-Extremity Rehabilitation in Chronic Stroke:A
Randomized Sham-Controlled Study
Arch Phys Med Rehabil 2005 (Dec); 86 (12): 2248–2255
Based on ITT analyses, we conclude that acupuncture does not improve UE
function or QOL in patients with chronic stroke symptoms. However, gains
in UE function observed in protocol-compliant subjects suggest
traditional Chinese acupuncture may help patients with chronic stroke
symptoms. These results must be interpreted cautiously because of small
sample sizes and multiple, unadjusted, post hoc comparisons. A larger,
more definitive RCT using a similar design is feasible and warranted.
New Reporting Method for Acupuncture Services to Begin in January
2005
Beginning Jan. 1, 2005, there will be a new reporting method for
acupuncture services. Effective on that date, CPT codes 97780
(acupuncture, one or more needles; without electrical stimulation) and
97781 (acupuncture, one or more needles; with electrical stimulation)
will be deleted. Four new codes have been developed for reporting
acupuncture services.
Acupuncture of Chronic Headache Disorders in Primary Care: Randomised
Controlled Trial and Economic Analysis
Health Technol Assess 2004 (Nov); 8 (48): 1–50
Patients in the acupuncture group experienced the equivalent of 22 fewer
days of headache per year. SF-36 data favoured acupuncture, although
differences reached significance only for physical role functioning,
energy and change in health. Compared with controls, patients randomised
to acupuncture used 13% less medication, made 23% fewer visits to GPs
and took 13% fewer days off sick. The study suggests that acupuncture
leads to persisting, clinically relevant benefits for primary care
patients with chronic headache, particularly migraine.
Acupuncture Using Laser Needles Modulates Brain Function: First Evidence
from Functional Transcranial Doppler Sonography and Functional Magnetic
Resonance Imaging
Lasers Med Sci 2004 (Aug); 19 (1): 6–11
Acupuncture using laser needles is a new totally painless stimulation
method which has been described for the first time. This paper presents
an experimental double-blind study in acupuncture research in healthy
volunteers using a new optical stimulation method. Significant changes (
p<0.05) of brain activity were demonstrated in the occipital and
frontal gyrus by fMRI. Optical stimulation using properly adjusted laser
needles has the advantage that the stimulation cannot be felt by the
patient (painless and no tactile stimulation) and the operator may also
be unaware of whether the stimulation system is active. Therefore true
double-blind studies in acupuncture research can be performed.
Writing Case Reports – Author Guidelines for Acupuncture in Medicine
Acupuncture in Medicine 2004 (Mar); 22 (2): 83–86 ~ FULL TEXT
Case reports are particularly valuable in specialist clinical areas such
as acupuncture to report new adverse events and to suggest possible new
hypotheses. They can also be used to report events that have been
reported previously but are rare or serious, in order to illustrate
their frequency. They may illuminate the wider side of clinical practice
by describing personal experiences of one practitioner.
Constraints to writing case reports include finding time, working in
isolation, and not having enough experience at the task. This article
reproduces and develops a set of guidelines that were previously
published, in an attempt to help authors to write thorough but succinct
reports in a structured manner.
An Audit of the Effectiveness of Acupuncture on Musculoskeletal Pain in
Primary Health Care
Acupuncture in Medicine 2002 (Mar); 20 (1): 22–25 We found an association between the general practitioner using fewer
needles and patients experiencing greater pain relief. This could be
a reflection of treating myofascial pain syndromes, which often appear
to respond well to a single needle in the key trigger point. Overall, we
found that sixty-nine percent of patients had a good or excellent
response to acupuncture treatment.
Informed Consent for Acupuncture An Information Leaflet Developed by
Consensus
Acupuncture in Medicine 2001 (Dec); 19 (2): 123–130
Patients have the right to be fully informed about the likely benefits
and risks of any proposed examination or treatment, and practitioners
are obliged to obtain informed consent beforehand. Accurate information
about the risks of acupuncture is available following publication of the
results of two prospective surveys. An informed consent form is
provided.
Standards for Reporting Interventions in Controlled Trials of
Acupuncture: The STRICTA Recommendations
Acupuncture in Medicine 2002 (Mar); 20 (1): 22–25
Acupuncture treatment and control group interventions in parallel-group
randomised trials of acupuncture are not always precisely reported. In
an attempt to improve standards, an international group of experienced
acupuncturists and researchers devised a set of recommendations,
designating them STRICTA: STandards for Reporting Interventions in
Controlled Trials of Acupuncture. FULL TEXT available
Characteristics of Visits to Licensed Acupuncturists, Chiropractors,
Massage Therapists, and Naturopathic Physicians
J Am Board Fam Pract 2002 (Nov-Dec); 15 (6): 463–480 ~ FULL TEXT
More than 80% of visits to CAM providers were by young and middle-aged
adults, and roughly two thirds were by women. Children comprised 10% of
visits to naturopathic physicians but only 1% to 4% of all visits to
other CAM providers. At least two thirds of visits resulted from
self-referrals, and only 4% to 12% of visits were from conventional
physician referrals. Most visits to chiropractors and naturopathic
physicians, but less than one third of visits to acupuncturists and
massage therapists, were covered by insurance.
Acupuncture: Efficacy, Safety and Practice
Up to five million people may have consulted a therapist specialising in
complementary and alternative medicine (CAM) in the last year with an
incalculable extra number consulting a doctor or other health
professional practising CAM. A new report from the British Medical
Association, published today (6–25–2000), looks at the usefulness,
safety and availability of acupuncture – one of the most widely
requested treatments.
Clinical Trials of Acupuncture: Consensus Recommendations for Optimal
Treatment, Sham Controls and Blinding
Complement Ther in Medicine 2001 (Dec); 9 (4): 237–245 ~ FULL TEXT
Evidence of effectiveness is increasingly used to determine which health
technologies are incorporated into public health provision. Acupuncture
is a popular therapy that has been shown to be superior to placebo in
the treatment of nausea and dental pain, and promising for migraine and
osteoarthritis of the knee. For many other conditions, such as chronic
pain, in which acupuncture is often used, the evidence is either
insufficient or negative. Misleading results may occur for a number of
reasons. False negative results may arise from inadequate treatment
schedules and inappropriate control interventions. This consensus
document considers these issues with the aim of improving the design of
efficacy trials of acupuncture in order that they are more likely to be
conclusive and more meaningfully interpreted.
The FULL TEXT file is available
Acupuncture ~ A Complementary Treatment in General Practice
Tidsskr Nor Laegeforen 2002; 122 (9) May 10: 921–923
THIS REVIEW FOUND THAT: Acupuncture is the complementary treatment most
commonly used by general (medical) practitioners. UNFORTUNATELY: "78%
had acupuncture courses of less than four weeks' duration" AND
THE MAJOR COMPLAINT WAS "Lack of time was regarded as the major
limitation to the use of acupuncture." YEAH...ESPECIALLY THE TIME THEY
INVESTED TO LEARN IT! UGH!
Acupuncture as Complementary Therapy for Back Pain
Holist Nurs Pract 2001; 15 (3) Apr: 35–44
Research has demonstrated that acupuncture may benefit those who suffer
from back pain when they have failed to respond to previous treatment by
drugs, bed rest, epidural injection, physiotherapy, osteopathy,
chiropractics, and surgery. Acupuncture is a powerful and complementary
therapy for back pain.
Acupuncture Treatment During Labour: A Randomised Controlled Trial
BJOG 2002; 109 (6) Jun: 637–644
Acupuncture treatment during labour significantly reduced the need of
epidural analgesia . Parturients who received acupuncture assessed a
significantly better degree of relaxation compared with the control
group. No negative effects of acupuncture given during labour were found
in relation to delivery outcome.
Texas Attorney General Restricts Acupuncturists from "Manipulation"
For the past several years, the Texas Board of Chiropractic Examiners
(TBCE) has received complaints, some quite serious, of patients injured
by acupuncturists allegedly performing spinal manipulations. The TBCE
forwarded the complaints to the appropriate regulatory body, the Texas
State Board of Acupuncture Examiners (TSBAE), with the appeal for them
to take action. Read the decision by the
Texas Attorney General.
Acupuncture Superior to Drug Therapy for Migraines
In one of the largest studies of its kind to date, a team of
investigators in Italy examined the effectiveness of acupuncture versus a
variety of pharmacological therapies in treating migraines. Their
results, published in a recent issue of the Journal of Traditional
Chinese Medicine, revealed that patients given acupuncture experienced
fewer migraine episodes, missed fewer days from work, and suffered no
side effects compared to patients on conventional drug therapy. They
also found acupuncture to be more cost–efficient, estimating a savings
of hundreds of millions of dollars in private and social health
expenditures if it were used to treat headaches alone instead of drugs.
Acupuncture and Stroke Recovery
Johansson et al (1993) investigated the effectiveness of acupuncture as a
supplement to physical therapy in recovery from stroke. Pang (1994)
investigated two particular scalp acupuncture techniques in order to
compare their effectiveness in treating apoplexy following stroke.
Acupuncture and Raynaud's Disease
A recent study indicates that acupuncture surpasses drug treatment for
Raynaud's disease, a vascular disorder that causes the small arteries of
the hands and, less commonly, the feet to spasm during exposure to cold
or stress. The appendages go white and sometimes hurt due to
insufficient blood flow.
Acupuncture and Crack–Cocaine Addiction
Lipton et al (1994) investigated ear acupuncture in treatment of cocaine
dependency over a one–month period. 150 patients were randomly assigned
to an experimental group and a placebo–control group. Konefal, Duncan
and Clemence (1994) found a 57% reduction in the time it took to achieve
a negative urine test with acupuncture.
Acupuncture Wins British Medical Association Approval
Acupuncture should become more widely available on the NHS and family
doctors should be trained in some of its techniques, a BMA inquiry has
concluded. The therapy has proved effective in
treating back and dental pain, nausea and vomiting, and migraine, the
BMA's Board of Science and Education has found after a two year study.
Beyond Endorphins in Acupuncture Analgesia: The Science Behind the
Art
In the last 20 years much has been written about acupuncture and its
efficiency in relieving pain. The ancient Chinese clinicians practised
acupuncture based on Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM) principles
using well established guidelines. Their reasoning were based on
empirical responses rather than scientific principles. This discussion
hopes to bring to
highlight some recent research findings.
The Acupuncture Bookshelf
Please browse around our Acupuncture book shelf. Any books you
purchase will help to support our non–commercial website.
Guidelines on Basic Training and Safety in Acupuncture
World Health Organization; 1999; 35 pages (Adobe
Acrobat)
The increasing popularity in recent years of acupuncture as a form of
therapy and the interest of some countries in introducing it into
primary health care mean that national health authorities must ensure
safety and competence in its use.
Acupuncture: Review and Analysis of Reports on Controlled Clinical
Trials
World Health Organization; 2003; 87 pages (Adobe
Acrobat 2.18 MB)
In recognition of the increasing worldwide interest in acupuncture, the
World Health Organization (WHO) conducted a symposium on acupuncture in
June 1979 in Beijing, China. Physicians practising acupuncture in
different countries were invited to identify the conditions that might
benefit from this therapy. The participants drew up a list of 43
suitable diseases. However, this list of indications was not based on
formal clinical trials conducted in a rigorous scientific manner, and
its credibility has been questioned. The past two decades have seen
extensive studies on acupuncture, and great efforts have been made to
conduct controlled clinical trials that include the use of “sham”
acupuncture or “placebo” acupuncture controls. Although still limited in
number because of the difficulties of carrying out such trials,
convincing reports, based on sound research methodology, have been
published. In 1996, a draft report on the clinical practice of
acupuncture was reviewed at the WHO Consultation on Acupuncture held in
Cervia, Italy. The participants recommended that WHO should revise the
report, focusing on data from controlled clinical trials. This
publication is the outcome of that process.
Acupuncture Information and Resources
This collection was developed by the National
Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine (NCCAM) @
the National Institutes of Health (NIH)
The Consensus Development Statement on the Use of Acupuncture
Acupuncture is an effective treatment for nausea caused by cancer
chemotherapy drugs, surgical anesthesia, and pregnancy; and for pain
resulting from surgery and a variety of musculoskeletal conditions, an
expert panel concluded. The panel of non–Federal, non–advocate experts
was convened in November 1997 for the NIH
Consensus Development Conference on Acupuncture, cosponsored
by the OAM and the Office
of Medical Applications of Research (OMAR). (NIH)
Position Statement on "Traditional Medicine"
The World Health Organization (WHO)
says: "Traditional medicine" refers to ways of protecting and restoring
health that existed before the arrival of modern medicine. As the term
implies, these approaches to health belong to the traditions of each
country, and have been handed down from generation to generation.
Traditional systems in general have had to meet the needs of the local
communities for many centuries. China and India, for example, have
developed very sophisticated systems such as acupuncture and ayurvedic
medicine. In practice, the term "traditional medicine" refers to the
following components: acupuncture, traditional birth attendants, mental
healers and herbal medicine.
AMAC Position Paper on Laser Acupuncture
Japan and several Scandinavian countries are at the forefront of
clinical research work with laser. Low Level Laser Therapy (LLLT) is
also used in Australia, Canada, France, Korea, People's Republic of
China, U.K. and many other countries. A tissue repair research unit,
examining the effects of laser, now exists at Guy's Hospital, London.
Many centres of research are now developing around the world.
What is Electro Meridian Imaging (EMI)?
The Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM) analysis for the the meridian
system is based on pulse diagnosis. This involves taking pulse readings,
twice on each wrist; the first three lightly, and the next three deeply
(for a total of 12 readings). All this changed in the early 1950s, with
the development of Ryodoraku by Dr. Yoshio Nakatani of Japan. Nakatani
developed his procedure of electronic evaluation by measuring skin
conductance at the yuan (source) points of the wrist and ankle. He
created one of the most significant acupuncture diagnostic methods yet
created in either contemporary or traditional acupuncture.
Merck is committed to bringing out the best in
medicine. As
part of that effort, Merck has created The Merck Manuals, a series
of healthcare books for medical professionals and consumers. As
a service to the community, the content of The Manuals is now available
in enhanced online versions as part of The Merck Manuals Online
Medical Library. The Online Medical Library is updated periodically
with new information, and contains photographs, and audio and video
material not present in the print versions.
Important: The authors, reviewers, and editors
of this book have made extensive efforts to ensure that treatments,
drugs, and dosage regimens are accurate and conform to the standards
accepted at the time of publication. However, constant changes in
information resulting from continuing research and clinical experience,
reasonable differences in opinions among authorities, unique aspects
of individual clinical situations, and the possibility of human
error in preparing such an extensive text require that the reader
exercise individual judgment when making a clinical decision and,
if necessary, consult and compare information from other sources.
In particular, the reader is advised to check the product information
provided by the manufacturer of a drug product before prescribing
or administering it, especially if the drug is unfamiliar or is used
infrequently.
THE RESPONSIBLE PARENT'S GUIDE
TO HEALTHY MOOD-BOOSTERS
FOR ALL THE FAMILY
INTRODUCTION
Could we live happily ever after? Perhaps. One's interest in the
genetically pre-programmed states of sublimity
sketched in The Hedonistic Imperative
is tempered by the knowledge that one is unlikely to be around to enjoy
them. It's all very well being told our descendants
will experience every moment of their lives as a magical epiphany. For emotional
primitives and our loved ones
at present, most of life's moments bring nothing
of the sort. In centuries to come, our emotional well-being
may indeed surpass anything that human legacy wetware can even contemplate.
Right now, however, any future Post-Darwinian
Era of paradise-engineering can seem
an awfully long way off. Mainstream society today has a desperately underdeveloped
conception of mental health.
There's
clearly a strong causal link between the raw
biological capacity to experience happiness
and the extent to which one's life is felt
to be worthwhile. High-minded philosophy treatises should
complicate but not confuse the primacy of the
pleasure-pain axis. So one very practical method of
life-enrichment consists in chemically engineering happier brains for all in the here-and-now. Yet how
can this best be done?
Any strategy which
doesn't subvert our inbuilthedonic
treadmill of inhibitory feedback mechanisms in the
CNS will fail. Political and socio-economic
reforms offer at best a lame stopgap. To the scientific naturalist, all
routes to happiness must ultimately be biological - "culture" and "talk-therapy" alike must be neurochemically
encoded to exert any effect on the psyche. Some of these routes to happiness involve
the traditional environmental detours. They are too technical, diverse and
futile to tackle here. If the quality of our lives is to be significantly
enhanced in the long term, then the genetically predisposed set-point of
our emotional thermostats needs to be recalibrated. The malaise-ridden norm
typically adaptive in
humanity's ancestral environment must be scrapped. So while we wait until
germ-line gene-therapy to promote mental super-health can become standard, it's worth considering instead
how ordinary early 21st Century Homo sapiens can sustainably
maximise emotional well-being with only present-day pharmacology to rely
on. No less importantly, how is it possible to combine staying continuously
"better than well" with
retaining one's sense of social and ethical
responsibility to other people and
life-forms?
Extracting
reliable
information on this topic is extraordinarily difficult
for laity and professionals alike. The layman is more
likely to be given heavily slanted propaganda.
Unvarnished fact might confuse his supposedly uneducated and
functionally diminutive brain. Career-scientists, on
the other hand, are bedevilled by a different problem.
Access to funds, laboratories, raw materials, journal
publication, professional preferment,
and licenses to conduct experimental trials is all
dependent on researchers delivering results their
paymasters want to hear. The disincentives to
intellectual integrity could scarcely be greater; and they
are cloaked in such reputable disguise.
By
way of illustration, it's worth contemplating one
far-fetched scenario. How might an everlasting-happiness
drug - a drug which (implausibly!) left someone who tried it once living
happily-ever-after - find itself described in the
literature?
"Substance x induces severe, irreversible structural
damage to neurotransmitter subsystem y. Its sequelae include mood-congruent
cognitive delusions, treatment-resistant euphoria, and toxic affective
psychosis."
Eeek! Needless to say, no responsible adult would mess around with a potent neurotoxin under this
description.
Several excellent
researchers play the game by the rules. They keep their heterodox opinions
to themselves. Others find such cognitive
dissonance too unpleasant. So they gradually internalise the puritanical
role and tendency to warped scientific prose expected of them. [Whereas
tortured non-human experimental animals,
for instance, blandly get "used" and "sacrificed", certain socially taboo
drugs always get "abused" by "drug-abusers"] On the
other hand, some of the most original and productive minds in the field
of psychopharmacology
- pre-eminently Alexander Shulgin
- have already been silenced. Many more careers have been intellectually
strangled at birth or consigned to professional oblivion. The danger of
poisoning the wells of information, for whatever motives, is straightforward.
When young people discover they have been lied to or deceived, over cannabis
for instance, they will pardonably assume that they have been lied to or
deceived over the dangers of other illegals
too. And this, to put it mildly, would be exceedingly rash.
Most recently, the Internet
daily delivers up an uncontrollable flood-tide of fresh ideas to counter
official misinformation. Some of the online literature, for instance Erowid, is first-rate. At its best, Wikipedia puts print publications to shame. Unfortunately, a lot of web-published material isn't much more objective
in content or style than the professional journals it complements. Medical ghostwriting, unacknowledged conflicts of interest and publication bias
are endemic to "peer-reviewed" academic journals; but methodological
rigour is scarce in the scientific counter-culture too. Devising one's
own system of filtering and quality-control to drown out the noise is a
challenging task for anybody.
SOME DEAD ENDS
One spectacularly incompetent
route to a lifetime of happiness involves taking unsustainable psychostimulants
such as cocaine or the amphetamines.
In the short term, their activation of the sympathetic nervous system tends
to elevate mood, motivation and energy. Users tend to talk a lot. Self-confidence
is enhanced: these are "power drugs". Physical strength and mental acuity
are variably increased. Whereas cocaine blocks the neuronal re-uptake of
the catecholamine
neurotransmitters noradrenaline
and dopamine, amphetamine
triggers to a much greater extent their synaptic release. Amphetamine feels coarser, lasts longer and costs less.
In either case, libertarian
indignation that the State presumes to subject its citizens to totalitarian-style
mind-control should not obscure the fact that for most purposes these are
not useful drugs. This is because the central nervous system supports a
web of mutually inhibitory feedback-mechanisms. In response to a short-term
increase of mood-mediating monoamines
in the synapses, the genes and neuronal receptors re-regulate. So at best
no real long-term benefit is derived from the use of such compounds. Neither
cocaine nor amphetamine yield the sustained activation of intracellular
signal-transduction cascades needed to cheat the hedonic treadmill and keep us truly happy.
Some people continue to
take psychostimulants casually for years without serious harm. Yet the potential
risks of adverse physical, psychological and social ill-effects
are high. Their use beyond narcolepsy and perhaps ADHD is best discouraged.
The "depressant" opioids are somewhat more benign.
They are effective painkillers. Opioids can also be extremely pleasurable.
In classical antiquity, Aristotle - admittedly not always the soundest authority
on medical matters - classified pain as an emotion. Opium
was a traditional remedy
for melancholic depression;
its efficacy is arguably superior to Prozac,
though comparative controlled clinical trials are lacking. In "animal models", opioids
reverse the depressed
behaviour, learned
helplessness and neuroendocrine
responses associated with clinical depression. By contrast, opioid antagonists
such as naloxone exacerbate
them. To confuse matters further, sufferers from depression typically share
an increased sensitivity to pain; and modern "antidepressants" can themselves
act as "physical" painkillers.
Conversely, mu-opioid
receptor agonists offer both unsurpassed pain-relief and extraordinary emotional
well-being; and delta-opioid
agonists and enkephalinase
inhibitors can function as antidepressants. There is clearly an intimate
link between "physical" and "emotional" pain. In defiance of dualist metaphysics,
opioids tend to be good at banishing both.
Contemporary medical orthodoxy classifies drug-induced bliss as an
"adverse side-effect" of opioid analgesics - even in the terminally ill. Yet we could
all do with having our native endorphin
systems enriched. Later this century and beyond, the customised site-selective
successors to today's opioid drugs may play a critical role in
promoting emotional super-health. For example, one of the most exciting
research breakthroughs in recent years has been the synthesis of JDTic.
JDTic exerts a sustained anti-anxiety and mood-brightening effect: it
is the first orally active selective kappa opioid antagonist. Kappa is
the "ugly" opioid receptor whose endogenous ligand is dynorphin. The dynorphin/kappa-opioid receptor system is implicated in the unpleasant states of mind caused by chronic uncontrolled stress. Repeated use of cocaine, heroin, ethyl alcohol and other euphoriant drugs induces a compensatory up-regulation
of the dynorphin/kappa-opioid receptor system too, causing anxiety,
anhedonia and dysphoria. Whereas mu receptor agonist opioids induce
euphoria by enhancing dopamine release in the nucleus accumbens,
activation of kappa opioid receptors inhibits dopamine release from the
mesolimbic terminals. This deficiency is subjectively unpleasant
because the mesolimbic dopamine system regulates hedonic tone and the
capacity to experience (and anticipate) happiness. Dopamine also
modulates the threshold of pain perception. As of 2009, controlled
clinical trials of JDTic or its analogues in humans have yet to begin. But results in non-human "animal models" are encouraging.
Unfortunately,
opioids in present-day human use are flawed. Taken at fixed dosage,
they lose some of their euphoriant and analgesic effect as tolerance sets in; opioid drugs are physiologically addictive. Overdoses can cause respiratory depression;
by contrast, physical pain is a potent respiratory stimulant. When
taken recreationally, opioids inspire a dreamily contented
disengagement from the problems of the world. Their use diminishes our
drive to constructive activity as consumers in today's competitive
global marketplace. More insidiously, excess consumption of narcotics inhibits the release
of endogenous opioids normally induced by social interaction with friends
and family. By diminishing
the craving for human companionship, the addict substitutes one form of
opioid addiction for another. Thus junkies are usually "selfish".
The physical risks of opioid
use shouldn't be exaggerated. Most of the problems that users suffer ultimately
derive less from their choice of drug itself than from the illegal status
of narcotics in prohibitionist society. Yet even if opioid drugs were legal
and given away in cereal packets, such drugs wouldn't make a good choice of
mood-booster - or at least not in their present, crudely non-specific guise.
Kappa receptor agonists, for
instance, impair dopamine function. They have dysphoric and psychotomimetic
effects: one might as well drink ethyl alcohol spiced with meths.
The paradise-engineers
of posterity will surely weed out such adulterants from their elixirs
altogether.
By contrast to
today's opioids, marijuana isn't usually addictive
in the traditional sense of the term. It can still be habit-forming. Marijuana
has euphoriant, psychedelic and sedative properties.
Experiments with stoned
rats suggest that cannabis use reduces the amount of corticotrophin-releasing factor
(CRF) in the amygdala.
Excess secretion of CRF is associated with abnormalities in the HPLA
axis and depression. The rebound surge of CRF on ceasing cannabis-use
correlates with increased vulnerability to stress and a withdrawal-reaction,
arguably one good reason not to stop in the first instance. Stress-induced endocannabinoid deficit in the brain may induce melancholic depression in users and non-users alike. A dysfunctional
response to stress,
linked to a chronically overactive HPLA axis, causes anxiety disorders and
depression; CRH-type 1 receptor antagonists like antalarmin are being investigated as potential anxiolytics and antidepressants. The deeper roots of
our malaise lie buried in the evolutionary past.
The primary psychoactive
ingredient in marijuana is THC,
tetrahydrocannabinol. Smoking or eating marijuana and its complex cocktail
of compounds may rarely trigger episodes of depersonalisation,
derealisation and psychosis. Sometimes it can induce paranoia, particularly
in advocates of The War Against Drugs. More commonly, marijuana just leaves the
user pleasantly and harmlessly stoned.
It's fun. Sleepiness, pain-relief
and euphoria are typical responses. Cannabinoid CB(1) receptor agonists are potential antidepressants. Indeed cannabinoids may be neuroprotective against the effects of stress. Conversely, cannabinoid CB(1) receptor antagonists/inverse agonists, like the new EC-licensed diet-drug rimonabant (Acomplia), may cause depression and anxiety. Indeed the first brain-derived substance
found to bind to our cannabis receptors was christened "anandamide", a derivative
of the Sanskrit word for internal contentment.
Getting high may thus serve
as an innocent recreational pastime in an uncaring world.
Yet marijuana is not a
wonderdrug. Cognitive function in the user is often impaired, albeit moderately
and reversibly. Marijuana interferes with memory-formation by disrupting
long-term potentiation in the hippocampus.
One of the functions of endogenous cannabinoids in the brain
is to promote selective short-term amnesia.
Forgetting is not, as one might have supposed, a purely passive process.
Either way, choosing deliberately to ingest an amnestic agent for long periods
is scarcely an ideal life-strategy. It's especially flawed given the centrality
of memory to human self-identity. Some artists and professional bohemians,
it is true, apparently do find smoking grass an adjunct to creative thought.
For persons of a more philistine temperament, on the other hand, it's hard
to see such a drug as a major tool for life-affirmation or the development
of the human species. This shortcoming does not, one ought scarcely need to add, suggest marijuana users
should be persecuted and criminalised. Indeed the marijuana compound THC may actually be superior to commercially licensed products at blocking the formation of mind-rotting amyloid plaques of the memory-destroying Alzheimer's disease.
The disparate drugs we label “psychedelics” - lysergamides
like LSD-25, tryptamines like DMT and psilocybin, and phenethylamines such as mescaline - are sometimes exhilarating. At best,
they are life-transforming and soul-enriching. They can certainly be
mind-wrenching. Taking major psychedelics can generate experiences too
outlandish for our normal conceptual framework to accommodate. We
haven't even names for the strange new modes of perception, selfhood
and introspection their biochemical pathways disclose.
Unfortunately, one can’t look after the kids, fill in one’s tax
forms or carry out one’s social responsibilities while tripping on LSD.
Psychedelics are typically too bizarre, exotic and ineffable in their
effects to integrate into the rest of one’s life. By trapping most of
us in "ordinary" waking consciousness, selfish DNA stumbled on a
cunning trick to help its vehicles leave more copies of itself. Worse,
the psychedelics aren't primarily euphoriants. They don’t directly
stimulate the pleasure-centres and guarantee the user a good trip. Both
the serotonin- and catecholamine-like families trigger psychedelia mainly via their role as partial agonists of the 5-HT2A receptors in the central nervous system; 5-HT2 heteroreceptors exert a tonic inhibitory effect on the striatal
dopaminergic neurons. Such agents aren’t a dependable choice of
clinical or recreational mood-brightener, whether in the short- or
long-term. Depressives, neurotics and other troubled souls in search of
enlightenment are most likely to undergo nightmarish freak-outs.
Psychotic derealisation isn't illuminating - or fun. The drug-naïve
mind can’t make an informed prior choice of whether to explore
radically altered states. For aspiring psychonauts can’t know, in
advance, the true nature of what they may be choosing - or missing.
Ultimately, when our well-being is genetically hardwired and invincible, psychedelia can be safely explored. The study of consciousness can become an experimental discipline. The synthesis of tomorrow’s designer-psychedelics may unleash an intellectual revolution without precedent. Until then, psychedelic drugs are too unpredictable - and our dark, Darwinian minds are too poisoned - responsibly to promote their use.
Apparently by contrast, the empathogen
"hug-drug" Ecstasy (methylenedioxymethamphetamine;
MDMA) offers a wonderfully warm, sensuous,
loving, and empathetic peak experience to the first-time user - "a brief fleeting moment of sanity" [Dr Claudio Naranjo]. MDMA enhances the release of serotonin and dopamine at the synaptic terminals; it also inhibits their reuptake. MDMA stimulates pro-social oxytocin release via activation of the serotonin 5-HT1A receptors.
In consequence, distrust, suspicion
and jealousy evaporate. They are replaced by a serene sense of universal love.
The sensorium remains clear. Emotion is intensified. Much recreational
drug-use tends to be self-centred. Drug use is often branded as selfish. Yet here
is a "penicillin of the soul" which promises to subvert our DNA-driven
tendency to self-aggrandisement.
Disappointingly, whether
due to enzyme-induction or other causes not fully understood, most users
never fully recapture the magic of
their first few trips. Moreover, Ecstasy is neurotoxic
to serotonergic
axons. It may even be harmful at sub-therapeutic doses. As the uncertain
process of neural recovery sets in, heavy users in particular may experience
the subtle long-drawn-out reversal of all the good effects they initially
enjoyed from the drug. Taking a post-trip selective serotonin re-uptake
inhibitor (SSRI) such as fluoxetine (Prozac)
2-6 hours afterward is prophylactic
against the measurable post-E serotonin dip
otherwise experienced some 48 hours later. Yet taking SSRIs on a regular
basis largely nullifies the already attenuated benefits of prolonged Ecstasy
use. In any case, the duration of the peak E experience is a mere 90 minutes.
So taking Ecstasy scarcely amounts to a full-scale strategy for life either.
Ecstasy does, on the other hand, deliver an exquisite foretaste of the beautiful
forms of consciousness that ultimately
await us.
Another tantalising and deliciously
sensuous hint of the sublime is offered
- infrequently and unpredictably - by gamma-hydroxybutyrate (GHB). GHB usually
takes the form of a clear, odourless, slightly salty-tasting liquid. In the brain, the GHB molecule is
also an endogenous precursor and metabolite of the inhibitory neurotransmitter
GABA. GHB is non-toxic;
but it mustn't be mixed with alcohol or other depressants. It's metabolised
quickly to carbon dioxide and water.
GHB's steep dose-response curve means naïve users run the severe risk of
falling asleep. When used lightly in recreational rather than stuporific
or anaesthetic doses, GHB is a touchy-feely compound which typically induces
deep muscular relaxation, a sense of serenity, and feelings of emotional
warmth. Often it enhances emotional openness and the desire to socialise.
Tactile sensitivity and the appreciation of music are enriched. Most remarkably,
the moderate user may awake refreshed after a deep restful sleep: GHB appears
temporarily to inhibit
dopamine-release while increasing storage, leading to the brightened mood
and sharpened mental focus of a subsequent "dopamine-rebound". GHB acts
both as a disinhibitor and an aphrodisiac. Intensity of orgasm is heightened.
Hence GHB is potentially useful in relieving the psychopathologies of prudery
and sexual repression. Unfortunately, its therapeutic
value has been eclipsed by its demonisation in the mass-media. Stories
of chaste virgins turning into sex-crazed nymphomaniacs make great copy
and poor scientific medicine. Moreover GHB is sometimes confused with the amnestic
"date-rape" benzodiazepine, flunitrazepam
- better-known as the potent and fast-acting sedative-hypnotic "forget pill",
Rohypnol. Bought on the street, GHB may be confused with all sorts of other
substances too.
Yet
even pure GHB is no magic elixir. Not everyone likes it. GHB's
psychological effects are unpredictable and poorly understood. It has a
relatively low therapeutic index. Nausea, dizziness, inco-ordination
are common; reaction-time is slowed. GHB does not usually promote great
depth of thought. Its very status as "an almost ideal sleep
inducing-substance" makes it of limited use to those who aspire instead
to be more intensely awake.
The lack of any discernible body-count to fuel the periodic moral panics
its use induces may allow a partial rehabilitation. Yet GHB evokes - at
best - only a faint, fleeting parody of the life-long chemical
nirvana on offer to our transhuman
successors.
Ethyl alcohol
- the traditional date-rape drug of choice - and, most insidiously of all,
cigarettes are
the really sinister mass-killers. A report published in The Lancet in March 2007 ranked alcohol and tobacco as more hazardous to human health than LSD. Their cumulative human death-toll to date is around 100 million and climbing. A WHO report published in February 2008 projected that tobacco abuse may kill one billion people by the year 2100.
With that poker-faced Alice-In-Wonderland
logic popular amongst the world's sleazier governments, not merely do the
authorities preserve the legal status of cigarette sales here in the UK
on grounds of upholding personal liberty. The slickly expensive marketing
and glamorisation of tobacco
products to potential victims is sanctioned on similar grounds too. We ought
to be as shocked at tobacco promotion as we'd certainly feel if instead
the billboards urged kids to try heroin because it's cool. Yet familiarity
breeds moral apathy. Youngsters are typically hooked before they are in
any position to make an informed choice of their preferred poison - or even to abstain altogether.
Meanwhile a state-supported export drive targets the poor in vulnerable
Third World countries. With a cynicism that almost beggars belief, one celebrated
British ex-Prime Minister accepted a million-dollar bribe from a leading
member of the drug-cartels for her services. Her party's Home
Secretary then delivered himself of blood-curdling calls for a crack-down
on evil drug-pushers(!). He went on to increase the draconian penalties
already available for personal users of cannabis.
So long as our governments
collude with the tobacco drug cartels to share out the billions of dollars
of tax revenues mulcted from nicotine-addicts - thereby keeping direct taxes
visibly down and themselves visibly in office - there seems little hope
of a more intelligent approach to psychoactive
drugs as a whole.
DIRTY MOOD BRIGHTENERS
The commonly recognised legal and illegal recreational
drugs offer poor prospects for sustained biological mood-enhancement. So what
about the heterogeneous group of compounds uninvitingly labelled as anxiolytics
and antidepressants?
Have they potentially anything significant to add to most people's quality
of life? Official medical doctrine says no. Allegedly, only sufferers from
clinically-sanctioned psychiatric disorders will benefit from such agents -
though in recent years it has at last been formally recognised that depressive
disorders are under-diagnosed and under-treated even by the early twenty-first century's
abjectly poor standards of acceptable ill-being.
Most of humankind, however, still doesn't fit any of the official diagnostic
boxes. So can "diagnostic creep" triumph over therapeutic minimalism and enhance
our quality of life? Yes. Must the goal of pharmacotherapy be as limited
as Freud's aspiration for psychotherapy: "to transform hysterical misery into
common unhappiness"? No.
First, the boring but crucial
preliminaries. Optimal nutrition and aerobic exercise will increase the efficacy
of all the potential life-enhancers touted here. A rich supply of precursor
chemicals (e.g. l-tryptophan,
the rate-limiting step in the production of serotonin)
can also reduce their effective drug dosages. By choosing to eat an idealised
"stone-age" diet rich in organic
nuts, seeds, fruit and vegetables, and drastically reducing one's consumption
of saturated fat (red meat, fried foods), sugar (sweets etc) and hydrogenated
oils (found in margarine and refined vegetable oils), then one's baseline
of well-being - or at least relative ill-being - can be sustainably lifted. There is mounting evidence too that an omega-3 fatty acid-rich diet or supplementation is protective against depression and other psychiatric disorders. Folic acid augmentation is advisable as well. Visitors to HedWeb probably don't expect
to be assailed by sermons on the benefits of exercise any more than food-faddism.
Yet regular and moderately vigorous physical exertion releases endogenous
opioids, enhances serotonin
function, stimulates nerve growth factors, promotes cell proliferation in the hippocampus,
and leads to a livelier, better-oxygenated
brain.
Alas, clean living and
wholesome thoughts typically aren't enough. We need stronger medicine to
flourish. At first glance, however, the standard, State-rationed chemicals
aren't a brilliant bunch.
The so-called minor tranquillisers,
benzodiazepines
such as diazepam
(Valium), chlordiazepoxide (Librium), alprazolam (Xanax), lorazepam (Ativan), clonazepam (Klonopin) and the shorter-acting sedative-hypnotic temazepam (Restoril),
are useful but still dreadfully crude anti-anxiety agents. Several benzodiazepines are of natural origin: diazepam, for instance, can be found in the potato. Benzodiazepines
act primarily on the GABA
(gamma aminobutyric acid) receptor complex. GABA functions as the main inhibitory
neurotransmitter in the central nervous system. GABA is made from the main excitatory neurotransmitter, glutamate. The progress of molecular
biology and neurogenetics in unravelling the fiendish complexity of GABA's
receptor sub-types
should eventually allow more targeted compounds to be developed. Ideally, these more
selective and site-specific drugs will lack the sedative, amnestic and hypnotic properties
of today's brands. Activation of GABA(A) receptors containing the alpha 1
subunit is responsible for benzodiazepine-induced sedation and memory
deficits. It is hoped that newly-synthesised agonists selective for the
alpha 2 GABA(A) receptor subtype may finally deliver a non-sedating antianxiety drug. Merck's investigational L838,417
is one such candidate. Human trials are eagerly awaited. The first
non-benzodiazepine, non-sedating/amnesiac drug of its class to reach
the market may prove to be DOV Pharmaceutical's ocinaplon. Ocinaplon is
a GABA alpha-2 modulator. It exerts its anti-anxiety effect at doses
(allegedly) substantially lower than doses that induce measurable
sedation, amnesia, muscle relaxation and incoordination. Ocinaplon is
in phase III clinical trials for anxiety (summer 2005; temporarily(?)
suspended August 2005). In the meantime, currently licensed
benzodiazepines tend to induce dependence, impair memory and psychomotor performance, dull
consciousness and cloud the intellect. So there's not much chance of radical
life-enrichment here, for now at least.
Buspirone
(Buspar) might seem more promising. It acts to desensitise the inhibitory autoreceptor 5-HT1A subtype
of serotonin receptor, thereby modulating serotonin release and (sometimes) promoting a brightening of mood. Thus
buspirone can be useful in anxious depressive states. Its active metabolite 1-PP
is an anxiolytic 5-HT1A partial agonist too. Buspirone lacks the
intellect-clouding effects of other clinical and alcoholic anti-anxiety
agents. It's not a muscle relaxant. It's only mildly sedating. Yet
buspirone's weak and equivocal effects on sub-types of dopamine
function, while useful commercially for the purposes of touting its
lack of "abuse-potential", mean buspirone isn't very exciting or
popular. Crucially, unlike the benzodiazepines, it's not a fast-acting
drug. Several weeks of use may pass before its dubious psychological benefits are felt. Researchers hope that newer
5-HT1A agonists in the pipeline will be more effective. Alas any
therapeutic gain is likely to be modest. In June 2004, the FDA
determined that Organon's gepirone
(Ariza) was "not approvable". In February 2007, GlaxoSmithKline and
Fabre-Kramer Pharmaceuticals announced an exclusive worldwide agreement
for the development and commercialisation gepirone ER. A FDA review of
its use for major depressive disorder is anticipated in 2009.
Oxytocin is a natural anti-anxiety agent: the "cuddle hormone". Several drug companies, notably Wyeth, are investigating its patentable synthetic analogues. Enhanced oxytocin release contributes to the acute pro-social action of MDMA (Ecstasy). Oxytocin builds trust by reducing activity in the fear-processing circuitry of the amygdala.
Taken off-label, oxytocin can be inhaled as an intranasal spray to
combat social phobia. It reduces shyness and normal social anxiety.
More controversially, oxytocin can be applied as an odourless body-spray
to manipulate the responses of other people: "trust in a bottle".
Nature's social peptide is also critical to pair-bonding. In future,
mastery of the oxytocin system may allow us to control our degree of
fidelity and attachment to each other far more effectively than
marriage vows. The sociological implications of the widespread use and
abuse of "social Viagra" would be far-reaching. It should be stressed
that research into the safe and sustainable enrichment of human oxytocin function has barely begun.
The ill-assorted drugs we today call antidepressants
fall into several categories.
Their delayed-onset mood-brightening effect is correlated with alterations in the concentration
of catecholamines and/or serotonin in the central nervous system,
long-term receptor
re-regulation, activation of specific transcription factors regulating gene expression, and new nerve-cell growth in the hippocampus. In the first decade of the 21st century, older monoamine theories of depressive illness popular among researchers over the past 40 years have been eclipsed by the neurogenic hypothesis of depression and antidepressant action. The neurogenic model interprets depression, at least in its more severe forms, as a neurodegenerative disorder. Chronic uncontrolled stress causes oversecretion of gluocorticoid hormones, notably cortisol. Cortisol activates the glucocorticoid receptors that regulate metabolism, inflammation and immunity. An excess of glucocorticoid hormones reduces the rate of new brain cell-proliferation
in the hippocampus. The hippocampus has the highest density of
receptors for glucocorticoids in the brain. Stress-induced activation
of the glucocorticoid receptors causes nerve cell death and dendritic atrophy in the hippocampus; by contrast, there is synaptic growth in the basolateral amygdala. The amygdala stores memories
of emotional experiences - frequently fearful and unpleasant memories.
Eventually, however, prolonged stress tends to atrophy the amygdala
too. These long-term changes in brain morphology lower mood. They may result in anhedonia and depression in the genetically vulnerable. Antidepressants either diminish, prevent or (ideally) reverse stress-induced neural damage and impaired structural plasticity. How do they really work? Despite an explosive growth in neurobabble, no one knows.
The tricyclics, prototypically
imipramine (Tofranil),
and their allies are relatives of the neuroleptic drug chlorpromazine.
Chlorpromazine is also known as Largactil, the notorious "chemical
cosh". Tricyclics block to varying degrees the reuptake of serotonin
and noradrenaline into the nerve cell terminals from where they are
released. The consequent changes in pre- and post-synaptic receptor
sensitivity may lighten the spirits of 60-70% of the depressives who
take them. Perhaps unsurprisingly given their parentage, the tricyclics
are all dirty drugs, though some are dirtier than others. Their anti-cholinergic
effects harm memory, concentration and intellectual performance. Their anti-histamine
action induces drowsiness and sedation. Their adverse effect on cardiac
function makes them dangerous in overdose. Most "euthymic" volunteers
on whom they have been tested don't like their dulling effects of consciousness.
Unlike chlorpromazine, the tricyclic antidepressants don't noticeably block
the dopamine receptors. But with one notable exception,
they do precious little to stimulate dopamine
function either. Hence they're not much fun even for the severely depressed
people who can benefit from taking them. For three decades they were the
mainstay of the treatment of clinically-acknowledged depression.
They contributed to the widely-held medical opinion that anything classed
as an antidepressant won't help "normal" people; unless of course
they were "really" depressed. Basically, tricyclics are cheap,
nasty and usually best avoided.
Better,
but still deeply flawed, are the selective serotonin reuptake
inhibitors [SSRIs]. Serotonin,
"the civilising neurotransmitter", plays a vital role in mood, memory, appetite,
sleep, pain perception and sexual desire.
Fluoxetine
(Prozac), fluvoxamine
(Luvox, Faverin), paroxetine (Paxil,
Seroxat), sertraline (Zoloft,
Lustral), and citalopram
(Cipramil, Celexa) are currently licensed and marketed. More of their
tweaked and enhanced relatives are on the way from pharmaceutical
companies eager for a lucrative piece of the action. In a triumph of
marketing hype and creative use of patent law if not clinical need,
citalopram's S-enantiomer was FDA-licensed in 2002 as "Lexapro". The SSRIs all differ in their half-lives,
chemical structure and precise specificities. Their functional effects are
broadly similar, though Prozac is the most activating, longest-lasting, least selective and most likely to provoke dose-related akathisia; paroxetine has anticholinergic
and sedating antihistaminergic effects; fluvoxamine most commonly
induces nausea and has the shortest half-life; and citalopram is the
most serotonin-selective. The mood-brightening, resilience-enhancing
and anti-anxiety properties of the SSRIs really
can make a (very) modest percentage of the population feel "better than well". Unpredictably, other users feel worse.
As a class, SSRIs (mostly) don't have the physically unpleasant and cognitively debilitating
anticholinergic effects of the tricyclics. SSRIs don't demand the dietary restrictions of the MAOIs. Their dependence potential and withdrawal reaction is usually milder than the opioids.
The (sometimes) beneficent properties
of the SSRIs are celebrated in Peter Kramer's contemporary classic Listening
to Prozac. Kramer has written a remarkably honest book. It's a discursive
memoir by a therapist who is forced to admit that many of his clients seemed
rapidly to fare far better on a pill than on his industrial-strength regimen
of caring talk-therapy. Kramer's discussion of "cosmetic psychopharmacology"
and "designer personalities", however, enraged traditionalists.
For chemical Calvinist orthodoxy finds the notion that people should have
a right to choose pharmacologically who and what they want to be profoundly
offensive. In Against Depression, published in May 2005, Kramer argues that depression should be eradicated altogether.
Two common problems limit
the usefulness of SSRIs, at least
when taken on their own. The problems stem from the indirect inhibitory
effect sometimes exerted by Prozac-style drugs on dopamine function, a consequence of deliberate
selective targeting of the serotonin system.
First, SSRIs can compromise libido
and sexual performance. This isn't always a disadvantage in over-excitable
young males; indeed the currently unlicensed SSRI dapoxetine may shortly be marketed as an on-demand treatment for premature ejaculation.
But SSRI-induced sexual dysfunction can still be a highly distressing phenomenon for older people
too embarrassed to talk about it. Technical performance difficulties
can sometimes be counteracted by taking the blood vessel dilators apomorphine
or phentolamine;
the alpha2-adrenergic antagonist yohimbine; a phosphodiesterase type-5 inhibitor like sildenafil
(better known as the sexual rocket-fuel Viagra), long-acting tadalafil (Cialis) or newly licensed vardenafil (Levitra);
or a dopamine agonist, licit or otherwise,
before bedtime action. Investigational drugs that heighten female sexual arousal (e.g. flibansein, or melanocortin agonists like PT-141/bremelanotide) are another option. Indeed, unlicensed use of the world's first aphrodisiac and inhalable sex-drug may herald a cultural revolution without precedent. Yet polypharmacy is scarcely an ideal
solution for existing SSRI users. One of the major signs of depression
is loss of interest in sex and reduced libido. So it's questionable
whether the FDA and the pharmaceutical industry should continue to
promote serotonergic "antidepressants" that are anti-sexual; and
collude to suppress antidepressants that are pro-sexual.
Second,
though a few subjects may feel mildly euphoric, in other users the
SSRIs serve more as mood-stabilisers and mood-flatteners in their
lives. By increasing the user's emotional self-sufficiency, too, SSRIs
may subtly change
the "balance of power" in personal relationships - for good or ill.
In some cases, SSRIs may even act as thymoanaesthetisers
which diminish the intensity of felt emotion; by contrast, a mood-brightening
serotonin reuptake-enhancer like tianeptine (Stablon)
may intensify emotion instead. Affective flattening may be welcome to
someone in the pit of unmitigated clinical depression. It is scarcely
a life-enriching property for "normal" people who lack any convenient
diagnostic category which acknowledges their malaise.
A backlash against SSRIs is now gathering pace. In February 2008, a Public Library of Science meta-analysis of four commonly prescribed "second generation" antidepressants - using both published and withheld drug-company data - reported that SSRIs were scarcely more effective as antidepressants than placebos.
The illustrious UK psychopharmacologist Professor David Healy
delivers an even more damning verdict on contemporary psychiatry:
"there is probably no other branch of medicine where the outcomes for a
core disease are steadily worsening." [p. 95; Shock Therapy by Edward Shorter and David Healy (2007)]
THE DOPAMINE CONNECTION
What's missing, crucially,
is the therapeutic enrichment of hedonic tone via a combination of mu opioid pathway enhancement and prolonged stimulation of meso(cortico-)limbic dopamine function.
This is really much more fun than it sounds. Yet the socially
responsible use of reward pathway enhancements/remedial therapies is a
technical, bioethical and medico-legal minefield. Complications aside,
the currently available experimental evidence has persuaded many - but
not all - investigators that the mesolimbic dopamine system serves as
the final common pathway for
pleasure in the brain. Enhanced responsiveness of post-synaptic dopamine
D2/D3 receptors is
vital to long-term emotional well-being. Insofar as they work, all "serotonergic" and "noradrenergic"
mood-brighteners eventually act on the mesolimbic
dopamine pathway, albeit in differing degrees and with varying delay. Even SSRIs depend on sensitization of the mesolimbic dopamine D2 receptors for their (modest) mood-lifting effect. New anti-Parkinsonian agents, notably the neuroprotective dopamine D3 receptor subtype selective pramipexole (Mirapex), ropinirole (Requip), and cabergoline (Dostinex)
owe their potential role as fast-acting pro-sexual antidepressants to their
dopaminergic action. Likewise, the possible mood-brightening effect of low doses of the dopamine receptor antagonist amisulpride (Solian), more commonly considered an antipsychotic agent, is explicable because amisulpride preferentially blocks the presynaptic dopamine D2/D3 autoreceptors; dopaminergic transmission is thereby enhanced.
The full story is inevitably
complex. Dopamine agonists
and reuptake inhibitors are often inadequate long-term mood-brighteners
by themselves. The mesolimbic dopamine system mediates reward-signalling, incentive salience and a sense of urgency and significance, not the essence of pure bliss. Dopamine isn't itself
the magic pleasure-chemical, though its functional role in conjunction with glutamate and mu opioid agonists in regulating medium spiny neurons of the rostromedial shell of the nucleus accumbens is critical. Researchers into affective disorders can prematurely become over-attached
to one particular neurotransmitter system, its receptor sub-types and their signal-transduction
cascades. Traditionally, serotonin
and noradrenaline have attracted
the fiercest rival partisans in antidepressant research. "Dopaminergic" (and opioid) agents, by contrast,
are suspect. They are politically incorrect since they are potentially "abusable".
Moreover it can be argued that the research and development of safe and sustainable Ecstasy-like empathogens
and sociabilisers is at least as morally urgent as the license of safe and sustainable euphoriants. At
any rate, enhanced mesolimbic dopamine release, exclusively or otherwise,
enriches the intensity of experience; increases pleasure and libido, and potentially
boosts cognitive performance.
Even better, whereas some dopaminergics are potentially toxic, some dopamine-enhancing agents may have neuroprotective properties as well.
So what are the other contemporary
options for chemical life-enhancement?
METHYLPHENIDATE (RITALIN); MINAPRINE (CANTOR); NOMIFENSINE (MERITAL)
A SSRI can be combined
("augmented" sounds more soothing to the official medical ear) with a dopaminergic
such as methylphenidate.
As Ritalin, methylphenidate is prolifically dispensed to American
schoolchildren for different
purposes altogether. It is sometimes abused as an instrument of social
control. In spite of its structural relationship to amphetamine,
methylphenidate resembles in many ways a more benign version of cocaine,
yet with a much longer half-life. Methylphenidate blocks the reuptake of, but doesn't significantly
release, the catecholamines noradrenaline and dopamine. If it is taken in sustained-release
form or combined with an SSRI,
all of which have anti-obsessive-compulsive
properties too, then the likelihood of dose-escalation is minimised. In Europe and North America, students
sometimes take Ritalin to gain a competitive edge in exams. However,
its long-term effect on the developing brain is poorly understood.
Chewing coca
leaves with a dash of powdered lime is a nutritious and energising way
to sustain healthy mood.
Unfortunately, it's illicit and not very good for one's teeth.
A more cautious but still
interesting option might be minaprine (Cantor).
Minaprine blocks the reuptake of both dopamine
and serotonin. It is also in some degree cholinomimetic. Thus it may exhibit
both mood-brightening and nootropic
properties. Much more research is needed. Unfortunately, minaprine is now obtainable only as a "research chemical".
Merital
(nomifensine) showed
great promise as a pleasantly stimulating dopaminergic
that also potently inhibits the reuptake of noradrenaline and - to a much lesser extent - serotonin. It was marketed by its manufacturers Hoechst with the slogan "vive la difference!" Merital was withdrawn from licensed use after the discovery of its rare side-effect
of precipitating a serious blood-disorder.
For retarded melancholics,
however, it was typically a very effective and well-tolerated
mood-brightener with minimal side-effects.
The risk/reward ratio of its carefully-monitored use may have been
misjudged. Nomifensine is now obtainable only as a research chemical
too.
BUPROPION (WELLBUTRIN); AMINEPTINE (SURVECTOR); TIANEPTINE (STABLON) Bupropion (Wellbutrin)
is possibly less effective than nomifensine. Yet it's useful because it
lacks the adverse effects on sexual
function characteristic of the SSRIs. In some subjects - particularly women - libido,
arousal, and the intensity and duration of orgasm may actually increase.
Bupropion weakly blocks the reuptake, but diminishes the release, of dopamine.
This may account for reports of its diminished propensity to induce mania
in the genetically susceptible. Bupropion's active metabolites
inhibit the reuptake of noradrenaline. Radafaxine,
one of these metabolites, also blocks the dopamine transporters;
radafaxine may in future be marketed as a slimming drug as well as an
antidepressant. Bupropion itself, branded as Zyban,
may help in giving up smoking.
Scandalously, bupropion isn't licensed and marketed as an
antidepressant in Europe - though doctors may prescribe Zyban to
non-smoking depressives "off-label". Bupropion plus an SSRI
is sometimes more effective than either agent alone. In June 2006, the
FDA licensed bupropion/Wellbutrin XL as the first preventive
pharmacological treatment of Seasonal Affective Disorder (SAD).
Amineptine
(Survector) is a cleanish, (relatively) selective dopamine
reuptake blocker. Higher doses promote dopamine release too. Amineptine is pro-sexual
and liable occasionally to cause spontaneous orgasms.
It is a mild but pleasant psychostimulant and a fast-acting
mood-brightener. Unlike most other tricyclics,
it doesn't impair libido or cognitive
function. Unlike typical stimulants and other activating agents, it
may actually improve sleep architecture. Scandalously, amineptine isn't
licensed and marketed in Britain and America. For it is feared it might
have "abuse-potential". FDA pressure led to its withdrawal in Europe too. This drove amineptine onto the pharmaceutical grey market,
discomfiting doctors and patients alike.
Another "French" option is amineptine's cousin, tianeptine (Stablon). Tianeptine is a neuroprotective antidepressant that reverses the neuronal damage and lasting misery caused by uncontrolled stress. Chronic stress
causes dysphoria by
inducing corticotropin-releasing factor (CRF2) receptor stimulation of
dynorphin release. The endogenous opioid peptide dynorphin activates
the unpleasant kappa opioid receptors. Tianeptine acts both as a
non-sedating anti-anxiety agent and a non-stimulating mood-brightener. Its use increases extracellular dopamine
concentration in the nucleus accumbens and, at higher doses, in the
frontal cortex. Uniquely in clinical medicine, tianeptine acts as a
selective serotonin reuptake enhancer. Its puzzling
efficacy as an antidepressant illustrates how little modern psychiatric medicine really understands
about mind, mood and depression. Like other contemporary antidepressants, tianeptine's therapeutic action presumably depends on downstream adaptations both between and within neurons occurring over a period of several weeks. Chronic tianeptine use reverses stress-induced hippocampal dendritric atrophy and amgydaloid dendritic hypertrophy, which is just as nasty as it sounds. But the precise molecular mechanisms are obscure. Tianeptine/Stablon is not licensed in North America primarily because its patent has expired.
REBOXETINE (EDRONAX); ADRAFINIL (OLMIFON); MODAFINIL (PROVIGIL) Reboxetine
(Edronax) is a relatively well-tolerated,
relatively selective "noradrenergic" agent. Crudely, whereas serotonin
plays a vital role in mood,
noradrenaline
is essential to maintaining drive, vigilance and the capacity for reward. There's a
fair bit of evidence that chronically depressive people have dysfunctional
and atypical noradrenergic systems - particularly their alpha2-
and beta-adrenoceptors. Reboxetine itself typically doesn't have the disruptive
effects on cognitive function or psychomotor performance common to older clinical mood-brighteners - though alas antimuscarinic effects are still not completely absent. Multiple interactions between the different monoamine
systems make it hard to target one neurotransmitter system without
triggering a cascade of effects on the others. But NorAdrenaline
Reuptake Inhibitors (NARIs) - and dopaminergics like amineptine
(Survector) - may be especially useful in drive-deficient "anergic" states
where the capacity for sustained motivation is lacking; and for melancholic
depressives with a poor ability to cope with stress. Reboxetine can be safely combined with an SSRI, though there is evidence that NARIs themselves indirectly enhance central serotonin function by a mechanism that doesn't depend on reuptake inhibition. More surprisingly perhaps,
preliminary studies suggest
reboxetine can actually reverse tranylcypromine-induced hypertensive crises.
The "cheese effect"
is triggered by ingesting tyramine-rich foods. Thus NARIs plus MAOIs
may prove a potent form of combination-therapy if first options fail. EMSAM, the transdermal selegiline patch, is probably the safest choice of MAOI.
Depressive hypersomniacs
who fare poorly on SSRIs,
or can't get hold of amineptine or EC-licensed reboxetine, might consider
trying a so-called eugeroic ("good arousal") agent instead. Alpha1-adrenergic agonists like adrafinil (Olmifon)
and modafinil (Provigil, Alertec) are centrally-acting
psychostimulants that can brighten mood and sharpen mental focus. They stimulate
the noradrenergic post-synaptic receptors, increase glutamatergic transmission, and activate the wakefulness-promoting orexinergic neurons, thereby boosting alertness, memory, mood, motivation
and energy. At sensible dosages, they are remarkably free of side-effects.
Modafinil was licensed by the FDA as Provigil for the treatment
of narcolepsy in Dec 1998; and in September 2003, an advisory panel to the FDA endorsed its use for treating shift work sleep disorder and sleep apnea.
However, the significance of these prescribing indications is rapidly
being eroded. Modafinil and adrafinil are now mainly used off-label as so-called lifestyle drugs.
Of course, many millions of insomniacs suffer from the opposite problem. They simply want regular sleep. Supracor's new sleep-aid eszopiclone
(Lunesta) can be taken on a nightly basis indefinitely. It will be the
first sleeping pill not to carry an FDA warning against long-term use.
MIRTAZAPINE
(REMERON); NEFAZODONE (SERZONE); VENLAFAXINE (EFFEXOR) &
DESVENLAFAXINE (PRISTIQ); DULOXETINE (CYMBALTA); ROLIPRAM; AGOMELATINE
(VALDOXAN)
NARIs are normally activating.
Anxious and depressive insomniacs, on the other hand, may benefit more from "dual-action" mirtazapine; or from newly-licensed duloxetine.
Mirtazapine
(Remeron) is a structural analogue of the off-patent mianserin (Bolvidon).
It is a comparatively new drug - a so-called NaSSA.
By blocking the inhibitory presynaptic alpha2 adrenergic autoreceptors and stimulating only the 5-HT1A receptors, mirtazapine enhances noradrenaline and serotonin release
while also blocking two specific (5-HT2
and 5-HT3)
serotonin receptors implicated in dark moods and anxiety. By contrast,
stimulation of the 5-HT2A receptors accounts for the initial anxiety,
insomnia and sexual dysfunction sometimes reported with the SSRIs;
stimulation of the 5-HT3 receptors causes nausea. Unfortunately,
mirtazapine is a potent blocker of the histamine H1 receptors too. So it tends to have
a somewhat sedative
effect. This profile may be good for agitated depressives and insomniacs.
Again, it is scarcely a recipe for life-affirmation.
Nefazodone
(Serzone) is another "dual action", mainly serotonergic agent. It inhibits the reuptake
of serotonin while displaying post-synaptic 5-HT2A-receptor antagonism. This may be useful
for anxious depressives; but again, it may cause feelings of weakness, drowsiness
and lack of energy. Nefazodone is less likely to cause priapism
than its older cousin trazodone
(Desyrel). It is less likely to cause sexual dysfunction than the SSRIs. But nefazodone can also be toxic to the liver, albeit rarely. It may soon be withdrawn altogether by its manufacturer Bristol-Myers Squibb under threat of litigation.
Venlafaxine (Effexor) is a phenethylamine. Thus it's a benign if distant chemical cousin of MDMA.
Its manufacturers launched it as "Prozac with a punch". In February
2008, the FDA licensed its extended-release active metabolite desvenlafaxine as the antidepressant Pristiq after Weyth's venlafaxine patent expired. Venlafaxine
inhibits the neuronal reuptake of serotonin, noradrenaline
and dopamine in descending order of potency. If dopaminergically augmented, it offers another opening for creative psychopharmacology.
Such augmentation-therapy remains
(almost)
clinically unexplored. Taken on its own at low dosage, venlafaxine acts
primarily as a serotonin re-uptake inhibitor. At the high-level dosages
most suitable for melancholic and hypersomnic temperaments, its
noradrenergic (and weakly dopaminergic) action becomes more pronounced.
Venlafaxine lacks anticholinergic activity; but some users are troubled
by its antihistamine side-effects. Like the SSRIs,
it is sometimes useful for a broad spectrum
of disorders beyond clinical depression.
It is possible that duloxetine (Cymbalta, Xeristar, Yentreve), licensed by the FDA in autumn 2004, and milnacipran (Ixel, Dalcipran, Toledomin), available in Europe, may be more effective than venlafaxine (Effexor) for a segment of the population that can benefit from dual serotonin-noradrenaline reuptake inhibition. Pain-ridden
depressives in particular may respond well to this class of drug. Many
depressed people suffer from poorly-defined aches and pains, persistent
fatigue, and shoulder-, neck- and back-pain. Duloxetine relieves both
the somatic and emotional symptoms of depression. Unlike venlafaxine,
duloxetine exerts its more balanced serotonin and noradrenaline
reuptake inhibition throughout the dosage range. Duloxetine also weakly
inhibits the reuptake of dopamine, and shows minimal affinity for the
histamine and cholinergic muscarinic receptors. Its side-effect profile appears to be relatively benign.
Yet an authentic wonderdrug for mental health remains elusive. Early
expectations that duloxetine would show superior efficacy in melancholic
depressives have not yet been convincingly borne out in controlled
clinical trials. Ill-served by mainstream medicine, victims of
melancholic and retarded depression may actually do better on dual
noradrenaline-dopamine reuptake inhibitors such as delicensed nomifensine (Merital) and/or mu opioid agonists/kappa opioid antagonists such as buprenorphine
(Temgesic, Buprenex, Subutex). Duloxetine itself will probably prove a
blockbuster product. It will most likely be marketed for everything
from stress urinary incontinence, social phobia and generalised anxiety
disorder, diabetic peripheral neuropathic pain and possibly irritable
bowel syndrome. But alas it takes time to separate genuine therapeutic
advance from drug company hype, typically not until the patents expire.
Phosphodiesterase-inhibitors,
both selective (e.g. the PDE type 4 inhibitor rolipram) and unselective,
are another under-used option. The next few decades will take us much closer to
the downstream intra-cellular action. For it is here that our minds will ultimately
be healed, genetically
or otherwise.
Agomelatine (Valdoxan) is a novel antidepressant and anti-anxiety agent developed by Servier and licensed in the European Union in February 2009. A synthetic analogue of the natural hormone melatonin, agomelatine is a potent melatonin receptor agonist and a serotonin 5-HT2C receptor antagonist. Blockade of the neural 5-HT2C receptors enhances frontocortical
adrenergic and dopaminergic transmission, potentially improving
cognitive performance. In "animal models", agomelatine also reduces the
adverse effects of stress on memory. By acting as a melatonin receptor agonist, agomelatine improves sleep
quality. When taken once daily before bedtime, agomelatine doesn't
cause daytime drowsiness and sedation like the old tricyclics; nor does
its use kill libido like the SSRIs. Agomelatine is typically well
tolerated and remarkably free from adverse side-effects at therapeutic
dosages. Drug giant Novartis acquired the US rights to agomelatine from
Servier in 2006. In July 2009, Novartis announced it was delaying
submission for US regulatory approval another three years while it
conducted additional Phase III trials. American consumers must now
order agomelatine from Europe.
HYPERICUM Hypericum is important
for a different reason altogether. Many constitutionally unhappy people refuse
to have anything to do with orthodox Western medicine. They won't take "unnatural"
pharmaceutical products
at all. In consequence, they spend much of their lives trapped in a squalid
psychochemical ghetto of low spirits. The only sort of remedy that
they'll conceivably contemplate taking must carry a "natural"
label and soothingly "herbal"
description.
Unfortunately,
most folk remedies are only marginally effective. Our drug-metabolising
enzymes are the product of an evolutionary arms race to counteract
plant toxins. For plants tend to manufacture psychotropics
because they poison or debilitate creatures tempted to eat them - not
to heal our psychic woes. The Wisdom Of Nature is a quaint piece of
make-believe. Perversely, several of the natural remedies that
sometimes actually work - notably Cannabis sativa, Erythroxylon coca and Papaver somniferum - are now illegal to consume. Other "natural" interventions such as bright light therapy combined with good sleep discipline may be of limited use. But two options worth exploring are SAMe and St John's wort.
Hypericum,
the active ingredient in St John's wort, appears
to be an effective mood-brightener and anxiolytic - by today's standards at
least. Its side-effect profile and efficacy
in mild-to-moderate depression compares favourably with its synthetic counterparts.
Hypericum's blend of serotonin-reuptake inhibiting and (mild) MAO-inhibiting
properties (not a combination otherwise to be explored with potent
synthetics: the risk of the potentially fatal serotonin syndrome
is too great) contributes to - without wholly explaining - its generally benign
effects. Once again, much more research is needed, preferably not bankrolled by the makers of lucrative competing products. Thus a German trial published in the British Medical Journal
in February 2005 reported that a proprietary standardised extract of
hypericum/St John's wort was more effective and a better tolerated
treatment of moderate to severe depression than the SSRI paroxetine
(Paxil). This runs counter
to the negative findings of the 2001 U.S. trial sponsored by the makers
of the SSRI sertraline (Zoloft) - which concluded that for moderate to
severe depression, St John's wort was no better than a placebo. Faith
in the integrity of biological psychiatry would be greater if the single strongest predictive factor in the outcome of any published
clinical trial wasn't the identity of the funding body. A Cochrane
Review published in October 2008 found that hypericum extracts used to
treat major depression had similar efficacy to standard antidepressants but fewer side-effects.
INOSITOL
One further remedy, albeit
at "unnatural" doses, is worth noting. Inositol levels tend
to be low in depressives and high in euphoric
people. Taking myo-inositol as a food supplement in doses of 12g and more
per day represents perhaps the first successful use of the precursor
strategy for a second messenger rather than a neurotransmitter in the search
for long-term mood-brightening agents. Inositol and its derivatives serve
as messenger molecules within the nervous system. The molecule itself is a
naturally occurring isomer of glucose. It is a key intermediate of the phosphatidyl-inositol
cycle. This is a second-messenger system used by several noradrenergic, serotonergic
and cholinergic receptors. Adult westerners typically consume about one gram
of inositol per day in their food. The richest dietary sources are fruits,
nuts, beans and grains. The mood-darkening ("stabilising") effect
of lithium in manically
euphoric people may be explicable in terms of its inositol-depleting effect.
Potentially, if taken in high doses, inositol seems to be a good way of lightening
the spirits and diminishing anxiety in "euthymic" and depressed people alike.
Dosages of even 50g and more reportedly produce no toxic side-effects. This
regimen shouldn't be attempted unsupervised by people with a history of bipolar
disorder. As usual, much more research is in order. One "problem"
is that naturally-occurring compounds - such as inositol and SAMe - can't be patented.
So the scope for high profit-margins is diminished. Progress is unlikely to
be brisk.
THE MAO INHIBITORS
A further option involves
using both some of the oldest and the newest drugs on the block, the monoamine
oxidase inhibitors (MAOIs).
The older irreversible MAOIs certainly shouldn't be combined with SSRIs.
It is inadvisable to combine them with stimulants or many other drugs. Yet both old and new,
the MAOIs do have some very interesting properties. MAOIs may be particularly useful for rejection-sensitive, so-called atypical depressives who have "reversed vegetative symptoms" i.e. overeating and oversleeping.
Monoamine
oxidase has two main forms, type
A and type B. They are
coded by separate genes. MAO may be inhibited with agents that act reversibly
or irreversibly; and selectively or unselectively; these categories are not
absolute. For instance, the beta-carboline alkaloids found in the world's most popular drink, coffee,
are competitive and reversible inhibitors of both MAO type A and type
B. MAO type-A preferentially deaminates serotonin and noradrenaline,
and also non-selectively dopamine; type B primarily metabolises dopamine,
phenylethylamine (the "chocolate amphetamine") and various
trace amines.
The mood-elevating
properties of the MAOIs were discovered quite by chance in a US veterans'
hospital early in the 1950s. Many patients given the anti-tuberculotic
drug iproniazid were
not merely cured of their tuberculosis. They became exceptionally happy
as well. The animated enthusiasm for life of a previously crotchety bunch
of old soldiers disconcerted their doctors. For it transpired that their new-found euphoria
wasn't just an understandable reaction to being cured of physical disease.
MAOIs typically have mood-brightening properties as well. At the time, there
was no accepted and clinically effective treatment for depression. Fortunately,
via the usual circuitous routes, the appropriate lessons were eventually
drawn. Many millions of people were successfully treated with MAOIs in consequence.
Sadly, the role of MAO
in deaminating tyramine (from the Greek word tyros, meaning cheese) wasn't
at first understood. Certain MAOI-treated patients suffered hypertensive
crises after eating varying amounts of tyramine-rich
aged cheese; and several died. It is now recognised that the use of any
MAOI which is both irreversible
and unselective must be accompanied by dietary restrictions. But the adverse
publicity of the initial inexplicable fatalities, combined with the introduction
of a succession of dirty but sometimes tolerably effective tricyclic compounds,
sent the use and reputation of MAOIs into a precipitous decline from which
they still haven't fully recovered. The older non-selective
and (more-or-less) irreversible inhibitors tranylcypromine (Parnate), phenelzine
(Nardil) and isocarboxazid
(Marplan) are nonetheless valuable antidepressants. Outside America, the
the selective and reversible MAOI moclobemide.
is used too. Of greater interest still
are central-nervous-system-selective compounds, notably the neuroprotective antidepressant and anti-Alzheimer's drug TV3326 (ladostigil). MAOIs that lack the peripheral effects
of currently explored drugs herald an exciting new window of
therapeutic opportunity.
SELEGILINE (l-deprenyl, ELDEPRYL, EMSAM)
A recent New York study showed that smokers had on average 40%
less of the enzyme, monoamine oxidase type-B, in their brains than non-smokers.
Levels returned to normal
on their giving up smoking. Not merely is the extra dopamine in the synapses
rewarding. The level of MAO-b inhibition smokers enjoy apparently contributes
to their reduced incidence of Parkinson's
and Alzheimer's disease.
Unfortunately they are liable to die horribly and prematurely of other diseases
first.
One option which the dopamine-craving
nicotine addict might wish to explore is switching to the (relatively) selective
MAO-b inhibitor selegiline, better known as l-deprenyl. Normally the brain's
irreplaceable complement of 30-40 thousand odd dopaminergic cells tends
to die off at around
13% per decade in adult life. Their death diminishes the quality and intensity
of experience. It also saps what in more ontologically innocent times might
have been called one's life-force. Eighty percent loss of dopamine neurons
results in Parkinson's disease, often prefigured
by depression. In future, the mood-enhancing transplantation of customized stem cells
may restore a youthful zest for life in dopamine-depleted oldsters:
such stem cell-derived monoaminergic grafts are currently on offer only
to depressed rodents. Deprenyl has an anti-oxidant, immune-system-boosting
and dopamine-cell-sparing effect. Its use boosts levels of tyrosine
hydroxylase, growth hormone,
superoxide dismutase
and the production of key interleukins. Deprenyl offers protection against DNA
damage and oxidative stress by hydroxyl and peroxyl radical trapping; and
against excitotoxic damage from glutamate.
Whatever the full explanation,
deprenyl-driven MAOI-users, unlike cigarette smokers, are likely to be around
to enjoy its distinctive benefits for a long time to come, possibly longer
than their drug-naïve contemporaries. For in low doses, deprenyl enhances
life-expectancy, of rats at least, by 20%
and more. It enhances drive, libido and motivation; sharpens cognitive performance
both subjectively and on a range of objective tests; serves as a useful
adjunct in the palliative treatment of Alzheimer's
and Parkinson's
disease; and makes you feel good too. It is used successfully to treat canine cognitive dysfunction syndrome (CDS) in dogs. At dosages of around 10
mg or below daily, deprenyl retains its selectivity for the type-B MAO iso-enzyme.
At MAO-B-selective dosages, deprenyl doesn't provoke the "cheese-effect"; tyramine is also
broken down by MAO type-A. Deprenyl isn't addictive, which probably reflects
its different delivery-mechanism and delayed reward compared to inhaled
tobacco smoke. In November 2004, Yale University researchers launched a study of deprenyl for smokers who want to quit tobacco. Whether the Government would welcome the billions of pounds
of lost revenue and a swollen population of energetic non-taxpayers that
a switch in people's MAOI habits might entail is unclear.
L-deprenyl/selegiline can now be delivered via a transdermal
patch. In December 2004, pharmaceutical firms Bristol-Myers Squibb and Somerset
Pharmaceuticals announced they had entered into an agreement to distribute and commercialize EMSAM, the first transdermal treatment for major depression. After various delays, in February 2006 the FDA
granted EMSAM a product license for the treatment of major depressive
disorder in adults. EMSAM's pharmacokinetic and pharmacodynamic
properties promote the inhibition of MAO-A and MAO-B in the CNS
while avoiding significant inhibition of intestinal and liver MAO-A
enzyme. Three different strengths of EMSAM patch are currently
marketed: 20mg/20cm2, 30mg/30cm2, and 40mg/40cm2,
delivering daily doses averaging 6mg, 9mg and 12mg respectively. Use of
the lowest dosage EMSAM 6 mg/24 hour patch calls for no dietary
modification. At this dosage, MAO-A in the digestive tract is preserved
at levels adequate to break down tyramine, while MAO in the brain is
inhibited at levels adequate to induce an antidepressant effect. A
restricted "MAOI diet"
is prudently advised for the higher dosage EMSAM 9 mg/24 hr patch and
the 12 mg/24 hr patch to avoid any risk of hypertensive crisis. But
it's worth noting that (as of February 2010) no hypertensive crises following dietary indiscretions have been reported even in users of the high strength patches.
RASAGILINE (AZILECT)
Unlike deprenyl, the novel irreversible selective MAO-B-inhibitor rasagiline (Azilect) is not metabolized to methamphetamine or amphetamine. These trace amines are unlikely to contribute to deprenyl's neuroprotective action. Rasagiline gained an EC product license as Azilect in mid-2005 for the symptomatic treatment of Parkinson's disease. Azilect finally gained a US
product license in May 2006. In August 2008, Teva announced promising
results from a late-stage Phase III 18-month rasagiline trial.
Parkinsonians who took a 1mg Azilect pill once a day from the start of
the trial showed "significant improvement" over patients who started taking Azilect nine months later.
MOCLOBEMIDE (MANERIX, AURORIX)
Humans now have the capacity to choose their own individual level of activity
or inhibition of the two primary monoamine
oxidases. This does not quite enable the fine-tuning of personality
variables with the functional equivalent of a graphic equaliser. It still
represents a promising start. In MAO-inhibition, as in life, more is not
always better. Excessive dosages of l-deprenyl, for instance, may
actually shorten, not increase, life expectancy - at least in Parkinsonians
if it's combined with l-dopa.
And levels of above 80% inhibition of MAO-A may lead to a sharp and possibly
unwanted fall in dopamine synthesis. Repairing
Nature's niggardliness will be a priority for the decades ahead.
Moclobemide (Manerix, Aurorix),
the "gentle MAOI", is both a selective and reversible inhibitor
of MAO-A. It marks the first RIMA to win clinical
acceptance. Moclobemide lacks anti-cholinergic side-effects. It promotes the healthy growth of new neurons in the hippocampus. No dietary restrictions
are needed. It is valuable as more than a mood-enhancer and resilience-booster. For moclobemide
is often useful in overcoming social phobia, panic
disorder, obsessive-compulsive
symptoms, irritability and aggression owing to the way it enhances serotonin
function. (The casual use of gobbledygook such as "enhanced x function"
will rightly alert the reader that many complications are being skirted
or omitted. Those hungry for the greater technical
detail of a non-popular account can rest assured the literature will leave
them feeling abundantly well-nourished).
TRANYLCYPROMINE (PARNATE)
Gentleness doesn't
suit everyone. Moclobemide isn't much good at lifting deep melancholy.
Tranylcypromine (Parnate), on the other hand, is one
of the older and non-selective MAOIs - and is often none the worse for it.
Structurally related to amphetamine, tranylcypromine is generally the most stimulating,
dopaminergic and relatively fast-acting of the MAOIs. Some doctors are uncomfortable
with its properties. This isn't just because of the dietary restrictions
its use demands. In adequate doses, tranylcypromine tends to induce a mild euphoria even in
"normal" subjects. Tranylcypromine use increases trace amines, modulates phospholipid metabolism
and up-regulates GABA(B) receptors. In fact, its nicest effects, as for all of
the compounds cited here, will vary in nature and extent from person to
person. To some extent, optimal dosage and long-term drug-regimen of choice
can be discovered only by (cautious) empirical self-investigation.
Tranylcypromine is of course
vastly preferable to the amphetamines
and cocaine. Yet frequently and
perversely, the more hazardous the drug, then the easier it is to get hold
of in our society. The carcinogenic cocktail that carries off more people
than all other toxins combined can be purchased quite legally and effortlessly
at any tobacconist or newsagent. Obtaining the less lethal - but scarcely socially
desirable - street opioids and psychostimulants
requires a little more exertion. Yet they can still be readily purchased
in pubs and clubs in all the big towns and cities. Many of the more beneficent
drugs discussed here, on the other hand, are unlicensed, "investigational", or available on a prescription-only
basis. They're not illegal to possess. But they are hard to obtain
short of visiting countries where they're available over-the-counter or
using online pharmacies of uncertain reputation.
If the central principle
at stake here were the preservation of a drug-free society, then some sort of
totalitarian (or, more euphemistically, paternalistic) argument could be
cobbled together for violating personal freedom so oppressively. Yet that's
rarely the issue. For in most cases, the issue effectively amounts, not
to drugs or no drugs, but to allowing people the choice to opt for better
ones. Perhaps 80% of the population in Western countries currently drink ethyl
alcohol or smoke cigarettes.
Often they do both. Whether viewed in terms of mortality, morbidity or overall
quality of life, we'd be better off if we switched
to enhancing receptor sub-type selective dopaminergic, opioidergic, serotonergic and cholinergic function by the
relatively safe, if crude, agents touched on here; and
perhaps to the more exciting
products under development. As a basic minimum, people shouldn't
be legally robbed of the right to do so.
This freedom of choice
isn't conventional wisdom. It will be suggested that the level of medical
expertise required to make informed choices exceeds that of the average
layperson. A quasi-priestly medical caste wielding the power of the prescription-pad
would doubtless wish to keep it that way. But the intrinsic difficulty and
complexity of psychopharmacology or nutritional medicine, say, doesn't
demand greater mental effort than, for instance, all those thousands of
grimly unnatural hours spent by school students learning mathematics. Moreover
it's far more interesting to study something palpably relevant to one's
emotional well-being than something that demonstrably isn't. The notion
of an education system geared to schooling people in, and for, happiness
would nonetheless strike adherents of the reigning educational orthodoxy
as abhorrent were it not so largely incomprehensible.
WORKING FOR A DRUG-FREE FUTURE
Suppose, for a moment, that the reproductive success of our DNA had been
best served by coding for ecstatically happy vehicles rather than malaise-haunted
emotional slum-dwellers. If this had been the case, then none of the pharmacological
interventions discussed in The Good Drug Guide would be necessary.
Life-long well-being would seem only "natural". We would all enjoy gloriously
fulfilled lives. Each day would be animated by gradients of
bliss. Unpleasant states of mind would be viewed as a tragic aberration.
Bad thoughts and bad feelings could be diagnosed as a freakish but clinically treatable type of psychopathology.
Of course, it didn't work
out that way. Instead, the inclusive
fitness of our genes has been served by the "natural" manufacture
of some of the most vicious
psychological adaptations imaginable. Sadness and anxiety are "normal". Discontent is "adaptive". Everyday emotional pain is part of "what makes us human".
The rot goes deeper. Selfish DNA can count
on innumerable dupes to act as its distal representatives even today as the biotech revolution unfolds. The
need for "character-building" emotional pain gets justified with all manner
of sophistries, both religious and profane. Suffering is good for you, one
may be told. It's all part of life's rich tapestry.
Actually, suffering exists only because it was
good for our genes. Conditionally-activated negative emotions were fitness-enhancing in the ancestral environment.
In the current era, apologists for mental pain are serving as the innocent mouthpieces of the
nasty bits of code which spawned them. If pressed, primordial DNA's unwitting spokesmen
would presumably disavow any such connection. Yet if one were purposely
building an intelligent robotic survival-machine, then endowing it with
the illusion of free-will would prove a highly fitness-enhancing adaptation.
It's a trick which our genes stumbled upon; and then blindly exploited.
Fortunately, over the
next few centuries humanity will be able to outwit its ancient genetic
masters. Our present status as throwaway genetic vehicles will finally
be subverted. When gradients of heavenly well-being become the genetically predestined
norm of mental health, then the very notion of tampering with our new-won
"natural" condition and feeling "drugged" may come
to seem immoral. It may also seem perverse. Why should anyone want to contaminate
the divine ecstasy of their spirituo-biological soul-stuff with chemical
pollutants? No thanks.
Today's twisted victims
of the primordial genetic code, on the other hand, view the notion of sullying
their natural state of being through
psychoactive drugs with a much more deep-seated ambivalence. They adopt it as a near-universal
practice. Given the inadequacy of the third-rate pharmacological stopgaps on offer, and
the lack of any serious drug-education, it's scarcely surprising we're so poor
at using them. Thus concerned parents are surely right to worry about the
trashy street drugs taken by their kids. Early in the 21st Century, "Just Say No" is frequently still a good rule-of-thumb. Yet with the right new genes and
designer-drugs, there's no reason why mature Post-Darwinian
life shouldn't just get better
and better.
Jing Luo (Channels and Collaterals | Meridians and Sub-Meridians)
Jing
Luo are the main channels of communication and energy distribution
in the body.
Link interior Zang Fu organs with various tissues of superficial
areas of the body. In this way they allow for internal adaptation
to external change.
They connect different superficial areas of the body.
The Jing Luo are more external (and more Yang) than the
Zang Fu Organs. When pathogens penetrate the body from the
Exterior, they usually penetrate the superficial channels
and then the main channels and finally the Zang Fu Organs.
Jing Luo cover the entire body.
Every
part of the musculoskeletal system is related to a main meridian
and its associated sub-meridians.
Via
the main channel, every part of the body associated with a
given internal Organ can be affected by imbalance in that
Organ.
Example:
The Bladder channel: connects the small toe, lateral aspect
of foot and ankle, posterior aspect of leg, buttocks, sacroiliac
and dorsal region, occiput, vertex, central frontal region
and inner canthus of eye.
Knowing the pathway of the channels, we can make connections
in symptoms as diverse as itchy eyes, occipital headaches,
lumbar pain and spasms in the gastrocnemius. For example,
the Heart channel begins in the axilla and ends on the small
finger. It has long been noted in western biomedicine that
in the case of myocardial infarction, the pain often travels
along this channel. TCM provides a link between this external
muscular pain and an imbalance in the associated internal
Organ.
Distribution
of the Jing Luo
Most
superficial: Cutaneous Regions
Deeper
Tendinomuscular
Meridians in the musculature
Province
of Wei energy
1st line of defense and adaptation
Deeper
Luo
Meridians
Associated
with Main channels but are more superficial. Link Yin
and Yang coupled pairs. Link Primary Meridians with surrounding
tissues.
Deeper
Divergent
Meridians
Reinforce
the circulatory network of 12 Primary Meridians. Provide
more functional contacts between Yin and Yang channels.
Deeper
12
Primary Meridians
Connect
with Zang Fu Organs. Carry mainly Ying (Nutritive Qi)
and Blood.
8
Extra Vessels
CV
GV and Chong Mai originate in Kidney Organ. The others
connect with Principal channels.
Function:
strengthen association between channels and control,
store and regulate Qi and blood of channels (reservoirs).
Carry mainly Yuan Qi.
The
sub-meridian system (superficial channels) has the main functions
of maintaining normal function providing for adaptation to
changes in the external environment. This adaptation can often
occur without the circulation of Qi in the main Meridians
being too affected.
There is much disagreement regarding the pathways of the Luo
and Tendinomuscular channels. In any case, these channels
do not have their own points but share points of the Primary
Meridians. The flow of Qi through these channels is affected
by needling points on the Principal channels.
The
Channels of Acupuncture
In
Chinese acupuncture anatomy, the internal organs of the body
are all interconnected with one another by pathways called
meridians, which are located throughout the body. The concept
of these pathways could be compared with Western ideas of
the blood vessels and capillaries, or the nervous system
with its centers and peripheral branches This system is
not,
however, the same as either of these other systems. The meridians,
unlike the blood vessels, which can be seen with the naked
eye, are not visible. As the blood vessels function as pathways
for the blood, so the meridians are pathways in which energy
is circulated throughout the body.
The
meridians spread out through the entire body connecting all
the tissues and organs of the body binding it together as
an organic unit. They regulate normal functioning of the body,
and diagnostically reflect pathology or illness. Meridians
are also referred to as Vessels, Chings, or Channels.
In
acupuncture we generally consider that there are 72 channels
of therapeutic importance:
12
Primary Meridians
12
Tendinomuscular Meridians
12
Transversal Lo Vessels
12
Longitudinal Lo Vessels
12
Distinct (Divergent) Meridians
8
Extra (Ancestral) Vessels
3
Extra Longitudinal Lo Vessels
1
Huato Channel
The
most important and essential ones for the circulation of Qi,
and for most therapeutic applications are the twelve Primary
Meridians and two of the Extra Vessels. The twelve Primary
Meridians are also known as the twelve Chings.
The
two extra Meridians are the Governing or Du Vessel (DU), and
the Conception or Ren Vessel (REN). (The term Conception Vessel
does not imply that this Vessel is exclusively concerned with
the female, although it does have extensive connections with
the female reproductive system, and is frequently used in
the treatment of gynecological disturbances. It is, however,
present in both male and female).
These
two Extra Vessels are usually included in a listing of the
twelve Meridians, because of their importance in the circulation
of energy, and their value in many treatment formularies.
They also have their own acupuncture points.
Some of the meridians of the body run in a more or less horizontal
direction, while others run vertically. The twelve Primary
Meridians are vertical channels.
The
twelve Primary Meridians are also bilateral. This means they have
symmetrical pathways on either side of the body in relation to the
median (mid-line) of the body, just as we have a right and a left side.
There is a Lung meridian on both the left side of the body and the
right side of the body, and similarly with all of the other eleven
Meridians. The acupuncture points for the various Meridians are in the
same mirror image locations on either side of the body.
Summary
We have 12 bilateral Meridians. The two special vessels (the
Conception Vessel and the Governor Vessel) are not bilateral.
They are singular channels, which follow the midline of the
body, one in front and one on the back. The following pages
are diagrams of the locations of the meridians on the human
body.
There
are a number of ways in which the Primary Meridians can be
classified. One method is to classify them into two groups,
according to their polarity of Yin and Yang. The Chinese determined
that some of the Meridians are predominantly of Yin energy,
and some are predominantly of Yang energy.
The
Primary Meridians are also grouped together in coupled pairs,
each Yin meridian being coupled to a specific Yang meridian.
The pairs are coupled according to the table above, i.e.,
Lung with Large Intestine, Spleen with Stomach, Heart with
Small Intestine, Kidneys with Bladder, Pericardium with San
Jiao, and Liver with Gall Bladder.
Another way of classifying the Meridians is based on the main
location of the Channel and its terminal point. Six Meridians
are located on the upper portion of the body, and start or
end on the fingers. The other six Meridians are located on
the lower portion of the body and end or start at the toes.
Which gives us the following relationships:
By
combining the Yin/Yang and Hand/Foot classifications or
groupings, we get the following
Abbreviations
Pathway
3
Yin Meridians of the Hand
(LU,
HT, PC)
Chest
to Hand
3
Yang Meridians of the Hand
(LI,
Sl, SJ)
Hand
to Face
3
Yang Meridians of the Foot
(ST,
BL, GB)
Face
to Foot
3
Yin Meridians of the Foot
(SP,
KI, LV)
Foot
to Chest
As
you can see, so far, the Meridians have been classified
into a division of two groups according to Yin and Yang,
hand and foot, and as coupled pairs. We are going to classify
the Meridians according to the traditional Chinese idea
of the cycle of Qi within the Meridians. The Chinese determined
that the energy flows from one meridian to the next in a
continuous and fixed order. It flows from meridian to meridian
in a two-hour cycle, making the complete circuit
once a day.
This
cycle is known as the Horary cycle.
As the Qi makes its way through the meridians, each meridian
in turn, with its associated organ, has a two-hour period
during which it is at maximum energy. The Horary Effect
is recognizable by measurable increases of Qi within an
organ system and meridian during its time of maximum energy.
(Qi is, of course, present within every organ system all
the time; its level simply fluctuates according to the Horary
Cycle.)
If
a person moves from one time zone to another, the resultant
"jet lag" is a result of the biological Horary clock adjusting
to the new time frame. Moving East or West causes this phenomena,
but moving due North or South has no effect on the internal
clock.
Just
as each organ system has a waxing and waning two hour period
of maximum energy on the Horary Cycle, there is also the
minimum energy effect of the organ on the opposite, side
of the cycle, 12 hours apart. An example of this is that
while the Lungs have maximum energy from 3-5 AM, the Bladder
on the opposite side of the table is at its minimum energy
level, 3-5 PM. Qi begins entering the Lungs at 3 AM, and
has reached its maximum concentration in the organ at 4
AM. By 5 AM it has done its tonification and repair work
and is moving into the Large Intestine channel.
Knowledge
of this cycle and its energetic effects is necessary for
highly effective acupuncture treatments, as the various
organs respond either very well or very little to acupuncture
depending on their energetic state at the time of treatment.
The Horary Cycle is an excellent diagnostic tool and will
be dealt with on the diagnostic level later in this course
work.
The
flow of energy begins with the Meridian of the Lungs and
completes its cycle with the Liver, to commence again
at
the Lungs, continuing the daily cycle throughout an individual's
life span. The reason that the Chinese say that the flow
begins with the Lungs, is that they consider the first
independent function of a child at birth to be its first
breath.
Circulation
of Energy Through the Primary Meridians
The
Classical Order of Meridians
Lungs
3
AM to 5 AM
Large
Intestine
5
AM to 7 AM
Stomach
7
AM to 9 AM
Spleen
9
AM to 11 AM
Heart
11
AM to 1 PM
Small
Intestine
1
PM to 3 PM
Bladder
3
PM to 5 PM
Kidney
5
PM to 7 PM
Pericardium
7
PM to 9 PM
San
Jiao
9
PM to 11 PM
Gall
Bladder
11
PM to 1 AM
Liver
1
AM to 3 AM
As
you can see in the table of Classical Order of Meridians, the energy
flows from one Channel to its coupled pair, and then on to the next
coupled pair. The following is a diagram showing the order of energy
circulation through the meridians.
The
Twelve Meridians - In Classical Arrangement
Hand
Yin Lung Meridian (LU)
Hand
Yang Large Intestine Meridian (LI)
Foot
Yang Stomach Meridian (ST)
Foot
Yin Spleen Meridian (SP)
Hand
Yin Heart Meridian (HT)
Hand
Yang Small Intestine Meridian (SI)
Foot
Yang bladder Meridian (BL)
Foot
Yin Kidney Meridian (KI)
Hand
Yin Pericardium Meridian (PC)
Hand
Yang San Jiao Meridian (SJ)
Foot
Yang Gall Bladder Meridian (GB)
Foot
Yin Liver Meridian (LV)
The
Governing Vessel (DU), also called the Du Mai, or Du Channel
The
Conception Vessel (REN), also called the Ren Mai, or Ren
Channel
A
Yin meridian joins its Yang coupled meridian (and vice versa)
in the extremities, either the fingers or the toes. Yin meridians
of the Hand terminate in the fingers. Yang meridians of the
Hand begin in the fingers. Yang meridians of the foot terminate
in the toes. Yin meridians of the foot begin in the toes.
Note:
Although the Governing Vessel is of Yang nature and the Conception
Vessel of Yin nature, these two are not, strictly speaking,
a coupled pair in the same sense of the twelve Primary Meridians.
The difference lies in the fact that the coupled pairs of
P.M.s have specific channels of communication, which join
them together. These are the Transversal Lo vessels. The Conception and Governor
Vessels do not have Transversal Lo vessels, but rather connect
all the Yin channels (Conception Vessel) or Yang Channels
(Governor Vessel) respectively.
Each
Principal Meridian has its own Transversal Lo vessel.
These are actually crosswise connecting channels, known as
anastomoses. Since each Principal Meridian has one Transversal
Lo, each coupled pair of P.M.s is linked by two of these.
(The one exception is the Heart channel, which is linked to
the Small Intestine by only one Transversal Lo vessel. We could consider the Transversal
Lo vessels as the horizontal or transversal pathways of the
Meridians.
Understanding
the energetic function of the Meridians is the Chinese equivalent
of understanding the function of the organs in Western Medical
thought. The meridians are connected with, and have their
origin in, the internal organs: treating a meridian effects
the organ to which it is connected. The acupuncturist manipulates
the vital organs with needles utilizing the acupuncture points
along the meridians to achieve the desired effect.
The
practice of acupuncture rests upon the relationship that exists
between a specific area on the surface of the skin and a particular
organ or energetic function. The needles or stimulus acts
directly on the meridian, which in turn affects the associated
organ. The more appropriate the selection of the points on
the meridian, the better the treatment results. Within the
12 Meridians and the two Extra Vessels lie the majority of
acupuncture treatment technique.
The
series of acupuncture points upon the skin, which constitute
the outward line of the meridian, are primary evidence of
the meridians existence although the meridians themselves
are invisible. Acupuncture point locators indicate the difference
in electrical resistance that exists around acupuncture points.
The traditional methods of locating the points are by locating
specific anatomical landmarks, using special methods of measurement
which are valid for any human body, and by finger sensitivity.
Finger sensitivity is necessary in many areas of acupuncture
practice; locating the points, feeling the quality of the
pulses, feeling the grip that Qi is exerting on an inserted
needle, feeling (palpating) for sensitized areas of damage
on the body.
The
meridians provide communication lines between external body
appendages and surfaces and the internal organs; upper and
lower parts of the body; and provide for the circulation of
energy. They govern the body's ability to function, carry
Qi, and so contribute largely in the maintenance of health.
This energy can be manipulated at stations along these communication
lines, the acupuncture points along the meridians.
General
Pathways of the Meridians
The
circulating pathways of the twelve Meridians flow from the
face to the feet, from the feet to the chest, from the chest
into the hands, and from the hands back to the face. The Yang
Meridians generally flow along the outward (lateral) side
of the limbs and along the back of the body. The Yin Meridians
pass along the inward (medial) side of the limbs and along
the front of the body. It has already been mentioned that
the pathways leading to or from the arms are called Hand Meridians,
and those that descend to the legs or ascend from the legs
are the Foot Meridians.
The
three Yin hand meridians travel from chest to hand; the
three Yang hand meridians, from hand to head (face). The
three Yang foot meridians travel from head to foot; and
the three Yin foot meridians travel from foot to chest.
This describes the circulation of energy over the entire
body and delineates the pathways in which Qi, or energy,
flows.
With
the arms raised over the head palms facing forward, the
energy in the three Yin Hand Meridians (Lung, Heart, and
Pericardium) will be flowing from the chest to the fingertips,
upward along the forward portion of the arm. The energy
in the three Yang Hand Meridians (Large Intestine, Small
Intestine, and the San Jiao) will be flowing from the
fingertips, downward on the back part of the arm, to end
their flow in the face.
From
the head, the energy of TWO of the three Meridians of
the Foot (the Bladder and Gall Bladder, but not the Stomach)
will be traveling down along the side or back of the body
and outward side of the leg to end in the toes. To complete
the cycle, the energy in the three Yin Meridians of the
Foot (Spleen, Liver and Kidney) will be traveling up from
the toes along the inward side of the leg, continuing
along the front of the abdomen and ending in the chest,
at which point the cycle begins again from the chest to
the hand. There are exceptions to this, but the general
pattern is accurate.
The
Stomach Channel is one exception. Although it is a Yang
Meridian, it runs on the front of the body with the Yin
Meridians, instead of up the back like the rest of the
Yang Meridians. The other exception is the Governor Vessel,
which is a Yang Meridian in the center of the back, in
which energy flows upward as opposed to the rest of the
major Yang Meridians in which energy flows downward.
The
Governor Vessel, or Du Mai (Du or GV), follows the spine
upward on the back, travels over the head and ends on
the inner surface of the upper lip. It has no direct connections
to any internal organ. Its energy flow is Yang and ascends
from the bottom of the pathway beginning near the anus.
It connects with all the Yang Meridians of the body, and
is important in many conditions requiring manipulation
of the Yang energy of the body.
The
Conception Vessel, or Ren Mai (CV or Ren) travels up the
midline in front of the body. It runs from near the anus
to the mouth, and its energy is Yin, ascending from the
lower body to the upper, as does the Governing Vessel.
In effect, these two meridians vertically encircle the
body on its midline, front and back.
These
two Vessels are not bilateral. They do not
form a direct part of the organ meridian's energy circulation
network, nor are they associated with any one organ. They
belong to the eight Extra Vessels.
The
energy traveling from the chest to the fingertip is predominantly
Yin energy. Yet on its way back up the other side of the
arm, it becomes Yang energy. The energy changes polarity,
from Yin to Yang, or from Yang to Yin, the nearer it approaches
the extremities of the limbs.
The
energy traveling from the chest to the fingertip begins
as predominantly Yin energy, but as the energy approaches
the extremity the polarity begins to change, and by the
time the tip of the finger is reached the Yin becomes
progressively mixed with the Yang energy. Energy traveling
from the fingertips to the face begins as mixed Yin/Yang,
but by the time it arrives in the face it is predominantly
Yang energy.
Energy
traveling from the face to the toes begins as predominantly
Yang energy. As this Yang energy approaches the lower
extremities of the leg, the polarity begins to change
again. By the time the toes are reached the Yang energy
is mixed with the Yin energy in almost equal proportions.
The return from the toes to the chest causes the transformation
again. This Yin energy then flows back into the arm, to
continue the cycle.
It
can be seen, therefore, that as Qi circulates through
the Primary Meridians, it alternates in coupled pairs
of Yin and Yang Meridians, staying for two hours in the
Yin and two hours in the Yang, in a smooth alternating
rhythm.
In
the central area of the head and chest, even though the
energy passes from one Channel to another, there is no polarity
change. The head is the area where one Yang meridian joins
another Yang meridian, and the chest is where each Yin
meridian joins another.
The polarity change is not a sudden thing, but occurs
gradually, mostly between the elbow and the fingertips,
and between the knee and the toes. Therapeutically, it
is at points below the knee and below the elbow that energy
polarity changes can be most easily accelerated or retarded.
Within these limits, the most important control or energy
manipulation acupuncture points are found.
On
acupuncture charts, the meridians appear as thin surface
lines connecting a series of dots that represent the acupuncture
points. Actually, there is much more to each meridian
than what is shown in the acupuncture charts and diagrams.
Every Channel has an inner pathway and an outer pathway,
and it is usually the outer pathway with its acupuncture
points that is shown on most charts or drawings, and the
inner pathways are not accessible to manipulation by needling.
The
true extent of the Meridians cannot be shown by lines
on a two-dimensional drawing. On a drawing the lines show
us an imaginary line from point to point, which usually
represents the approximate centerline of the sphere of
influence of that Channel. According to the Chinese, each
Channel is connected to all the tissues, organs and functions
over which its acupuncture points have an influence or
produce an effect, whether in the immediate area of the
points or at a much distant area.
For
example:
Examine the Heart Meridian with its nine acupuncture points
running from the armpit down the inner surface of the
arm to the tip of the little finger, very close to the
surface. This much is shown on standard Meridian charts
and most diagrams. However, the Heart Meridian naturally
must be connected to the Heart, so it extends internally
from the armpit point to the organ of the Heart itself.
But, the Heart Meridian also has several other branches
deep inside the body. One runs to the Small Intestine,
and another branch connects to the head, specifically
with the eye, tongue and brain.
Major Acupuncture Points Chart Yuan-Source,
Luo-Connecting, Xi-Cleft, Five Shu Points, Front Mu, Back Shu, Mother,
Child, Entry, Exit, Four Command Points, Hui Meeting Points, and Four
Seas Points, all laid out in a matrix for easy reference.
The Eight Extraordinary Channels
Ren Mai (Conception Vessel), Du Mai (Governing Vessel), Chong Mai
(Thrusting Vessel), Yin Qiao (Yin), Yang Qiao (Yang), Yin Wei, Yang
Wei, and the Dai Mai (Girdling, Belt Vessel)
Circulation of Energy
This cycle is known as the Horary cycle. As the Qi makes its way
through the meridians, each meridian in turn, with its associated
organ, has a two-hour period during which it is at maximum energy.
Three Main Circuits of Qi Flow
Qi and blood flow through the channels by way of the Lou (Connecting)
points in the order depicted by the green and red arrows in the
diagram.
Yuan (Source) Points Each
of the 12 primary channels has a Yuan source point close to the wrists
or the ankles where the source Qi is described as surfacing and
lingering. In clinical practice, they are important in treating
disharmony of the internal Zang-Fu organs, and are often combined with
the Luo (Connecting) point of the interior-exterior related channel.
Luo (Connecting) Points Each
of the 12 channels has a Luo point that links the interior-exterior
related pairs of yin and yang channels in order. There are also three
additional Luo points; one for the Ren Mai (Conception Vessel), one for
the Du Mai (Governing Vessel), and the Great Luo Connecting point of
the Spleen. The Luo points establish a system for qi and blood to be
circulated throughout the entire body to nourish all tissues and the
Zang-Fu organs.
Xi (Cleft) Points The
Xi points are where the Qi and Blood which has flowed along the surface
from the Jing Well points is described as plunging more deeply. Xi
Cleft points are indicated generally for acute problems and pain, with
the Xi Cleft points on the Yin channels having the added ability to
treat blood disorders.
Hui (Meeting) Points
The Hui points, also called the Eight Influential or Gathering Points
are described as having a special effect on their related area; the
vessels, blood, bones, Zang, Fu, marrow, sinews, and Qi.
Xi (Confluent) Points The
Xi points of the eight extraordinary channels are used not only to
treat disharmony in the specified extraordinary vessel but also their
related primary channel.
Mu (Front) Points The
Mu or gathering or collecting points are where the Qi of the respective
Zang-Fu organs is infused. Located on the abdomen and chest, they are
in close to their related Zang-Fu organ, and may tender or sensitive if
there is disharmony in the underlying organ.
Shu (Back) Points There are 12 Back Shu points on the Bladder channel that correspond to each of the 12 Zang-Fu organs.
Window of Heaven
Also called Window of the Sky points, these points can be used for
rebellious qi and blood between the head and body, goiter and scrofula,
emotional disorders, and sense organ disorders.
Sun Si-Miao Ghost Points Originally appearing in the Thousand Ducat Formulas by Sun Si-Miao, these points were indicated for mania and epilepsy.
Course Title: Acupuncture: An Evidence-Based Assessment Credits: 1 hour of CME; 1.2 nursing contact hours (CEU) Cost: Free
Lecturer: Richard Hammerschlag, Ph.D., Dean of Research at the Oregon College of Oriental Medicine
Learning Objectives:
Discuss the history of acupuncture
Compare the differences between western medicine and Chinese medicine
Identify how acupuncture research is conducted
Describe research on the efficacy of acupuncture and the mechanisms underlying itsvarious uses
This lecture is part of the CAM Online Education Series. The series contains 10 chapters. Each lecture includes:
A video lecture by one author, including the transcript
A question and answer transcript
An optional online test
Additional resource links
A certificate of completion
Although developed for health care professionals to receive
continuing education, members of the public are invited to view the
series and learn more about various aspects of CAM and CAM research.
J
LBP, EAR AKU, CHAKRA ACU,
Thu, Mar 11, 2010 at 12:08 AM
The Ultimate
Acupuncture Point Formula for Relieving Low Back Pain
By John Amaro, LAc, Dipl. Ac. (NCCAOM), FIAMA, DC
Low back (lumbar) pain has been reported to be one of
the most
common conditions for which sufferers worldwide seek medical attention.
It has numerous causes and can never be lumped into one specific
etiological category.
The same is true for
treatment. There are numerous treatments
available, of which chiropractic and acupuncture have repeatedly
demonstrated their effectiveness in the majority of low back pain
syndromes. The most important treatment goals are to achieve a
successful level of pain reduction followed by correction and
stabilization of the condition. Most low back pain suffers will
wholeheartedly agree that pain relief is paramount, and as quickly as
possible.
In
my almost four decades of acupuncture and chiropractic practice, I have
seen thousands of cases of low back pain that have been successfully
treated. Only the very rare case has had to be referred for surgery. In
the vast majority of cases, regardless of the specific cause, the
patient has experienced significant pain relief in a very short period
of time with the administration of a specialized acupuncture point
formula. In many cases, pain relief was considerable before
chiropractic and/or physiotherapy procedures were even implemented.
This
formula is by no means a cure-all for every lumbar pain syndrome, but
has proven the test of time in countless cases. It does not do what
chiropractic can do regarding structure, nor does it do what physical
therapy, soft-tissue treatment, physiotherapy, therapeutic massage and
other non-invasive procedures can do to strengthen muscles, ligaments
or tendons. Its primary application is for early pain relief.
As
most practitioners of acupuncture are vitally aware, there are specific
points on the body that are key to most low back conditions. The
points, SI 3, BL 62, BL 40 (54) and "surround the dragon" are usual
points of application. It stands to reason that there are many other
points that may be selected for a variety of reasons and diagnosis, but
as far as a general overall pain-relief application, the aforementioned
acupuncture points are classic. It's important to note that any
additional points that a practitioner has used successfully may be
added to this basic formula without disrupting its effectiveness.
In
my experience, approximately 90 percent of typical cases of low back
pain can be predicted and expected to positively respond when one uses
the three major "30" points along with the previous mentioned points.
These three powerful points are known as GB 30, BL 30 and ST 30. GB 30
is directly over the sciatic nerve notch, a third of the way from the
head of the femur on a line drawn from the tip of the coccyx. BL 30 is
two-fingers breadth (1.5 tsun) from the midline (GV-DU MO),
bilaterally level with the fourth sacral foramen. This is level with
the top of the vertical buttock crease separating the right and left
gluteal areas. ST 30 is precisely two tsun bilateral to CV
(REN) 2, which is directly at the level of the symphysis pubes.
When
one uses the additional points of CV 3, KI 12, CV 4 and KI 13, the
clinical response can be potentially raised another percentage point or
two. KI 12 is one-half tsun bilateral to CV 3, which is one tsun
superior to CV 2. KI 13 is one-half tsun bilateral to CV 4,
which is one tsun
superior to CV 3. These four points, along with ST 30, are all points
on the lower abdomen. Most practitioners and patients will find it
unusual at first to use these points, since the pain is in the back.
However, its polar opposite effects and the fact that the lower Kidney
meridian is the direct opposite of the huo tuo jia ji points on
the back make them some of the most powerful points for low back pain
on the body.
So,
in essence, the ultimate low back pain acupuncture formula for general
pain relief, anti-inflammatory effects, increased blood flow and
relaxed supporting muscles consists of the following points: SI 3, BL
62, BL 40 (54), GB 30, BL 30, ST 30, CV 3, KI 12, CV 4, and KI 13, in
addition to the huo tuo jia ji points in the area of
involvement and local GV points, with GV4 (ming men)
being specific for lumbar pain. If you use this formula for low back
pain as a substitute for, or in addition to, points which have shown
success in your own practice, it is the very rare patient who will not
see outstanding clinical pain relief in a very short time.
It is imperative that other
procedures such as gua sha,
direct low-level laser, cold therapy and heat therapy also be used.
However, these acupuncture points can lead to successful symptom
resolution without the use of ancillary treatment.
Even though
I always recommend 12 treatments in cases of lumbar pain as a trial of
therapy, I fully expect to discharge the patient from acute pain relief
to stabilization care within the first four visits. Do not become
discouraged if on some occasions it takes longer. However, the better
you become with this procedure, the better your response will be.
These
points are ideally treated with needles, but laser, electronic and
percussive stimulation also may achieve favorable response. Needle
retention should be no longer than 10 minutes with either electrical or
manual stimulation.
All the best for your success using this
formula. Drop me a note and share some of what I expect will be
dramatic and successful responses. I would love to share your
experiences in a future article. You can also contact me and request a
graphic of these points should you wish to see them on a human form for
easy application. Simply send your request for the Ultimate Low Back
Acupuncture Formula directly to my e-mail address. All the best in
2010, the Year of the Tiger.
_____________________________________________
Spinal Hua Tuo Therapy
By John Amaro, LAc, Dipl. Ac. (NCCAOM), FIAMA, DC
Without question, some of the most dynamic
acupuncture points on the human body are known as the Hua Tuo jiaji
points. These points are extremely easy to locate and use. They respond
not only to the acupuncture needle, but also to any type of percussion
such as a neurological reflex hammer, Wartenberg pinwheel, tuning fork,
green and red laser, percussive instrument, gua sha, teishein
(non-invasive needle) or firm digital pressure.
Any form of stimulation works absolute wonders in
clinical practice when it comes to the Hua Tuo jiaji points.
The points were discovered by the legendary physician Hua Tuo,
who was born in 110 A.D. and lived to the unprecedented age (at that
time) of 97. He was reputedly murdered by the ruler of the Wei Dynasty
after the ruler suspected an assassination attempt when Hua Tuo
suggested brain surgery for his severe headaches. Hua Tuo was
considered immortal, as he appeared to be in the prime of life even
while approaching 100 years old. He was rumored to have found the
secrets of exceptional health and longevity. He was known to stimulate
his discovered points routinely, which may explain his unnatural
longevity and health.
Spinal points actually
extend both upward through the cervical spine and downward across the
sacrum. However,only the 17 bilateral points attributed to Hua Tuo
carry his name as Hua Tuo jiaji. The points in the cervical
spine and sacrum are correctly and simply known as jia (lining)
ji (spine).The Hua Tuo jiaji
points are located just 1/2 human inch (a human inch is the distance
across the widest part of the patient's thumb) bilateral to the Du
Mai (GV) midline over the vertebral spinous process, bilateral from
T1 through L5. The shu (associated points) of the 12 primary
meridians, beginning at T3, are located 1.5 tsun from the Du Mo
midline. These points work in startlingly similar fashion to the meric
(mere = zone) system of chiropractic.
In
traditional chiropractic circles, exceptional clinical response in most
health conditions is thought to be obtained by treating an insulted
nerve at the level of the intervertebral foramina due to displacement
of the vertebrae; in modern times, explained as a vertebral fixation.
These spinal fixations will cause both hypertonicity and hypotonicity
of the paravertebral musculature, resulting in a neurothlipsis or
so-called "pinched nerve." The nerve involved will affect the organ and
tissue at the level of the involvement. Thus, the third thoracic
vertebrae has a direct response to anything in the level of the lung
including the bronchi, pleura, chest, breast, etc. This same
explanation extends up and down the spine with respect to all organs,
muscles, bone and structures of the body.
Hua Tuo
developed a system of healing that appears to be remarkably similar to
this approach; however, he did it 2,000 years prior to the discovery of
both osteopathy and chiropractic. By the stimulation of these specific
points at the precise vertebral level, virtually any condition known to
man can be positively affected. That does not mean to say these points
will cure everything; however, in my experience, the success
rate in using these points at the precise locations is nothing short of
miraculous.
The
key is to understand the exact
level of the vertebra in relation to the organ and tissue it controls.
For example, Thoracic 6 is specific to the stomach, whereas Thoracic 7
and 8 are specific to the spleen/pancreas. The jiaji points
of C7 are specific to the thyroid, as well as the shoulders and elbows.
The classic acupuncture point known as BL 10 is 1.3 tsun bilateral to
DU 15, which is just below the pseudo spinous of the first cervical
vertebrae. However, the jiaji point, located 0.5 tsun lateral
to DU 15, will affect the pituitary gland, scalp, brain, inner and
middle ear, and sympathetic nervous system. An "energetic subluxation"
at this point will manifest itself in neurasthenia, insomnia,
hypertension, migraine, chronic tiredness, vertigo, headaches and
susceptibility to colds.
These reflexes are very
specific and have been a vital part of certain specialty practices of
chiropractic for well over a century. The stimulation of the Hua Tuo
jiaji
points is not a routine or well-known procedure in the chiropractic
profession. However, the reflex levels are classic and extremely
well-established. I always advise practitioners to stimulate not only
the Hua Tuo jiaji points, but also the GV itself and if
appropriate, the shu point during treatment. Gua sha
is an exceptional way to stimulate these points, as it is quick, easy
and effective.
In
as much as the specific reflex areas of the spine are not exclusive to,
but generally only used by specialty practices, it is assumed that most
chiropractic and acupuncture practitioners are unaware of the exact
location of these points. Contact me directly at dramaro@iama.edu
dramaroiama.edu if you have questions and I will be glad to
help.
It was recently announced that the U.S. Air Force will begin training physicians
being deployed to Iraq and Afghanistan in a specific type of treatment.
The treatment uses small needles in the skin of the ear to block pain
in as few as five minutes and can last for several days or longer. The
procedure was initially introduced in 2008 at Landstuhl Regional Medical Center
(LRMC), where it was applied to wounded service members and local
patients for pain relief, with significant results. The hospital,
located near Ramstein Air Base in Germany, is the largest and
most modern U.S. military medical facility outside the United States.
One
of the pain specialists at LRMC personally experienced a 25 percent
increased range of motion and a 50 percent reduction in pain for
chronic shoulder and upper back pain he had endured for several years.
As a result of his outstanding success, this pain specialist recruited
his most challenging patients, for whom traditional pain treatment had
offered limited relief. Within minutes of the needles being inserted,
many said their pain was reduced by up to 75 percent. A 25 percent
reduction would be considered a success with traditional pain
medications.
Despite
its name, battlefield acupuncture is not
purposely designed to replace standard medical care for war-related
injuries, but rather to assist in pain relief and in many cases
eliminate the need for pain medication for acute and chronic pain. This
procedure is extremely easy to learn and may be taught to anyone in an
extremely short time. It allows a provider to confidently complete a
treatment and expect a good result within minutes. There are virtually
no complications and patients are subjected to little or no discomfort.
It
has been reported that only approximately 15 percent of patients do not
respond to this acupuncture procedure, but of those who do, their pain
reduction often averages about 75 percent. The frequency of application
and the duration of relief vary with each patient, but treatment can
progress from about two times a week to as little as once a month or
longer. In some cases, further acupuncture treatment may not be
required.
There are
five specific ear points that are
classically used; however, many practitioners only use two. The five
points are: Wonderful Point (also known as Point Zero), Shen Men,
Omega 2, Thalamus and the Cingulate Gyrus. The Cingulate Gyrus point
and the Thalamus are the two points all practitioners use.
As in so many acupuncture procedures, practitioners may
place the
points in different locations. The Cingulate Gyrus has also been called
the Subcortex by Terry Oleson, PhD (international authority on
auriculotherapy). Beate Strittmatter, MD,
a German authority, places it slightly differently (see Illustration).
Personally, I use both locations just to make sure I cover all of my
bases.
The Omega 2
point is on the internal of the helix. Due
to the thinness of the auricle at this point, any stimulation from the
exterior will contact the Omega 2 point. Some may wish to approach this
point from the interior, but I personally go from the exterior.
The
Thalamus point is directly opposite on the internal side of the
exterior points known as the Temple or Sun. Most battlefield
acupuncture practitioners approach the Thalamus from the internal
position. However, I have always felt this point could be accessed just
as easily by stimulation of the Temple (Sun) points from the exterior,
and have used it that way for years.
The official procedure uses
gold semi-permanent needles, which are placed directly into the point
and left to fall out on their own in a day or two. I have seen
marvelous results with low-level laser directly to the points, as well
as electronic stimulation. Conventional acupuncture needles may be
stimulated for 10 minutes. Then use an acu-patch, which is a small
stimulation sphere attached by flesh-colored adhesive. This can be left
in place for several days or longer.
This procedure is too
valuable to overlook in your general practice. It is easy, quick and
effective. Do not limit yourself to just acute or chronic pain with
this combination of points. It is also extremely effective in anxiety,
neurosis, neurasthenia and any psychological or stress-related issues.
Perhaps one of the most perplexing clinical
questions concerning
ear acupuncture is which ear to treat for maximum effectiveness. As
most practitioners are aware, some "authorities" have advised that if
"the patient is a woman," treat the left ear.
On the other hand, other "authorities" say to treat the
right ear based
on yin/yang principles. The same is true for male patients. Some
authorities say if the problem is truly on the left side of the body,
treat the opposite side; other authorities advise to treat the same
side as the affliction. If the problem is an internal disorder, some
say to treat both ears; however, an equal number recommend treating one
ear or the other, based on a multitude of principles which have been
shown to be highly questionable.
I personally knew of a quite elderly MD in the early
1970s who returned
to practice with his MD son after being in retirement for more than 15
years. The senior doctor was so taken by the ease, effectiveness and
excitement of "auriculotherapy" that he joined his son's internal
medicine practice, attending to patients three days a week, seeing
between 35 and 50 patients a day.
The junior doctor had
purchased a used dental chair for his enthusiastic father, and the
senior doctor (bear in mind, he was in his upper 80s) had his charts on
the wall in front of him and a stool which was perched on the patients'
right side. He treated every patient's right ear because that was where
his stool was located. Based upon his stellar clinical response, which
was probably more due to his infectious enthusiasm and expectation than
his skills, one would think you should always treat the right ear. It
certainly seemed to work for him. However, when I studied in extreme
Northwest China in 1980 and in Tibet in 1985, I learned of what I
believe to be one of the most significant applications of which side of
the body to treat. I have personally used this procedure for well over
25 years and can speak of its value.
In 2003, I wrote a two
part series titled, "The Caduceus, Chakras, Acupuncture and Healing."*
I highly recommend you read these two articles for a general
background, as space limitations do not allow me to explain the entire
procedure in explicit detail. Be sure to read the part concerning the
nations that have contributed to acupuncture education. This is
imperative.
In
those two articles, among a variety of educational thoughts, the general
concept of the "ida," "pingala" and "sushumna"
was discussed. This provides the basic framework for the procedure to
be discussed here. Ida is the feminine (yin) or right side,
which is activated through the breath through the left nostril, whereas
the pingala is the masculine (yang), which is activated through
breath in the right nostril. The sushumna
constitutes the spinal tracts and cord (GV and CV). The three of these
make up what we know as the intertwining snake comprising the chakras,
the energetic basis for the meridians and what has become to be known
as the medical caduceus. Please bear in mind, the concepts of the ida
(feminine, right, yin), pingala (masculine, left, yang) and sushumna
(Ren and Du) are mind numbing as to detail and only a fraction of the
explanations are discussed here.
Quite simply, if you were to apply pressure to the
outside of the right
nostril, blocking it completely, and breathe deeply through the left
nostril, and then repeat the procedure by applying pressure to the
outside of the left nostril (blocking it completely) and breathing
deeply through the right nostril, you would discover that you have a
definite nostril which is more open than the other. In the acupuncture
programs I teach, we demonstrate this to the surprise of the entire
class. A class of 50 or more will demonstrate the above-described
procedure, and fully 48% of the participants will clearly show a right
nostril open, whereas another 48% will show the left nostril open
completely. The remaining 2% will report both nostrils are equally open.
This is extremely significant; if
the "right" nostril (pingala) is more open, this means the
left brain (masculine, analytical) is in full activation, whereas if the
"left" nostril (ida)
is more open, the right brain (feminine, creative) is fully engaged.
From an ear acupuncture approach, and many applications of body
acupuncture to include cerebral acupuncture, this means if the right
nostril is open, the left ear is more receptive to treatment; if the
left nostril is open, treat the right ear. If both nostrils are open,
treat bilaterally.
The most stunning part of this concept is
that the person of usual health will naturally shift back and forth
between the left and right nostril being open in relation to the
harmonics and flow of the horary cycle as it goes through the four-hour
element cycle of each of the 12 meridians in a 24-hour day. As a
general rule, the average person will shift from left to right and back
again every three to four hours, as each of the specific elements has a
four-hour maximum flow before moving to the next dominate element.
Lung and Large Intestine (Metal) are from 3 a.m. to 7
a.m., followed by
Stomach and Spleen (Earth) from 7 a.m. to 11 a.m. If a practitioner
checked a patient and found both nostrils equally open, this would mean
the patient is in a state of transgression between left and right,
suffering from a malady that does not permit the shift from left to
right. This is critically important. Of equal importance is a person
who, because of chronic sinusitis, a deviated nasal septum or other
cause, is not allowed to shift the openness of the nostril throughout
the day.
In
essence, the bottom line is that before initiating
either ear acupuncture or cerebral acupuncture, always have the patient
completely block each nostril in turn by pressing firmly with the
finger on the nasal ala and breathing deeply through the unimpeded
nostril. The nostril that is open indicates treating the opposite side
(ear or cerebral). If the nostrils are determined to be open equally,
it is imperative to treat bilaterally.
Initiating this concept
into your clinical practice will reap incredible clinical responses
possibly not seen in previous applications. Remember: Even if you do
not do this procedure routinely, you are still going to have a
50-percent chance of choosing the right ear. Try it and let me hear of
your victories. It is truly spectacular.
The Caduceus, Chakras,
Acupuncture and Healing, Part II
By John Amaro, LAc, Dipl. Ac. (NCCAOM), FIAMA, DC
Part I of this article (DC,
April 21) explored the historical perspectives and healing corollaries
of the medical caduceus, represented by the double-coiled serpent, as
it relates to the chakras and acupuncture.
As I was preparing that article, I found it difficult to
encapsulate
the information into a format consistent with this column space. The
topic of the caduceus and chakras, as it relates to acupuncture and
healing, may well be one of the most challenging I have endeavored to
describe. This is only because of the vast amount of information this
topic encompasses, including the philosophies of dozens of nations,
both ancient and contemporary. I soon realized that what I have learned
over the years and practice clinically on this topic could easily fill
a book.
As
a student of the Asian healing arts for over three decades, I have
observed firsthand healing principles in nine separate Asian nations.
However, my studies have taken me to a variety of nations and
historical times I have not personally observed, yet still formed my
education. This was most recently brought to mind with the world
focused in 2003 on the Middle East, specifically Iraq; Syria; Turkey;
Iran; Afghanistan; Pakistan; and India.
Most
practitioners of
acupuncture and Asian medicine in the Americas, Australia and Europe
tend to think of China as the place of origin of this style of healing.
However, when one explores the numerous healing disciplines, from
scores of nations, that have contributed to the development of
traditional Chinese medicine (TCM) over the centuries, the amount of
knowledge is humbling, to say the least. These contributions have
occurred from all of the mentioned Middle Eastern nations, ancient
Greece and Rome. The healing philosophies of Persia and India have had
an extremely strong influence in developing the philosophical concepts
that created the healing principles of Tibet and Nepal.
The
primary nationality comprising China's westernmost regions has a strong
medical tradition that combines Islamic (Unani) medicine with ayurvedic
medicine of India, along with TCM. The Hui, or Muslim
Chinese, are most heavily concentrated in Northern and Western China.
Much of their medicine has, at its root, a strong Arabic influence,
introduced when the Arabs came into Western China in the ninth century.
As the Arabs conquered the Mediterranean, what they gathered from the
Greeks in regard to medicine became a vital part of the medicine and
philosophies of the entire Middle East.
Part I of this article drew a
strong corollary between the double-coiled snakes around a single shaft
and its relationship to what was referred to in the spinal tracts of
Indian medicine as the "ida," "pingala" and "sushumna"
that comprise the kundalini,
or the power centers of the body. (Refer to part I for illustrations.)
Every time the ida and pingala, represented by the snakes in the
caduceus, cross one another, the crossing forms what is referred to as
a "chakra" when applied to the body.
Historically,
these chakras are represented on the front of the body, and correlate
with what we know in acupuncture as vital acupoints.
The study
of the chakras is a topic that goes well beyond the space limitations
of this column. I urge the reader to visit his or her local book dealer
for a variety of literature devoted to the significance of the chakras.
You may contact me at the e-mail address at the end of this article for
specific sources. It is imperative, however, that those involved in
Asian medicine explore the importance of the chakras in its creation
and distribution of the energetic field of the body.
Anyone who
has ever studied Asian medicine is familiar with the ancient concepts
of the "five elements," as it forms one of the most practical, clinical
and historical foundations of acupuncture. The relationships between
the elements, the meridians they represent, and general factors
affecting the body, are time-honored. There is a strong relationship
between the chakras and the five elements in Western, Tibetan,
Nepalese, and even Southern Chinese acupuncture.
Examine Figure 1 and Figure 2.
Please note that the chakras on the anterior body indicated by the
crossing of the two tracts have a specific relationship to a specific
acupuncture point and vibratory color, namely:
Note that each chakra has a particular relationship to a yin
and yang
coupled set of meridians (e.g., 5th chakra-Ren 22-Bl/KI). Also note
each chakra is associated with a particular color, consistent with the
colors associated with the elements in five-element acupuncture. The
meridian correlation to a chakra is based on the color associated with
the five elements. For example, green is associated with the wood
element, which, in turn, is associated with the LIV/GB meridian.
Chakra
Acupoint
Color
7th
DU 20
violet/white
6th
YinTang
indigo
5th
Ren 22
blue
4th
Ren 17
green
3rd
Ren 12
yellow
2nd
Ren 3-8
orange
1st
Ren 1
red
In Figure 2,
on the posterior of the body, please note that each chakra has a
specific relationship to a particular vertebral level. For example, the
5th chakra is connected with DU 14, between C7/T1. The
meridian and color relationship, as in the anterior body, are the same
for the posterior body.
To utilize one of
the most powerful
healing affects in ancient Western Chinese, Persian and Indian
acupuncture, make a correlation between the involved meridian and the
associated chakra, and utilize acupoint locations on the anterior (yin)
and posterior (yang) side of the body related to the involved chakra.
One
of my favorite clinical stories that illustrates this concept relates
to a gentleman whose son-in-law lives in Paris. The son-in-law suffered
from extreme low-back pain with radiating sciatica, which was
excruciating. After exhausting all forms of "alternative" medicine,
including acupuncture and chiropractic, the patient was scheduled for a
decompression laminectomy. Prior to going into the hospital for
surgery, the patient was advised of a "healer" who practiced on the
third floor of a building in Paris, not far from the patient's home. He
was convinced he should at least give it one more chance. On arriving
at the building, he was met with three flights of stairs, which he
navigated slowly and painfully. After explaining the history of the
problem, the practitioner simply placed his two overlapped fingers
directly on the top of the patient's sternum at the manubrium. After
holding this spot for approximately two minutes, the healer leaned away
from the patient and asked how he felt. The patient, being a busy,
no-nonsense businessman, was mortified this was all the practitioner
had in mind to do. Disgusted with the fact he had just climbed three
flights of stairs with considerable pain, he turned, and in a huff,
started down the stairs. When he reached the first landing, he suddenly
turned and went back up to the practitioner, demanding to know what he
had done to him. The pain that had been so excruciating had suddenly
lifted to a tolerable ache. The patient returned the following day for
a follow-up treatment that completely resolved his condition, at least
with regard to pain. His surgery was cancelled. Two full years have
passed with no return of the symptoms.
This
is an ideal example
of the abovementioned principle in action. Due to the patient's spinal
condition, it was ascertained through acupuncture principles that he
had involvement of the bladder and kidney meridians. Each is associated
with the water element, which is associated with the color blue. The 5th
chakra is likewise associated with the vibratory energy of "blue."
Therefore, in five element/chakra balancing, this action will be taken
directly at Ren 22, which is the 5th chakra.
Since
many of the conditions we see clinically are of the musculoskeletal
variety, it behooves us to recognize that muscles, tendons and
ligaments are under the influence of the wood element, associated with
the meridians of the gallbladder and liver. These two meridians have
their related chakra at CV (Ren) 17. One of the most startling clinical
responses you can expect results from stimulation of CV 17 in any
musculoskeletal-ligamentous condition. Likewise, it is imperative one
take action on both the yin and the yang chakra, by stimulating DU 11
between T5/6.
The same is true for the 3rd
chakra,
as it connects with the stomach meridian and the earth element. Its
posterior chakra is specifically at the double-point of DU7 and DU6,
between T10/11 and T11/12. It is imperative to realize that the earth
element is divided: The 2nd chakra is likewise associated
with the earth element; however, it is related specifically to the
spleen meridian and associated with the color orange. This entire area
from the navel to the pubic symphysis constitutes what is known
as the "tan tien" or center of energy. The spleen meridian in
TCM is responsible for the creation of chi through nourishment.
Those with metal-element situations affecting LU/LI
will receive significant results by stimulation of the 7th
chakra relating to DU 20 and specific vertebral stimulation at DU16 at
the atlanto/occipital area. Keep in mind: The color associated with the
7th chakra is violet; however, white is likewise associated
here, as it is the culmination of all the colors. White is reflective
of the metal element. DU 20 has a powerful effect on any condition
affecting the lung or large intestine meridian. Academically, it is not
a classic point for these meridians, but it is extremely important in
the "chakra" style of acupuncture. Symptoms associated with the fire
element have shown stunning success by utilizing Ren 1 in the perineum.
It can also be reached through the posterior at DU3 between L4/5. As
opposed to stimulating Ren 1 in its delicate location, utilizing the
Korean hand point (at the base of the hand, just distal of the wrist on
the palmar surface) has yielded stellar effects.
The one chakra that does not have a specific color associated
with the five elements is the 6th
chakra: indigo. This becomes a combination of the blue of the 5th
chakra and the violet of the 7th chakra. In clinical applications, it
has a very strong influence with the kidney meridian. Just as the 2nd
and 3rd chakras are divided into the color of orange (which
does not exist on the five elements) for the 2nd chakra and
yellow of the 3rd chakra, the same thing occurs at the 5th,
6th and 7th chakras. Consider the bladder
meridian associated with the 5th chakra, and the kidney with
the 6th.
Note
how the ida and pingala cross at DU 26; however, no mention of a chakra
is located here. This is perhaps one of the most powerful points on the
body for a variety of conditions, which is often overlooked in
acupuncture. Most practitioners know this point to be effective in
reviving a fainted patient; however, it is extremely powerful for pain
and anxiety. It meets all of the criteria of a chakra in that it is at
the junction of the crossing ida and pingala; however, it is usually
not associated with a chakra location. DU 26, in my opinion, is a
landmark acupuncture point. Begin to use it for any pain condition.
This point is so powerful, I will have to reserve further comment for
an entire article devoted specifically to its application.
Any
practitioner who is academically knowledgeable of the five elements can
utilize some creative imagination and successfully treat hundreds of
conditions specifically through the chakras. Assume a patient visits
your clinic with the complaint of macular degeneration. Besides the
typical medical approach to this condition, the practitioner will draw
a corollary between the eyes and the liver meridian. This, of course,
would be associated with the green, which is the 4th chakra,
with its key point on the yin side at CV (Ren) 17 and yang side at DU11
T5/6.
Electromeridian
imaging (EMI) has shown incredible promise in contemporary acupuncture
with regard to this application. On electronic examination, any time a
paired meridian, such as BL/KI or LU/LI, is involved by being elevated,
depressed or split, direct action to the chakra has shown quicker
stabilization of the meridians. This same concept can be applied to
auriculotherapy (ear acupuncture). This is accomplished by discovering
the involved paired or single meridian electronically, then locating
the corresponding ear point. The effect is extremely noteworthy.
When
one begins to correlate the various factors attributed to the five
elements, such as environmental; emotional; body parts; senses; and
tastes, and begins treating both the yin and yang chakra related to
specific conditions, it opens up a dimension in acupuncture that is one
of the easiest and most effective to utilize in your practice.
Be sure to read my previous articles on EMI [www.chiroweb.com/archives/20/20/01.html
and www.chiroweb.com/archives/20/26/01.html].
This contemporary method of diagnosis, combined with the ancient
principles of acupoint chakra balancing, will create a new environment
in your office that will be rewarded by increased referrals, financial
benefits, and most importantly, patient satisfaction.
In the early days of my career, I treated a young lady
who had suffered
extensive neurologic injuries to her face after slipping while cleaning
the side of the bathtub. She'd experienced agonizing nose and facial
pain, 24 hours a day, seven days a week, for over four years.
She complained of multiple paraesthesias, and that her
teeth felt like
"mush" against her tongue. Virtually every medical doctor in every
specialty she consulted ultimately suggested psychiatric care, simply
out of total frustration in their failure to eliminate (or even reduce)
her horrific pain.
The
DCs my patient saw were some of the best, including technique experts
in cerebral manipulation; endonasal technique; kinesiology; and various
adjustive procedures from the atlas to the coccyx. She consulted me for
the possibility of acupuncture, even though it was quite new in the
U.S. in 1973. In those early days of acupuncture, only the most
desperate patients sought it.
Although I
was young in my
practice, I possessed incredible confidence, albeit backed by minimal
clinical experience. After numerous acupuncture treatments;
chiropractic adjustments to the spine; manipulation of the hard and
soft palates; and "pulling" her uvula, I came to the hard realization
that I, too, had failed her. I suggested she see a psychiatrist. Why,
when a patient fails to respond, are we so eager to put the blame on
the patient's mentality?
One evening, I
felt a sudden urge to
find a newspaper article I had saved in a large box in the back of my
closet. After dragging out the box and extracting papers, photos, etc.,
I found a small steno notebook. I threw it over my shoulder to join the
rest of the heap, but instead, it struck me right between the eyes,
scratching my forehead with the sharp edge of the projecting spiral
binding.
The notebook landed in my lap,
with a page staring up
at me that said, "For nasal pain - point #17." There was also a small,
barely legible sketch I had drawn of a hand with the acupoint
illustrated. This was the notebook I used on my first visit to China in
1973, when I visited the Tai Chung Medical School in Taipei. It was at
the school that I was first presented with the concept of Chinese hand
acupuncture.
Talk about something hitting
you right between the
eyes! I immediately thought of my patient, and wondered if this point
could do something for her. Up to that point, I had used every method I
knew, and had accepted that I was going to have to relieve her from
care.
On her next visit, I stimulated the
point I had
discovered, quite by accident, the night before. She was irritated with
me, because the only procedure I performed during that visit was to tap
with a noninvasive needle (teishein) on a point on her wrist.
She felt the simplicity of this treatment was inadequate to help her
raging pain, and wanted me to do more. Frankly, at that point, there
was nothing else I knew to do.
As she
walked through the
reception room on her way to the door following her treatment, the
patient slumped into a dead faint in the middle of the floor. Upon
reviving, she explained that she had been overwhelmed because, as she
moved across the room, her pain and paraesthesia, which had been of the
highest magnitude, were suddenly and instantly relieved.
I
can't explain it, and it makes no sense to my physiologic (or just
plain logical) mind, but it happened. I shall never forget that
acupuncture point, located two fingerbreadths distal to the dorsal
wrist crease, in line with an imaginary line drawn down the middle of
the index finger.
The patient was released
from over four years
of devastating, unexplained pain and paraesthesia in a matter of
seconds - an incredible testimony to acupuncture. However, it is
imperative to understand the whole message, not just the specific point
used. The real message is to always act upon those glimmers of innate
intuitive insight, and to truly listen to that small voice whispering
in your ear throughout the day. Anyone who has been in the health care
field long enough to be called a "veteran" knows exactly what I am
talking about. Sometimes, the answer to a troubling case may come to
you in the most unusual way. Always be receptive to innate, intuitive
thoughts regarding patient care.
Years
ago, I attended what may
have been one of the first graduate school programs in acupuncture in
the United States. The principle speaker, from Kowloon, China, stated,
"When you don't know what to do any more with a patient, or didn't know
what to do in the first place - always consider tsing (jing-well)
points, because they're magic. "My initial thought was that this was an
extremely exaggerated, simplistic statement, barely worthy of note.
However, I scribbled the thought down, which as we know, unfortunately
often ends up buried in a myriad of words and paper, never to be seen
again.
Months passed, and my practice
became increasingly
filled with fewer and fewer open appointments. Acupuncture was at a
fever pitch, as the general public was inundated with positive reports
of its effectiveness from the media.
As I
was closing the
office one evening in late spring, the front door opened. Standing
before me were a mother and father carrying their daughter, who was in
obvious severe neurologic insult. Gazing upon this twisted child, I
wondered how, because of her advanced condition, the parents could care
for her. I then noticed the hospital band on her wrist. The parents
explained to me that they were in the process of returning the child to
ChildrenÕs Mercy Hospital, as they had been out on a rare day pass.
Apparently, it was the child's seventh birthday, and she had been taken
home to celebrate with friends and family. This was to be her last
birthday. The prognosis was grave.
The
diagnosis from the Mayo
Clinic was Òidiopathic neurogenic syndrome. Since she suffered from an
unusual, unexplained neurologic condition, there was treatment to save
her life, only to prolong it Ð and that was failing. She presented
rigid neurologic opisthotonis; death imminent.
On the way back
to the hospital following the party, which was literally a living
funeral, family and friends gathered to be with the child one last
time. The child's parents passed my office and decided to stop. Having
heard of the benefits of acupuncture, they wondered if perhaps it could
help.
As the parents explained the gravity
of the situation,
including the diagnosis and prognosis, I was frankly overwhelmed. With
tears streaming down their faces, they asked if I could treat their
baby. Looking at this pitifully rigid child and the parents, I
reluctantly told them, "I'm sorry, this is really out of my league, I
wouldn't even know where to begin." When they asked if I would just
try, as they had literally nowhere else to go, or even if I would work
on her as a research project, I again responded with apologies and
sorrow that I wouldn't even know where to begin.
At that point,
it became as if someone was sitting on my shoulder, whispering, "When
you don't know what to do anymore, or didn't know what to do in the
first place, always use the tsing points, because they're
magic." Was it a thought in my head, or were these words being
whispered to me? In any event, the feeling was too strong to ignore. I
took a nonpenetrating teishein (one of the original nine
acupuncture needles first described) and stimulated each and every one
of the 12 meridian tsing
points next to the nail bed, for approximately 15 to 20 strokes apiece.
I then took a green marking pen and marked each point I had just
stimulated, instructing the parents to repeat this procedure every day
in the morning and evening, using a ballpoint pen.
Even though
they realized they were now on the way back to the hospital to watch
their daughter's eventual demise, the parents left the office with a
glimmer of hope and the words of a master. (I am embarrassed to say I
never even got his name.)
That event
happened on a spring
evening. One morning that fall, this child began school with her
regular class. I only officially saw her once; however, the parents
stimulated the tsing points of that child with love,
compassion and expectation twice a day. I was invited to her eighth
birthday party! To this day, I still use a green felt-tip pen to mark
points for follow-up stimulation.
From
where did this point
selection arise? It had absolutely nothing to do with my academic
excellence or highly evolved intellect; it came directly from innate
intuition, and listening to what was being said. How many times do we
hear, but not listen? Sometimes, we are afraid to act, because the
thought may be contrary to what we felt was proper academia. Be alert
and aware of the many clues and fleeting thoughts received throughout
the day. Acting on some of these innate intuitions can be extremely
rewarding.
My last celebrated case of
innate intuition bordered
on the eerie. I recently saw a middle-aged woman complaining of
multiple visceral symptomatologies. It appeared as though every system
of her body was pathologically involved, from respiration to the
cardiovascular, digestion, musculoskeletal, lymphatic and endocrine
systems. She had seen a variety of specialists and was taking 14
different medications. She presented an extremely complicated case
history that, when the primary doctors she was seeing came in, needed
to be filed in two folders because of the sheer mass of the paperwork.
I
began treatment on her using the "electro-meridian imaging" (EMI)
method of diagnosis; it showed extreme involvement of 10 of her 12
meridians. She had been to a TCM practitioner I know has a stellar
reputation, but even with his years of practice, he could not commit to
a TCM diagnosis. To say this was a complicated case would be an
understatement.
One afternoon, while
driving my car, I was
stopped in traffic and found myself wandering mentally. I thought of
this patient, what her underlying problem might be, and what I could do
for her. As I sat gazing out the passenger window, another vehicle
pulled up beside me and rolled just past my window as its rear bumper
came into my direct view. I couldn't help but notice its license
number: LU6-TW4.
I tried my best to talk
myself out of using
these two acupuncture points on this patient; however, having been in
similar situations before, I had no choice. Following the first
treatment, the patient's condition worsened, which I did not think was
possible. However, by the next morning, she reported feeling
considerably improved. I treated her two times a week for four weeks,
at which time she stated she felt like an entirely new person. I also
balanced her meridians using EMI.
A recent
examination by her
primary medical physician revealed major improvements in her blood
chemistry. Her symptoms are a fraction of what she previously
experienced. Her EMI exam is close to being balanced. She is energetic,
sleeps all night and has regained her appetite. She came into the
office recently stating she had just signed up for a yoga class. She is
excited about the future, as her extreme depression is now just a
memory. She has received a total of 12 treatments.
LU6 is the hsi point and TW4 is the yuan
point. They have to have a rational explanation. However, how they
worked together in this case is a mystery to me. I guess the biggest
mystery is, whose car was that?
Of course,
this is just a
freaky coincidence... or a script from a "Twilight Zone" episode... or
a total fabrication - a dream after too many Shitake mushrooms. Our
rational mind will not allow for any other explanation. However, these
events are around us daily. Take advantage of them.
We are
often presented with the answer to our patients' problems (or our own)
in unusual ways. We may see a sentence in a book or a billboard that
triggers a thought, hear a statement on TV. Act upon it. Don't be
afraid to let intuition enter your thoughts. These thoughts, coupled
with sound academic principles, are extremely powerful. Keep yourself
mentally attuned by constant reading and study, but also allow the
sixth sense to become a part of your being.
One of the most
significant masters I have had the good fortune to study with said it
best: "When the student is ready, the teacher shall appear."
Best wishes for a healthy, happy, productive 2003.
John Amaro, DC, FIAMA, Dipl. Ac, LAc Carefree,
Arizona
Spectacular Acupuncture Points in Diffuse
Musculoskeletal Pain -- with or without Needles!
By John Amaro, LAc, Dipl. Ac. (NCCAOM), FIAMA, DC
The treatment of musculoskeletal conditions by
acupuncture is
legendary. There are perhaps no modalities in the healing arts which
are as effective for specific area pain relief. As a general rule,
acupuncture is most easily applied to a particular joint or area of
musculoskeletal complaint with the use of acupuncture point stimulation
at the area of complaint.
This procedure known as "surround the dragon" is one of
the most
classic of acupuncture techniques. It is used throughout the
acupuncture world and has been for centuries. But what happens when the
pain is extreme and diffuse throughout the body? How do we treat and
where is our focus?
In
"surround the dragon" for localized problem areas, acupuncturists
palpate tender (ah shi) points in and around the area of complaint and
stimulate them. Even though needle stimulation is most often thought of
as acupuncture, it must be remembered, "Acupuncture is a principle, not
a technique." Therefore, many forms of stimulation are as effective as
needles: simple electronic stimulation; noninvasive pressure
stimulation through a "teishein"; red light laser stimulation; heat;
cold; pressure; and ultrasound. In addition to "surround the dragon,"
traditional Chinese medicine (TCM) recognizes three patterns of disease
which are most often connected with diffuse systemic pain and are
extremely important to treat. They are "dampness," "blood vacuity
(deficiency)" and "exterior wind."
Dampness
Dampness
is primarily associated with loose stool; fatigue; nausea; general
heaviness in the body; multiple painful sites; and joint stiffness,
with difficulty in locating an exact point of pain. The tongue is
greasy and the pulse is slippery and boggy. According to TCM, the way
to treat this situation is to remove dampness by supplementing the
spleen. When musculoskeletal conditions arise as a result of dampness,
it responds remarkably well to the liberal use of moxa, which can be
used through the use of a moxa stick held close to specific points, or
by attaching moxa to the end of the needle and allowing it to burn. A
practical approach is to have the practitioner mark the points for the
patient and have the patient apply warming moxa to the specific points
at home through the use of a moxa stick held close to the point. There
are a number of specific acupuncture points which have a remarkable
effect on conditions brought on by dampness. They include:
GB 34 (outside of knee), the most
important of all the musculoskeletal points of multiple site pain
origins;
ST40, classically used to
disperse phlegm;
SP 9
(inside of knee), removes dampness;
JEN MO 9
(CV 9) removes dampness;
SP 3, SP 6
supplements spleen qi;
BL 20 (associated point for the spleen);
LIV
13 (alarm point for the spleen tip of the 11th rib), the major
meeting points of the viscera;
JEN MO 12 (CV
12) with CX(P) 6, extremely effective in
conditions of nausea and constriction of the chest as a result of
dampness;
ST 36 supplements spleen qi;
SP
21, great luo point, deals with any systemic pain due to
dampness.
Exterior Wind
Exterior
wind is a common occurrence which is responsible for multiple
musculoskeletal pain sites. Even though exterior wind can produce
multiple pain sites, it is most often associated with the neck, upper
back and shoulders. Wind generally is much more of an acute pain than
that of dampness, coming on very quickly even in the otherwise healthy
individual. These conditions usually occur when the patient has been in
direct wind situations, such as having a fan or air conditioning duct
blowing on them. It may even occur when a patient is protected from the
wind but wind is exhibiting itself in the environment such as a very
windy day. It is the energy of wind in the environment which is the
culprit. In these situations the extraordinary meridians become taxed,
which generally produces the pain. In TCM, the tongue has a thin white
coat and the pulse is considered floating. In needle therapy, it is
suggested to use a superficial stimulation. In situations where cold is
combined with wind, moxa to the points are very effective. The points
of significance in wind conditions are:
GB 34, specific meeting point for all the
sinews;
GB 31 disperses wind from the
lower half of the body;
LI 4 disperses wind from the upper half of the
body;
BL 12, point where perverse
wind energy enters the body, disperses wind;
BL
10, GB 20 are points just below the occiput that disperse wind
and also are points where wind enters the body;
BL 11, point of significance for any bone
problem;
TH 5 and GB 41,
master points for the balancing of the yang wei mo and du mai;
significant in any multiple joint or musculoskeletal pain, especially
as connected with arthritis;
SI 3 and BL 62, master points for
multiple pain, especially of the back; deals with the governing vessel
and yang qiao mai.
GV 14 and LI 11,
used in fever.
Blood Vacuity (Deficiency)
This
pattern creates diffuse relatively mild pain which and produces
discomfort on palpation throughout the body. The pain is most often
described as being in the flesh, as opposed to the joints or muscles.
The patient generally presents appearing sick with symptoms of pale dry
skin; brittleness of the nails; fatigue; insomnia; nervousness;
vertigo; and general emaciation. In TCM diagnosis, the pulse is thready
and the tongue is pale. Treatment is focused on supplementing qi and
blood and supporting the spleen. It is advised to use few needles and
to avoid strong stimulation. Moxa is also effective when used with a
moxa stick applied to the point. Points of significance are:
ST 37, ST 39, used for vague general
pain with lowered energy ("Sea of Blood" points);
SP
4, master point for supplementing blood and affecting the
spleen meridian;
SI 6, powerful point for general pain in
the elderly or very weak;
BL 11, great
bone point but also a point associated with Sea of Blood;
BL 20, associated point for the spleen;
BL
17, diaphragm point but also meeting point of blood;
GB
34, master point for the sinews;
SP 10, powerful point to increase blood;
ST
36, SP 6, supplements spleen and affects blood.
The points you have been presented with here are some of
the most
classic points historically used by "masters" in the field of
acupuncture. They are simple to use, especially with noninvasive
procedures, and produce spectacular results. Should you use needles, do
not leave the needles indwelling more than 20 minutes at a maximum. If
you have the patient use a moxa roll on the points themselves at home,
remind them to just warm the point as opposed to overheating it.
I
have written this article for those who are familiar with the location
of the aforementioned acupuncture points. If you are a neophyte or
confused as to the location of these points, be sure to include
acupuncture postgraduate education in your schedule this year. You
absolutely cannot afford not to. You've been given the keys. Now go out
and open the doors to allow the pain to leave. Let me know of your
stellar cases.
Use Some of the Most Powerful Acupuncture Points as an
Adjunct to Your Practice!
By John Amaro, LAc, Dipl. Ac. (NCCAOM), FIAMA, DC
In the practice of acupuncture, there is no question
that some of the
most powerful points on the body are the "MU" points, otherwise known
as "alarm" points. These points are diagnostic, therapeutic, and have
stood for centuries as first-choice points by countless masters in the
treatment of a multitude of health conditions.
Each
of the specific acupuncture meridians has an alarm point on the
anterior side of the body which is located over the organ for which it
is named, i.e., the lung meridian is over the lung, the gallbladder
meridian alarm point is over the gallbladder, etc. All but two of the
alarm points are on the chest and abdomen. Those two points are found
at the tip of the eleventh and twelfth rib and correspond to the spleen
and kidney meridians, respectively. Master Asian acupuncturists
use these points extensively, but the typical contemporary practitioner
has a tendency to disregard these points in favor of others. In my
opinion, to ignore these points is perhaps one of the worst mistakes a
practitioner can make.
I like to refer to
the alarm points as
being the circuit box of the body. If a health condition exists and a
meridian is involved, it will "trip a circuit breaker." If the lung
meridian is involved in a case of bronchitis, the lung alarm point is
the localized therapy for those skilled in muscle testing (applied
kinesiology) but will also be acutely tender to palpation.
There
are a number of factors concerning acupuncture which are extremely
significant in the diagnosis and treatment of meridians. For example,
the functions of the skin are controlled by the lung meridian; muscle
and ligaments are controlled by the liver meridian; and hearing is
controlled by the kidney meridian. Emotions such as grief, sorrow,
worry, fear and anger are associated with individual meridians, as are
environmental factors, which may trigger disease processes.
One
of the primary treatments involving the principle of acupuncture, which
virtually any practitioner may employ, is to simply palpate and treat
the tender alarm points. Since each alarm point is directly associated
with a specific meridian, a general treatment approach affecting all of
the alarm points would not be out of order. Treatment may consist of
something as easy as firm, direct digital stimulation for 12-20 seconds
per point, or simple electronic stimulation via one of the inexpensive
but powerful electronic devices available today. Acupuncture is a
principle not a technique. There are a number of acceptable ways
(without needles) to treat an acupuncture point, although proper needle
procedures to these points create dramatic effects.
One of the
easiest methods, and one in which your patient may participate, is to
utilize the Koryo Sooji Chim or Korean hand system to generally
stimulate one or all of the meridian alarm points. In 1971, a complete
system of acupuncture was discovered which today has over 20,000
practitioners internationally. These practitioners practice a system of
acupuncture that employs nothing more than the use of specific points
on the hands. Each meridian point on the body has a corresponding point
on the hand.
Examine the charts of both
the body alarm points
and the Korean hand system. General stimulation of these points will
provide dramatic response. Even if you are a neophyte in acupuncture,
using the points shown here is easy, effective and available. I
strongly urge you to use these points.
Here is my wish to you for a wonderful holiday
season and the best in 2000, "The Year of the Dragon"!
The "Forbidden Points" of Acupuncture!
By John Amaro, LAc, Dipl. Ac. (NCCAOM), FIAMA, DC
Of the approximately 1,000 acupuncture points on the
body, only a few
have been shown through historical and clinical experience to be
contraindicated for certain types of stimulation. Throughout
history, the two primary methods of acupoint stimulation have been
moxibustion, the burning of the herb artemesia vulgaris at the
acupoint, or the insertion of acupuncture needles.
Today, with the advent of electronic forms of
stimulation and laser
beams, the acupuncture points which are forbidden to both acupuncture
or moxa can be safely and effectively treated.
One
of
the most memorable experiences in my acupuncture career involves a
class I was teaching some years ago. Commenting on the birthrate in Mao
Tse Tung's People's Republic of China, I noted that in the mid-1960s,
Chairman Mao issued an edict proclaiming no married couple could have
more than one child. This was an attempt to keep the population of
China at one billion or less by the year 2000. The latest estimates I
have seen of China's population is 1.4 billion. Even though it was a
noble attempt, it didn't quite work. However, it is hard to imagine
what the population would have been had this edict not been put forth.
If
a woman in China is pregnant with a second child, or in numerous cases,
if the couple knows the first pregnancy is a girl, the couple will go
to the medical clinic for an abortion. One common method of abortion is
simply to use strong acupuncture point stimulation of San Yin Chiao
(SP6) in conjunction with He Gu (LI4). The abortion is generally
realized within 24 hours.
After relating
this information to
the class, a doctor in the class suddenly became pasty white and began
to experience dry heaves. He ran outside, and through the closed doors,
I could hear him become violently ill. During the class break, I found
the doctor in the hall with his head in his hands sobbing
uncontrollably. The doctor stated that he and his wife had been married
for 12 years, and with both he and his wife having come from large
families, they were excited about having their own. They both wanted a
houseful of kids.
As the doctor continued,
he told me his wife
had been pregnant seven different times over their 12-year marriage.
Each time she became pregnant, shortly into the pregnancy, she would
miscarry. She had sought the help of numerous specialists to no avail.
She had no problem in becoming pregnant, but could never take the fetus
to term.
The doctor was distraught about
the "abortion" points.
To boost her immune system and provide the best possible health for his
wife's pregnancies, he had stimulated SP6 and LI4 each time she was
carrying. He was sick to think he may have inadvertently caused the
abortion of the fetuses.
The story ends on
a happy note. At
last report, the couple have three children. They named the first
child, a girl, Johnna (after me)!
Take
appropriate caution concerning the following list of forbidden
acupoints. Disobeying the rules can be quite costly.
Point --Stimulation
Point --Stimulation
LU 11 Moxa LU
10 Moxa LI 4 Needle during pregnancy LI 15
Moxa LI 19 Moxa LI 20 Moxa ST1
Needle ST 2 Needle ST 7 Moxa ST 8 Moxa ST 9 Needle (deep) ST
17 Needle, moxa ST 25 Needle during
pregnancy ST 32 Moxa SP 2
Moxa during and shortly after pregnancy
SP 6 Pregnancy SP 7 Moxa HT 1
Needle HT 2 Needle SI 10
Moxa SI 11 Needle SI 18 Moxa
BL 1 Moxa BL 2 Moxa BL 6
Needle BL 49 Needle BL 51
Moxa BL 54 Moxa BL 56 Needle
BL 60 Needle during pregnancy BL 62 Moxa BL 67 Needle during pregnancy KI 11
Needle P(CX)8 Needle two times in same treatment or
with nasal polyps
Most
acupuncture authorities will agree with this list. It is imperative
that acupuncturists know and understand the potential risks if these
points are stimulated with needle or moxa. Laser and electronic
stimulation have been shown to be acceptable substitutes in virtually
all cases.
The Pulse Points from the
Second Century A.D.
by John Amaro,DC,FIAMA,Dipl.Ac.(NCCAOM)
The Han Dynasty, which flourished from 206 B.C. to 220
A.D., gave us
one of the most revered books on acupuncture ever written, namely the Nan
Jing, otherwise known as the "Classic of Difficulties." It was
written following the first book on medical conditions, the famous Nei
Jin.
The Nan Jing discussed a number of topics,
including the
"eight extraordinary meridians," the theory of the mother/son rule
regarding tonification and sedation, the Luo points, and the meridians
and points. However, the Nan Jing is best known for introducing
pulse diagnosis to the wrist.
Previously, acupuncture pulse diagnosis was used at a
variety of
points, with most meridians having multiple pulse locations. A very
little-known technique used in acupuncture, which developed within the
first 400 years of the first millennium, was the stimulation of the
related pulse points to affect the associated meridian.
Practitioners of acupuncture from the far Western
provinces of China
use this technique to generally affect the meridian channels. The
points shown here are of historical significance, because it was at
these points that acupuncture pulse diagnosis was originally used.
Should you have a difficult case in which you have
properly ascertained
which meridian is involved, use the points listed here, and you may
find remarkable clinical response. Even though there is very little
further information on this ancient system of healing, it definitely
bears our attention.
Lung LU9 - LU5 - LU4, LU3 - LU2 - LU1
Large intestine LI4 - LI5 - ST4
Stomach ST5 - ST9 - ST30 - ST42
Spleen SP11 - SP12
Heart HT1 - HT3 - HT4
Small intestine SI16 - GB1
Bladder BL54
Kidney KI3 - KI9 - KI10
Pericardium P8
Triple heater GB2 - GB3
Gallbladder ST7 - GB2 - GB39
Liver ST9 - CV2 - LIV3 - LIV10 - LIV11
For those who are well versed at "therapy localization" a
la
AK, these points are very reactive for meridian examination. I am told
by one of the masters I studied with in Western China, that some
masters were known to dowse these points with a small piece of gold,
malachite or jade attached to a leather string.
As you can see by the list of points, they are all, with
the exception
of a few, quite powerful. Try them on your next difficult case. You
have nothing to lose and everything to gain.
John Amaro DC, FIAMA,Dipl.Ac(IAMA),Diplo.Ac.(NCCAOM)
Carefree, Arizona Dr.Amaro@IAMA.edu
Cerebral
Acupuncture (for Neurological Syndromes)
By John Amaro, LAc, Dipl. Ac. (NCCAOM), FIAMA, DC
It would be highly unlikely to find an adult today who
has never heard
of acupuncture, or who could not come up with some kind of definition
of acupuncture. Most people would tell you that acupuncture is an
therapy which is thousands of years old.
Even though this is true, there are a number of
procedures which fall
under the heading of acupuncture which in fact are not ancient: perhaps
the most notable is cerebral acupuncture.
Cerebral
acupuncture,
otherwise known as scalp or skull acupuncture, is a system
which does not utilize acupoints, but specific zones on the head which
have very specific indications.
Generally
credited to an
unnamed "barefoot" doctor in central China, history is now telling us
that cerebral acupuncture was first theorized and applied by Dr. Huang
Xue-Long in 1934. Cerebral acupuncture was resurrected in the early
1970s, coincidentally corresponding with North America's interest in
acupuncture.
A visitor to any hospital,
clinic, institute or
research center in China will see numerous patients receiving this
relatively new procedure. It is the number one treatment for any
neurological syndrome. It is extremely easy to apply and the clinical
results border on the miraculous in many cases.
It is common to
see, especially in the communal clinics of remote China, the patient
male or female, having their head shaved and longer than usual slender
needles being threaded just under the skin of the scalp to stimulate a
particular zone or zones. It has been my observation that the head is
not often shaved for this procedure in the clinics of the larger
cities.
I could write columns every month
for the next year to
simply relate some of the incredible case histories I personally have
encountered with cerebral acupuncture, but it's probably best for you
to create your own success stories as opposed to reading about mine.
On
returning from my first trip to China in 1973, where I first witnessed
cerebral acupuncture, I began to experiment with a variety of different
types of stimulations, as the state I was practicing in did not allow
for puncturing of the skin by DCs. I experimented with everything from
the "teishein" (mechanical stimulation) through electronic stimulation,
and finally to laser. I have concluded that virtually everything works!
The best part of cerebral acupuncture is
that it's a "this for
that" system, meaning "this" zone is specific for "that" problem, and
"that " zone is great for "this" situation. In other words, what you
see is what you get. The equilibrium zone is specific for equilibrium,
whereas the leg and foot zone does just that.
Vasovagal
Chorea
Motor
Sensory
Functional
Vertigo/Hearing
Speech
Thorax
Abdomen
Reproductive
Leg & Foot
Speech
Visual
Equilibrium
The
primary landmark to determine locations is the acupuncture point known
as GV 20 at the extreme top center of the head. Draw an imaginary line
from the very extreme top of the ear to the center of the skull, this
is GV 20. The chorea zone begins less than a human inch anterior to GV
20, whereas the motor zone begins less than a human inch posterior to
this point.
With noninvasive procedures, one
does not have to be
specific as we would with a needle. Therefore the patient or patient's
family can be advised to stimulate these points themselves with a comb,
brush or similar modality.
Perhaps the
most notable and
certainly most utilized zones for a clinical practitioner would be the
sensory and motor zone. Both of these zones are divided into an upper
1/5, a middle 2/5, and a lower 2/5. The sensory zone upper 1/5 is
specific for leg, back, neck and occiput pain, numbness or
paraesthesia. The middle 2/5 is for upper limb involvement; the lower
2/5 is for facial paralysis and paraesthesia, migraine and TMJ
dysfunction. The motor zone upper 1/5 is for the lower extremity; the
middle 2/5 is for the upper extremity, and the lower 2/5 is for
paralysis, loss of and slurring of speech with drooling.
The
motor and sensory can be used for virtually any condition whereby motor
and or sensory symptomatology occurs. The other well used zone is the
chorea zone, which deals with any choreic movement such as tremors,
Parkinson's, Huntington's chorea and similar neurological dysfunctions.
The vertigo and hearing zone is specific for Meniere's syndrome; the
functional zone is specific for the function of the limbs. Visual is
not for nearsightedness, but for neurologically induced visual
disturbance. The same is true of speech (neurologically induced, such
as CVA).
The leg and foot zone is
tremendous for sciatica,
femoral nerve involvement, or any syndrome which affects the leg and or
foot, especially when combined with the motor or sensory zone.
The
rule is to stimulate the opposite side of the involvement, however most
practitioners in China stimulate bilateral. If you are using
stimulation such as a quartz peizo stimulator, I suggest general
stimulation back and forth over the entire zone for approximately 20-30
seconds with a multitude of stimulations. The same is generally true
for electronic stimulation of either micro or macro current. If you are
using teishein, the same general rule applies and with laser, stroking
the light source over the entire zone for about 20 seconds per inch is
a standard rule of treatment.
This chart
should be available in
each treatment room of your office for quick and easy reference. Feel
free to photo copy the accompanying chart or a full color chart is
available through the International Academy of Clinical Acupuncture.
Cerebral
acupuncture is incredibly effective, quick in its application, does not
require invasive procedure, nor requires a background or knowledge of
acupuncture. Therefore I can see no reason whatsoever why the reader of
this article wouldn't add this important work to your arsenal of
procedures immediately. It is truly a significant addition to healing.
________________
"The
Most Important Notes of Acupuncture"
Part I-A
By John Amaro, LAc, Dipl. Ac. (NCCAOM), FIAMA, DC
Yes,
I was really serious about clipping Part I of this column and saving it
for future reference. To make my point perfectly clear, we are
repeating the graphics of the first four meridians, namely LU, LI, ST,
and SP.
For
those of you in North America, you have seen these graphics in the
September 12, 1990 issue of Dynamic Chiropractic. For those in the rest
of the world, this is your first opportunity. Please heed my advice --
clip and save this column. Don't miss an issue of Dynamic Chiropractic.
The information presented in this column alone will undoubtedly,
positively alter the course of thousands of your patients' lives.
What
we are presenting here and throughout this series is the classic
"meridian" pathway as described by the ancients, 5,000 or more years
ago. The graphics presented here are unique in that they also show the
"internal" meridian pathway illustrated by a broken line as well as the
classic pathway shown by a solid line.
Perhaps one of the most
significant rules of acupuncture is: A Meridian Affects What It Is
Named After Or Where It Courses To (or through). It is imperative you
take a few minutes, analyze that last statement, and become more than
familiar with each of the pathways discussed.
To affect a
meridian, one may simply stimulate (non-invasive is fine), the source
point on the meridian which you will find shown in the descriptions.
For example, it is possible to affect an eye condition by stimulating
the source point of the stomach (ST42) as the meridian flows just under
the eye. An inner knee problem could be possibly treated by SP3, as
well as surround the dragon (points on and around the knee).
Sounds
too easy? Sorry! Obviously there are more rules to learn, however,
these will get you started with a significant number of successes.
Do
these "meridians" physically exist? I seriously doubt it. Researchers
have been unsuccessful to physically display the "meridians," however,
they likewise have been unsuccessful in physically producing beta,
gamma, radio, as well as other "waves" known to exist. I personally
feel the mechanism of acupuncture/meridian therapy affects the
electromagnetic flow of the body through the "meridian waves" of the
body. I do not stand alone regarding that thought even though I just
now coined the word "meridian wave." I kind of like it!
________________________
The Most Important Notes of Acupuncture --
Part III
By John Amaro, LAc, Dipl. Ac. (NCCAOM), FIAMA, DC
In
retrospect, we have been presented with eight meridians in Part I and
II of this series and are now ready for four more. If you took my
advice in Part II, you are very familiar with the meridians presented
and in all liklihood have a few success cases under your belt.
If you are typical, there are also a few people you
didn't help at all.
You probably thought you were the only one. Once we finish this series
of articles we will expound on how to minimize your failure cases, but
first things first.
Another
cardinal rule of acupuncture is "Always stimulate scar tissue wherever
you find it." Even if the scar was produced in the sterile environment
of a hospital surgical arena, the meridian flow of magnetic energy may
be disrupted as a radio broadcast signal would be if a large building
or mountain were in the path of the beam. Often times, serious
conditions are the result of simple appearing scars which adversely
affect the meridian flow. I prefer the teishein (non-invasive) pressure
device or he ne laser to stimulate the scar; however, any form will
work.
Also
remember, the chiropractic adjustment is of
paramount importance and is fully utilizing the principles of
acupuncture. It makes no difference if the adjustment is given prior to
acupoint stimulation or after, as long as it is accomplished.
Study
the next four meridians offered here, digest them completely, and begin
using them if you have not done so. Remember, "A farmer never plowed a
field by turning it over in his mind."
The Most
Important Notes of Acupuncture -- Part IV
By John Amaro, LAc, Dipl.
Ac. (NCCAOM), FIAMA, DC
In this final installment of "The Most Important Notes
of Acupuncture,"
take particular note of the two meridians illustrated here, namely the
"conception" and "governing vessel."
These
two meridians have an extremely important significance to acupuncture
and are generally classified as "extra" meridians, even though they
comprise the totality of the meridian system.
Energy
enters the body, according to ancient philosophy, at the CV8 point
(Shrine of God), and leaves the body at death through the same point.
It is of extreme importance especially in any neurologic disorder,
primarily of children, and is considered forbidden to the needle. The
classics of acupuncture suggest filling the navel with salt, covering
the salt with a thin slice of ginger, and burning a moxa cone
(concentrated herbs) over the point. In my experience I find laser
light to have an extremely significant benefit.
In an earlier
article in Dynamic Chiropractic, Feb. 1, 1989, titled "Did D.D. Palmer
Understand Acupuncture?" I discussed the "Mei Hua" system of
acupuncture in which the governing vessel (number seven point located
between T10-11) and a secondary point (between T11-12) are always used
prior to general stimulation of the spinous and transverse processes of
the vertebral level of the involvement in any condition. This system is
generally only used by "masters" and carries with it an extremely high
success rate.
Please
study the notes shared with you concerning
these two most important meridians and generally review all of the
meridians on a weekly basis. We are now ready to begin 1991 with an
academic approach to acupuncture, which will affect your practice in a
positive manner regarding results, patient referrals, and accelerated
healing.
May I
wish you a healthy and joyful 1991.
CV 1 Midway between the anus and the
scrotum or posterior commissure of the vulva. Emergency drowning point
after CPR has failed, mental or spiritual problems.
CV 3 Four human inches below
the umbilicus. Bladder alarm point, muscle and joint problems, also
check ST 3, GB 13, and GB 22.
Palace of the Child: Three human inches bilateral to CV
3. Treat with "Sperm Palace" for infertility.
CV 4 Three human inches below
the umbilicus. Small intestine alarm point.
CV 5 Two human inches below
the umbilicus. Tripple heater alarm point, lower burner.
CV 8 The center of the
umbilicus. "Shrine of God," powerful point for children's disorders.
CV
12 Four human inches above the umbilicus, or between the umbilicus and
the costophrenic angle. Stomach alarm point, middle burner, check every
visit, stimulate if sore.
CV 14 One human inch below the
xiphoid process and six human inches above the umbilicus. Heart alarm
point, heart disease, hiatal hernia.
CV 15 Along the median line, below the xiphoid
process.
CV
17 Level with the 4th intercostal space and midway between the nipples,
two human inches above the xiphoid process. Pericardium alarm point,
anti-smoking point, respiratory problems, upper burner.
CV 22 Middle of the depression
above the suprasternal notch. Main thyroid point.
CV 24 Middle of the
mentolabial sulcus. "Water Ditch," drooling, facial involvement.
GV 1 Between the tip
of the coccyx and the anus.
GV 2 In the middle of the sacral hiatus. Polarity point.
GV 4 Below the spinous
process of the 2nd lumbar vertebra. Adrenal command point, multiple
sclerosis, low back pain.
Sperm
Palace: Three finger breadths bilateral to GV 4. Most effective point
for male or female infertility, treat with "Palace of the Child."
GV
7 Below the spinous process of the 10th thoracic vertebra. MEI HUA,
famous acupuncturist who treated GV 7, then spine at level of
involvement.
GV
14 Between the spinous process of the 7th
cervical vertebra and that of the 1st thoracic vertebra. "Big Bump,"
Five Star Point, connects with many meridians, treat every visit with
ST 12.
GV 16 One
human inch above the middle of the natural
line of the hair at the back of the head, in the depression below the
occipital protuberance. Occipital cephalalgia, memory problems, use
with GB 20 for neck pain and occipital headache, relaxes the body in
general, said to enhance psychic awareness.
GV 20 Five human
inches from the middle of the natural line of the hair at the top of
the head, in line with the ears. BEI HUA "One Hundred Meeting Places"
or "Cure of 100 Diseases," point for hemorrhoids, use caution with
teishin, may cause blackout.
GV 23 One human inch above the middle of the natural line of
the hair on the forehead. Opens closed sinuses immediately.
Yintang
"Seal Palace": Directly in the middle of the forehead, between the
eyebrows. Frontal headache, "Third eye" in psychic awareness.
GV 25 The tip of the nose.
Increase lung vital capacity, sober a drunk (may cause nausea).
GV 26 The tip of the philtrum. Emergency point for
fainting or shock, Chinese use for high fever.
John A. Amaro, D.C.,
F.I.A.C.A., DIPL. AC Carefree, Arizona
_________________________
Edema and Swelling -- What Can Be Done?
By John Amaro, LAc, Dipl. Ac. (NCCAOM), FIAMA, DC
Besides pain and fatigue, I think the condition I see
most often, which
is generally not looked upon as a condition but as a symptom of a much
larger medical entity, is probably edema.
Edema
in and of itself can sometimes be more of a problem for a patient than
the condition which has created it.
Even though most edema is generally seen in the lower
extremities, it also affects every area of the body.
Prescription
diuretics are effective, as are Vitamin C and several other natural
occurring substances, but personally I find nothing quite as effective
as acupuncture in the vast majority of these cases.
Obviously,
there are going to be cases where more heroic measures need to be
taken, but in the lion's share of the cases that we see in a typical
chiropractic setting, the follow points are perhaps one of the most
memorable formulas for this common problem.
KI 16 ... .05
inch bilateral to navel (CV 8) KI 27 ... in small depression just
below lower border of clavicle 2 inches bilateral to CV
KI 2 ... (see diagram) KI 3 ... midway between the medial malleolus
and the tendocalcaneus KI 6 ... one thumb-width below the medical
malleolus *CV 9 ... one thumb-width above the navel (CV 9) *this
point is very important
SP 9 ... in the depression of the lower border of the medical condyle of
the tibia SP 6 ... four fingers breadth above the medial malleolus
on the midline GB 25 ... tip of the 12th rib BL 23 ... 1.5 inch
lateral to the lower border of spinous of second lumbar vertebra
Try stimulating these
points with a quartz-piezo stimulator
or HeNe laser for greatest effect. Acupressure does not even receive
honorable mention.
Incidentally, I saw a
patient lose 18 lbs. of water weight in seven days with this formula.
Let me know of your successes.
John A.
Amaro, DC, FIACA, Dipl.Ac. Carefree, Arizona
Inflammation and Acupuncture
By John Amaro, LAc, Dipl. Ac. (NCCAOM), FIAMA, DC
Perhaps one of the most common conditions which patients
bring to our
doorsteps, is pain associated with an inflammatory process. Even though
inflammation can be virtually anywhere, we as chiropractic
practitioners often see it in the musculoskeletal realm.
Throughout
the course of history, people have known the benefits of a variety of
plants to relieve pain and suffering which upon investigation, have
shown to be anti-inflammatory in nature. One of the most infamous herbs
for pain and inflammation, which plays a major role in one of history's
highlight moments, is known to the Chinese as mo yao, or known to us as
myrrh. I believe you probably know the rest of the story.
Acupuncture,
and I use that word as a philosophy, not as a technique, has also been
used for centuries to control inflammation with startling response. One
of my favorite case histories concerns itself with an elderly lady who
sought care in my office after dealing with a disabling sciatic
condition for months. She had exhausted the usual and customary medical
treatment, which had failed, and now sought alternative treatment. She
had already been under the care of a better than average DC, who she
said aggravated the situation. She now wants to try acupuncture.
During
the examination, she made the comment, "My leg is on fire, if I could
just throw a bucket of water on it, it would be better." This emotional
response was often repeated throughout each treatment which she
received from me. This particular patient received approximately 18
treatments consisting of low force chiropractic and acupuncture,
however her response to treatment was virtually none. Finally, I
understood what she had been saying. It was as if there before me stood
an angel disguised as a patient who was there to teach me a lesson in
life.
In acupuncture, there are a number
of different points
which have very specific characteristics, one may tonify while the
other sedates. There are points of fire, earth, metal, wood, and water.
In what is referred to as the law of five elements, water extinguishes
fire, or as she said: "Doctor, my leg is on fire, if you could just
throw a bucket of water on it I know it will be okay."
The
patient's pain was a combination of sciatic and femoral neuralgia
according the location which was distinctly down the back of the leg
and radiating into the side of the leg. Realizing the gallbladder and
bladder meridian corresponded exactly where the pain and paraesthesia
was located, I selected the water point of each of these two meridians.
Electronically stimulating GB43 and BL66 bilaterally as an adjunct to
her treatment, I was shocked when she exclaimed to the entire office
that her pain had vanished. If this makes no sense to you, then welcome
to the world of acupuncture.
I personally
had given her close
to 20 treatments, not counting the four or five orthopedic, neurologist
and chiropractors she had seen previously. Now in one instant, her pain
was not just diminished, but gone. She followed up on my advice with
several more treatments, however, she really didn't need anything as
far as the pain was concerned. She now comes in once a year for a
routine treatment, and refers scores of patients. I am convinced she
was really an "angel," as I relate this case history to the entire
chiropractic profession worldwide.
Learning
from this
experience, we should be aware of the water points of each of the
meridians. If you do not have a background in clinical acupuncture,
than get one. If it's been forever that you glanced through your notes,
refamiliarize yourself with the meridian pathways. Understand that a
meridian affects what it is named after or where it courses through.
Really
confused about how to use these? Suffice it to say that anytime anyone
has any inflammatory condition in the body, these points are paramount.
If you see a patient with inflammation (fire) in the shoulder use the
water points of the upper extremity. The same logic would be true of
the lower extremity. The best part is, if you really don't know which
point to use, use a combination of all of the water points as a general
treatment. This should only be used however with electrical stimulation
and not with a needle. Why? If you really don't know what point to use,
you have no business using a needle!! Electrical stimulation will not
cause extreme disruption to occur by driving perverse energies deeper
in the body.
In essence, the water points
are dynamic, powerful
points to relieve inflammation anywhere in the body. They are perhaps
best used with simple electronic stimulation, rather than needles by
the nonexpert. The water points are quick, easy, and incredibly
effective. They are all located at the elbow, inside of the knee or the
point right next to the tsing point (fingertip). Disregard the he-sea
points on this graphic. We will discuss them at another time. In the
meantime, begin using the water points often throughout your practice
day, they are truly dynamic.
The Treatment
of Chronic Pain
By John Amaro, LAc, Dipl. Ac. (NCCAOM), FIAMA, DC
The American public has been emotionally and
physically traumatized
due to announcements by the FDA concerning the devastating health
effects discovered in a number of prescription pain medications,
including of the COX-2 inhibitors - some of the most popular pain drugs
on the market.
With Vioxx, Bextra, Celebrex, Aleve and Naprosyn being
named in
specific consumer health advisories, and warnings to medical physicians
to "stop prescribing," millions of Americans who have relied heavily on
these drugs to ease their pain and positively impact their lifestyle
are now wondering what their future holds, where they can go, and what
they can do to ease their chronic pain.
Acupuncture is
without question one of the most
powerful pain-altering modalities in the world. Its reputation for pain
relief is known and respected internationally. It may be practiced
successfully with a variety of procedures other than needles, including
lasers, electronic and noninvasive stimulation devices for those who
are needle-phobic and would not consider acupuncture otherwise.
Literally millions of Americans suffering chronic pain
are beginning to
seek the care of those knowledgeable in the academics and techniques of
acupuncture, to help ease their pain and lessen their dependency on
dangerous and cautioned prescription drugs.
There are a variety
of techniques, procedures, acupoints and philosophies surrounding
acupuncture and pain relief worldwide. As a practitioner whose clinic
has seen in excess of 100 patients a day, five days a week, I have had
the opportunity to attend to a number of patients suffering from a host
of maladies. Chronic pain, however, may be the most common occurrence
seen in a practitioner's office. Historically, our clinic has averaged
a 94 percent success rate of "cure" to "major clinical response" with
chronic pain, based on the patient's response index. Only 3 percent of
all pain patients have reported less than satisfactory response in 34
years of practice. It is obvious that the acupoints for pain are
extremely effective.
The acupoints
illustrated throughout this article
are without question some of my favorite for the successful treatment
of chronic pain. This list does not constitute the totality of
effective points available to us as practitioners. There are many more
effective points not listed here; however, the illustrations are my
personal favorite points that have elicited incredible clinical success
in chronic pain. Many points illustrated in this paper will be
instantly recognized, while others will make little sense. Regardless,
please use them, even though space does not allow for a detailed
explanation of each point.
Most of these
points have been taught to me by some
of the great masters of acupuncture in a variety of Asian nations. To
say that combination of acupoints is effective for chronic pain would
be an understatement. All illustrated points do not need to be
stimulated on the same day if only needles are used. Utilizing a
combination of both laser/electronic stimulation and needle on the
points is also extremely effective. Otherwise, all points may be
stimulated for 12-15 seconds with either a green 535nm, 5mw laser or a
red 635nm, 5mw laser. Microcurrent electronic stimulation is also quite
effective as a stand-alone treatment.
Best wishes for
your successful treatment of severe
and unrelenting pain syndromes. I would also like to hear of your
successes.
Click here for more information about John Amaro, LAc,
Dipl. Ac. (NCCAOM), FIAMA, DC.
The Eight (Hui) Influential Points
By John Amaro, LAc, Dipl. Ac. (NCCAOM), FIAMA, DC
Some of the most "influential points" on the body are
named
accordingly. These particular acupuncture points exert a profound
effect on the functioning of the body. Each of them has a specific
systemic effect on a particular tissue, body area or organ system.
Because
illness may generally assert an effect on multiple sites in the body,
the influential points have a practical effect by eliminating
superfluous needle stimulation and focusing the treatment on as few
points as possible. A classic example would be the influential point GB
34 (just in front of the tibial tuberosity). This point is the classic
point for any symptomatology affecting the "sinews." The stimulation of
GB 34 has a positive effect on any symptoms dealing
with muscles, ligaments or tendons.
Regardless
of
the location of the musculoskeletal condition, GB 34 will have a
positive effect. Whether a person is suffering with rotator cuff
syndrome or epicondylitis, the influential point for the "sinews" will
have a particular effect, even though it is far removed from the site
of discomfort. However, most practitioners will, in addition to GB 34,
stimulate local points in the area of pain.
GB 39
is the "influential point of marrow" and is located just above the
external malleolus. Marrow is generally referred to as assisting brain
function or bone marrow itself. In traditional Chinese medicine (TCM)
bone marrow does not have a relationship to blood formation as it does
in Western physiology. The point is not typically used for blood
disorders as one might think.
GB 39 has a
particular effect on
both sciatic neuritis and cervicalgia, as it is a specific point
linking the yang meridians of the lower extremity, namely the
gallbladder, stomach and bladder. Remember, a meridian affects what it
is named after and where it courses. This point has also been used for
vertigo and brain dysfunction.
LU 9
is the
"influential point of the vessels," a point often used to help make the
pulse more prominent in those with fine and weak pulses. This point is
used in when using pulse diagnosis and has been used in cardiovascular
disease. Its ancient claim to fame is for conditions affecting the
pulse.
BL 11 is known as
the "influential
point of bone." This point is two fingers breadth bilateral to C7-T1.
It is probably one of the most controversial points on the body: in
part because of its effect on bone, but primarily due to its effect
with pathogenic wind. When a patient complains of bone symptomatology
due to an attack of pathogenic wind, as in "bi-patterns," this point
has a particularly high effect rate. Additional points (BL 12, GB 21,
TH 15) have very similar effects.
BL
17 is
known as the "influential point of blood." The point is two fingers
breadth bilateral to T5-6. This is one of the classic points and deals
with blood stasis. In classical osteopathy, this acupoint deals with
any condition involving blood. "The rule of the artery is supreme,"
said Andrew Taylor Still. Anytime pain is a factor, blood will be
involved. Think of this point as one of the most important points on
the body.
CV 17 (ren mai)
is known as the
"influential point of chi." Known as the mu/alarm point for the
pericardium/circulation/sex meridian, it is particularly related to the
lungs. Located two inches above the xiphoid process, it is often used
for conditions affecting the lungs and heart. This point has numerous
applications, as it is also the fourth chakra; it also has hormonal
effects, due to its relationship to the pericardium meridian.
CV 12
(ren mai) is known as the "influential point of the bowels." Located
halfway between the umbilicus and the xiphoid process, this point is
the alarm point for the stomach. It is perhaps one of the most
significant points on the body for any stomach or bowel symptomatology.
It has an effect on the spleen meridian.
Liv
13
is the "influential point of the viscera," located at the tip of the
11th rib. This point is known as the alarm point of the spleen. It is
one of the premier points on the body, affecting visceral
symptomatolgy. This point, when used with BL 38 (on the vertebral
border of the scapula halfway between the top and bottom), is legendary
for patients with visceral complaints, regardless of its origin. The
relationship of the spleen meridians to the extraordinary meridians is
one of the most important relationships in the body. This point is
critical.
GB 34 is the "influential point
of the sinews,"
located just in front of the tibial tuberosity. This is one of the
classic points on the body for any condition affecting muscles,
ligaments and tendons. It has been used for thousands of years in every
Asian nation.
The eight points presented
here are extremely
powerful. You will find these points an incredible addition to a
clinical practice. Strong caution is urged when using needle
stimulation, as some of these points are in sensitive and potentially
dangerous areas. Remember: Acupuncture is a principle, not a technique.
Therefore, many techniques can be safely used, including laser and
electronic stimulation.
Best wishes for your
successful use of the principles of acupuncture in the "Year of the
Dragon."
"What Points Do
You Use For ________?"
By John Amaro, LAc, Dipl. Ac. (NCCAOM), FIAMA, DC
Without hesitation, the number-one question posed to me
by doctors
interested in the application of acupuncture is simply, "What points do
you use for ________?"
This
simplified approach to what many practitioners feel is the practice of
acupuncture is in reality a far cry from proper applications that deal
with a host of theoretical and procedural processes both ancient and
modern.
Even
though this article will be read by doctors around the world, I speak
especially to my American brethren who, having been born Americans,
feel we have the birthright to change ancient acupuncture traditions.
It appears this is quickly becoming a global trend. Some seek to make
acupuncture easier and less complicated, sometimes disregarding the
hows, whys and historical significance of acupuncture.
Many
health care practitioners who "dabble" with acupuncture through simple
stimulation of patterns of acupuncture points often find themselves
frustrated when they achieve outstanding results on some patients, but
no response on others. This is usually attributed to the fact that many
practitioners commonly use cookbook approaches. Even though they are
acceptable, they are not specific for the individual patient.
The
practitioner must understand the reasoning behind the specific points
on the meridian system and how and why they are used in a clinical
practice, as opposed to the simple, "What points do you use for
________?" To practice proper acupuncture, the medical/chiropractic
professional needs an understanding of the principles of acupuncture,
along with scientific correspondences and knowledge of special reflex
areas that are essential to its successful practice.
Acupuncture
does not have to involve the myriad of myth, shamanism and folklore
that abounds in many of the ancient principles of traditional Chinese
medicine (TCM). TCM is just one method of a large multinational system
which includes Japan, Korea, Taiwan, southeast Asia and Malaysia, not
to mention every country in Europe which has used acupuncture
extensively for centuries. European applications have demystified many
of acupuncture's explanations that are more compatible with Western
scientific thought.
Still, practitioners
will continue to ask, "What points are good for ________?" In The
Science of Acupuncture Therapy,
Richard Cheng,MD,PhD, discusses many of these orthopedic/neurologic
basic points and formulas. These points have been found to be effective
in the majority of cases based on neurologic explanations, rather than
the TCM explanations.
Dr. Cheng, a
personal friend of mine and
faculty member of the International Academy of Medical Acupuncture, is
a neurophysiologist who is internationally recognized researcher. He
was one of the principal researchers in the discovery of endorphins and
enkephalins at the University of Toronto. His work has been published
in numerous prestigious scientific journals that earned him the first
PhD in acupuncture research in North America. Following are specific
points Dr. Cheng's neurologic research has shown to be extremely
effective in pain control.
The points will
only be listed by
number. (Dr. Cheng's book is illustrated). Should you not know the
location of these powerful points, bring out your acupuncture chart or
mannequin and begin your review. I have personally used these important
points for years. The following represent just a few from the book.
Neuralgic Headaches
GV 15; TW 17; ST 4; GB 1; GB 14; ST 7; LI 20; BL 2; BL
9
Acupuncture Points for
Neck Pain
GV 16; GV 15; GV 14; BL 10; BL 11; GB 20; GB
21; SI 15; SI 17; ST 9
Sciatica
GB 30; BL 54 (UB 40)
Elbow Pain
LI
11; LI 10; P 3; SI 8
Wrist Pain
TH 4; LI 5
Hip
Pain
SP 12; BL 49; BL
48; GB 31; LIV 11
Knee
Disorders
SP 9; SP 10; GB
34; LIV 7; GB 33; ST 35; knee eye; ST 32; BL 53; KI 10
Ankle Pain
KE 3; BL 60; ST 41
Dr. Cheng lists the following as the 11 master/major points
that should be learned in detail:
LI
4; HT 7; LI 11; GB 20; P 6; TW 5; GV 26; ST 36; SP 6; SP 10; Shen Men
(ear)
As
the practice of acupuncture has now become firmly established in North
America, it is important that the chiropractic physician becomes more
acutely aware of the nature of acupuncture and not rely on simple
formulae. Even though many formulae and powerful points remain an
important part of even traditional acupuncture, being able to devise a
treatment approach based on the individual patient is what will set you
apart from the mediocre practitioner.